Got a one way or the other SC dilemma? You’ve come to the right place.
Put your question to the masses and answer others using the T.U and T.D function.
2
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Table For Two – Round 4
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Thomson Dow for Dylan Stephens if he’s dropped
TU Yes
TD No
Who to trade out for Nic Martin this week
TU: Brady Hough
TD: Josh Ward
Ward will be a slow burn but I’d opt to keep him over Hough. Higher ceiling, higher CBAs (I’m pretty certain Hough didn’t attend one last round), and his JS is far, far more solid.
Sure you might make a bigger buck by trading Ward this round, but I’m sure you’ll make more from Ward if you hold on.
You are correct Budwa, Hough didn’t attend any CBA’s whilst Ward had the highest attendance at Hawthorn with 19.
Treloar Vs Heeney – Both have pro’s & cons.
TU: Treloar
TD: Heeney
Jelly for Crippa?
Jelly had been solid till last weekend, but only way I can get Cripps is through this premo trade.
TU Yes
TD No
Clearing up my wording!! Jelly –> Crippa
Out of interest, are you:
TU – Making trades this week
TD- Not making trades this week
Trade out for Nic Martin
TU Jack Hayes
TD Josh Ward
Gidday BDM
Martin is a must. I traded Ward to Rowell last week as it was the only option with my rookies. Ward will do well over the coming rds.
Hayes may get dropped this week but will come back as Ryder will get injuried [again] or managed & Hayes has a good cash generation.
Depending on what rookies you have playing then Hayes goes.
Good luck.
Yep agreed WG&S, I’ve got all playing rookies so I’m happy with that part but not having Martin from the start was a miss. Given Stephens not named, perhaps makes it easier but have a feeling Hayes might be dropped or have a much lower ceiling now with 3 talls in the team so got tonight to think about it haha.
Soligo for…
TU: J. Mead
TD: T. dow
Comment: save the trade and keep as C loophole
Soligo has been frustrating for me as he gets named as an emergency and so becomes a sub risk. Make it hard use him as a loop.
Start this week
TU:Play C.Curnow
TD:Play N.Martin
Marshall to English
TU: Do it!
TD: Hold fire
Cheers guys
Rowell > Cripps/Green?
Only way I can get him into my side
TU – Fade Cripps/Green completely
TD – Make it happen
Gidday K,
TU for me. Rowell could ave the same as the other 2 over the yr & finish as your M8.
Save the trade
Cheers mate, I’ve run Cripps over the past 2 years and burned me all the time. Now the one time I dont own him, he goes ballistic. Gotta love SC
Who to cull for Martin now that Dylan is dropped.
TU: Comben
TD: Stephens and get a fwd/mid loop set up
Johnno…
How do I take Stephens out as a mid…in SC…and replace him with Martin a forward?
Neither be DPP!
Have seen a similar suggestion with Hawk Ward and also no DPP…
What am I overlooking here?
Sorry for not seeing this earlier. You trade out Stephens and then swap a fwd/mid into the midfield which leaves a space for Martin to then come in
TU: Cripps (proven history)
TD: Green (Clarry/Rowell production line?)
T/U: Rachele
T/D: Naish