If English is out do you put in Gawn or move Andrews across from the bench and get a premo mid-fielder.
T/U Gawn is a must have now
T/D save a few $$ and get a mid-fielder.
I’m in the same predicament and I feel like the best play if possible is to get mcandrew to your flex, Gawn seems like he will torch you if you don’t have him, but ideally you don’t want mcandrew sitting on your bench. If you can’t get him to flex however, I would consider just chucking him at R2 and banking the cash for other upgrades
With Whitfield (and Ash), at least we know their role every week
McKercher loves racking up the stats, but there is no guarantee that he will play the half back role every week – which is where he clearly scores the best
Currently have Gawn at R1. Is it still viable to go back and run Lmac at R2?
Need to trade English but don’t love any of the options. Grundy would be my favourite but not sure I want to pay up if I can just grab another premium from any line.
If Grundy is going to play like this all year then I think you just get him no matter what. I’m waiting for DPP likely hood to show up somewhere before I decide what to do about English. I’ve got Gawn at flex and Jackson at R1. English is my r2 and Macca pure bench. At a minimum now Macca goes to r2 but I’m for sure thinking about English for Grundy….
I like Jackson..at his price i take the 120+ every week. For me, have 2 premium rucks takes away alot of stress…Gawn, English Xerri and Jackson…120+ every week
Coming off the byes, no longer best 18, feel like the fwd line is looking a little weak.
Break even of 49 with ESS, RICH & WCE to come in the next 5 weeks. Feel like it’s now or pay up later on.
Has been a full time mid basically for the dees across the last couple of weeks and we can only assume the role will stick with how good he has been playing.
Won me 13/14 league games in the last two weeks when it feels everyone had Xerri/Grundy as c! Great POD at the moment. Don’t know if it keeps going but geez I hope it does 🙂
As per Derek’s point, he’s already expensive and has a history of spike scores followed by quiet periods. As a demons fan, I also know, on a very personal level, he loves to get suspended.
The fact he’s already expensive and has a history of suspension and uneven scoring makes me think I’d rather wait and see more and pay full price for him later once hes a sure thing, than burn a trade and get him for 70-80k less and potentially regret it.
in a year when forward premiums are hard to find, he might be an option and might well end the season as a top 6 forward. but like on all other lines, we wait for them to become cheaper before getting them. I’m watching Darcy’s price fall
Windsor/English -> Farrow/Jackson. Thoughts and feelings? 145k in the bank, can swing McAndrew into R2 and grab someone different or cover English injury if it’s just a week or two, but already have Bont/Gawn/Butters
I have Windsor does he get one last chance against the bombers he attended 3rd most centre bounce for mids. The 3 top mids for the dogs against the bombers all went 115+
Normally you do side ways trade premiums however what do you do with daicos?
Are you worried about his injury being a hindrance
T.u – keep him
T.d – trade him
i watched him closely this week (because he was in my team) and he was always around the ball, but never in a position to receive it, team mates wouldn’t even look at him and kicked it over his head.
his 7 this weeks puts a full stop on his cash generation, and thats the only reason i brought him in, he now has to go for either Farrow or Shoenburg
I’m going to need 50 trades at this rate.
Can I suggest a thread for “Rate my Team” for suggestions from coaches on what needs to be done to fix teams like mine that have gone off the rails with injured players and underperforming
Mid pricers.
B/E is -5 and projected price rise is about $31k. Earliest I’d cash in would be after the upcoming round and even then, I’d only consider it if he scored poorly.
Another week, another round of injury trades. This week it’s English and Richards.
I can’t ignore Gawn anymore, he’s going to be top 3 SC player barring injury, and GWS has a friendly draw over the next few weeks so Whitfield in for Richards via DPP.
Awaiting team selection for a potential third. Although my cows still have more fattening and I’ve often gone early in previous seasons then run out of trades so trying to show restraint this year!
Torn on which way to go with English.
Already have Gawn R1 and could possibly run Lmac R2. The only other ruckman that interests me currently is Grundy.
TU: Grab Grundy and lock in the big rucks.
(Will also need to downgrade budarick to fund this)
TD: Play the value game and target someone like a Whitfield off their bye.
(Can keep Budarick and downgrade someone like a Watkins)
I’m also looking ahead to next week with Petracca possibly back. Budarick can still make money this round with a BE 45 but that may be it so I’m looking at somehow funding Budarick to Trac next week
Warning too all I’ve just brought in Gawn , Bont , and Coleman so if my form keeps up this year they will all get hurt , pull out last min , or get reported , just a heads up !!
I have English and Richards
T/U: Gawn and N. Daicos with 300k in the bank
T/D: Jackson and Whitfield with 480k in the bank
Keep in mind I will want to do Buderick to trac next week. Jordy clark, mccluggae, anderson, rankine will all be heavy discounted in a few weeks time. Nic newman looked pretty good on return too at a cheap price
Out Lindsay, English and Carroll, sit Richard’s on the bench until he returns.
In Farrow, Whitfield and Callaghan…
Or
Out Lindsay, English and Richard’s.
In Coleman, Callaghan and Grundy….
Farrow because has Def/Mid DPP. Meaning he can replace anyone in defence or midfield while also giving a swing set with Grij (if possible).
Steene can only replace either forward of Ruck, and at the moment we don’t have many that need trading out. If he sits at R3, that will need another trade to cash him out once he is fattened up (ie trade in another R3).
Farrow looks the better trade for structure, unless you have a forward or ruck that needs trading out.
Fellow holder here and been saying that for the last 3 weeks as he sits on 290k churning out 60s… he will probably finally go big just as I trade him out so not convinced you can win either way on this one…… do whatever works best for your structure imo
Hey guys
i’ve already traded in bont for 700k last week. I have a lot of cash in the bank can get anybody i want, and obviously gawn is the main man but i don’t know if i can justify spending 700k on players two weeks in a row when upgrade season hasn’t even started properly.
english to gawn is the play everybody else is doing but would it be smarter to trade english to jackson/grundy/sweet.
TU: jackson/grundy or sweet
TD: Gawn
either way i’ll have money in the bank for next week
Decided I’m holding Windsor as he plays Essendon (not that I trust him I just want to keep the trade)
Trading English for Steene and putting mcandrew R2, and keeping cash to upgrade Watkins to anyone I want via DPP.
Tu – good play
Td- can’t miss out on Gawn
I need some advice please.
My backline is
Sinclair,Worrell,Robert’s,Windsor,Jaques, Serong. {Selwood,Lindsay) 304,900 ITB
Need to get rid of Windsor but not sure for who.
Thumbs up::upgrade him to Short
Thumbs Down: down grade to Farrow
Comment: Other
Not sure where to go with Reid as I don’t have crazy cash, open to other options below 442k
TU: Tim Kelly
TD: Rachele
Also considering Coleman, CMac, Milera, Newman, Bice. So many options but none are really sticking out. Could also just hold and try to upgrade next week.
I suppose most supercoachites are in the same situation as me with injuries and suspension. Traded out include..Rozee, Gulden, Young, Petracca, Xerri, English with Marshall and Murdock injured..Still unsure with English trade as no period has been given for his injury…if we could have clarity I may reverse trade..have the Dogs given us a hint of length of his absence????
Have English, but obviously want to trade for gawn. But was wondering is it worth considering jordan sweet. Cheap, and port have a easy draw. Any advice…
T/U: English and Parish to Farrow and Grundy
T/D: English, Parish and Watkins to Grundy, Farrow and Oscar Steene?
Or comment. I have also thought about moving Lmac to R2 and just making the 2 trades of Farrow and Steene for Parish and Watkins and get Grundy the following week after the GCS game?
This fixes my team structure, but does mean I won’t have Gawn/Grundy yet and McAndrew will be at r2…
English > Kozzie Pickett
Phillipou > Coleman
Watkins > Farrow
TU: yes
TD: no, find a way to get Gawn/Grundy in immediately
Blamires was on the wing last week. His time in defence has been taken by McKercher. This will limit his scoring, depending on which side of the ground the ball is on.
I think Lindsay against Essendon is more likely to be a good score
What would you do ?? sitting 486
TU English,Carroll, Phillipou to Z Bailey, McInerney Steene 30K over
TU English, Carroll, Sellwood to Grundy, Steene, Farrow… 156K over upgrade next week
Thanks……
Looking to get Farrow, obviously wait and see teams but if neither are dropped, who do I trade out of;
TU: Windsor
TD: Watkins
to get him in? On-field team probably slightly better with Windsor still in but over 100k more if he is traded.
Do I trade Gawn in for English even though he’s full price? He’s in flex currently.
I’ve held Xerri and have Jackson in R1, McAndrew in R2.
So it means I’ll need to downgrade McAndrew when Xerri is back, probably leaving cash gen on the table.
Or am I better off trading English to a Steele or Holmes type and reduce the amount of rucks I have.
TU: get Gawn with his next few games looking juicy, sort out the rest later
TD: get someone else, don’t need 4 rucks and look for value instead
Similar to above actually, but I’m looking at tossing Windsor
TU : Trade out one of Carroll/Watkins and hold Windsor for now
TD : Trade out Windsor instead. Doing this means one more rookie on field though.
Groan. What to do with Richards?
Seems like he may only miss a week but I’m already holding Xerri.
It’s one of those ones where you hold him and he misses 4wks or you trade him and he goes over 140 for the next 6wks in a row isn’t it…
Got Bear Grlj as cover who got a 90 last time around so the hold is tempting.
Dumb game.
I am looking at that trade for next week.
NAS’ break-even is 119, so he should hold his price (or go down by about 10k).
Windsor’s B/E is 51 (62 average), so unless he has a disaster day, his price won’t go down.
I really want to use a boost to sideways trade Ed Richards to Nick Daicos, I can’t afford Marcus Bontempelli. Now that Ed is named to play, should I do it?
T/U – Do it! Nick will be top eight midfielder by the end of the season and Ed won’t.
T/D – Don’t do it! Sideways trades break the rules of supercoach, you’ll regret it.
Yeah I think Whit mate, you know he’s most likely going to be a top 6 if not top 3-4 defender.
Assuming you already have Gawn, so wait and give yourself some time to pick who the next best ruck will be while McAndrew is doing well. You’re paying almost top dollar for Grundy too. The extra 114k or so will come in very handy.
Currently thinking:
English, Budarick and Watkins/Sellwood to Gawn, Farrow and Steene. Any thoughts?
Watkins n English to Gawn and Farrow? save a boost? :O
Ideally that’s the move. I’m short 93k tho
If English is out do you put in Gawn or move Andrews across from the bench and get a premo mid-fielder.
T/U Gawn is a must have now
T/D save a few $$ and get a mid-fielder.
I’m in the same predicament and I feel like the best play if possible is to get mcandrew to your flex, Gawn seems like he will torch you if you don’t have him, but ideally you don’t want mcandrew sitting on your bench. If you can’t get him to flex however, I would consider just chucking him at R2 and banking the cash for other upgrades
TU: Whitfield
TD: McKercher
at half time last week i would have said McKercher
With Whitfield (and Ash), at least we know their role every week
McKercher loves racking up the stats, but there is no guarantee that he will play the half back role every week – which is where he clearly scores the best
Currently have Gawn at R1. Is it still viable to go back and run Lmac at R2?
Need to trade English but don’t love any of the options. Grundy would be my favourite but not sure I want to pay up if I can just grab another premium from any line.
TU: Lmac at R2 is fine
TD: Run 2 premium rucks
If Grundy is going to play like this all year then I think you just get him no matter what. I’m waiting for DPP likely hood to show up somewhere before I decide what to do about English. I’ve got Gawn at flex and Jackson at R1. English is my r2 and Macca pure bench. At a minimum now Macca goes to r2 but I’m for sure thinking about English for Grundy….
I like Jackson..at his price i take the 120+ every week. For me, have 2 premium rucks takes away alot of stress…Gawn, English Xerri and Jackson…120+ every week
Have to trade English out.
TU Gawn
TD Grundy
Comment anyone else
just look at Gawn’s next 5 games, Grundy might be a bit harder
Man wtf do I do with Tom McCarthy?
TU: hold. He will come right
TD: trade to a reliable D6
I am trading McCarthy to Coleman and banking $150k for future upgrades.
I picked McCarthy on the basis that he would get midfield minutes which he is not getting.
He is losing $’s so getting him out in preference to Windsor
Got McAndrew stuck at R3.
Is it worth trading a non-playing Rookie like Sharp or Dovaston to Steene, so I can start McAndrew in the flex position.
Alternately I have Luke Jackson at R2, is he likely to receive forward line eligibility, and if so when would that happen?
the mid-price experiment is over.
Out Windsor and Buderick and in comes Steene and Whitfield
Coleman?
Another mid pricer that will burn or do you think he’s a good get?
Tu – good get
Td – trap
Already doing English>Gawn + Windsor>Farrw
– Is it worth boosting to trade Parish > Steene via DPP (Cook)
TU: boost for Steene
TD: hold boost, pass on Steene
Kozzie Pickett anyone? $518k
Coming off the byes, no longer best 18, feel like the fwd line is looking a little weak.
Break even of 49 with ESS, RICH & WCE to come in the next 5 weeks. Feel like it’s now or pay up later on.
Has been a full time mid basically for the dees across the last couple of weeks and we can only assume the role will stick with how good he has been playing.
TU/TD
$518k seems alot for Pickett
Won me 13/14 league games in the last two weeks when it feels everyone had Xerri/Grundy as c! Great POD at the moment. Don’t know if it keeps going but geez I hope it does 🙂
As per Derek’s point, he’s already expensive and has a history of spike scores followed by quiet periods. As a demons fan, I also know, on a very personal level, he loves to get suspended.
The fact he’s already expensive and has a history of suspension and uneven scoring makes me think I’d rather wait and see more and pay full price for him later once hes a sure thing, than burn a trade and get him for 70-80k less and potentially regret it.
in a year when forward premiums are hard to find, he might be an option and might well end the season as a top 6 forward. but like on all other lines, we wait for them to become cheaper before getting them. I’m watching Darcy’s price fall
Windsor/English -> Farrow/Jackson. Thoughts and feelings? 145k in the bank, can swing McAndrew into R2 and grab someone different or cover English injury if it’s just a week or two, but already have Bont/Gawn/Butters
I have Windsor does he get one last chance against the bombers he attended 3rd most centre bounce for mids. The 3 top mids for the dogs against the bombers all went 115+
Who is more of a trade
T/U Windsor
T/D parish
Normally you do side ways trade premiums however what do you do with daicos?
Are you worried about his injury being a hindrance
T.u – keep him
T.d – trade him
TU: English & Budarick > Grundy & Pickett
TD: English & Lombard > Whitfield & Pickett
(2nd option leaves me with Lmac R2)
Looking for help. Team is starting to take shape.
Def – Sinclair, Stewart, Worrell, Short, Coleman, Serong (Jacques, Sellwood)
Mid – Daicos, Butters, Anderson, Dawson, K.Pickett, Bruhn, Smith, Grlj (Blarmires, Carroll, Sharp)
Ruck – Gawn, Jackson (Steene)
Fwd – Sheezel, Flanders, Lukosius, Cook, Robertson, Marshall (Phillipou, Dovaston)
Flex – McAndrew
Used 1 trade from round 5 to trade Windsor to Steene, which will allow me to field McAndrew.
May use a 2nd trade if Murdoch is playing.
Is there another Rookie I should be looking at?
Help appreciated
Farrow could be a shout
*Insert Homer Simpson Why Doesnt Mine Look Like That? meme
would not change a thing, gun side and can save trades…golden rule..dont trade if you dont have to
TU – Farrow
TD – Steene
Both
Is Harley Reid a sell? 42 is gonna hurt cash gen for a few weeks
Does Watkins have any more cash in him?
I would say yes as he has a break even of only 33, and Watkins has shown that he score on his day
But unfortunately there is a decent chance that Watkins get dropped this week 🙁
Not the way he played this week. He was invisible to his team mates.
I just got him this week, bow he has to go
Derek
I think with Wines back you’re right out he goes
PS appreciate your great analysis on this site
i watched him closely this week (because he was in my team) and he was always around the ball, but never in a position to receive it, team mates wouldn’t even look at him and kicked it over his head.
his 7 this weeks puts a full stop on his cash generation, and thats the only reason i brought him in, he now has to go for either Farrow or Shoenburg
Windsor replacement
TU: mid pricer such as Coleman or Trainor
TD: Farrow
TU: Coleman
TD: Trainor
Is it worth trading Windsor to Coleman or just go down to farrow
Tu – Coleman
Td – Farrow
Who to trade English to
Tu – Gawn
Td – Jackson
Reply – someone else
Hold richards
TU: Hold
TD: Sell
I’m waiting for a timeline. 1-2 weeks will probably hold, 3+ gotta go.
TU: Richards and Windsor out for Gawn Farrow
TD: Save the trades
T/U – Budarick and English to Farrow and Grundy
T/D – Watkins and English to Farrow and Luke Jackson
Worth a boost to get Kalani White to Steene at R3?
T/u – Yes, boost for cash gen
T/d – not worth it
I’m going to need 50 trades at this rate.
Can I suggest a thread for “Rate my Team” for suggestions from coaches on what needs to be done to fix teams like mine that have gone off the rails with injured players and underperforming
Mid pricers.
I think I’m going
English to Gawn
Don’t know whether to go Watkins to Farrow
Or cash in on Blamires for Farrow
What are we thinking
Hold Blamires, still plenty of cash to make.
This.
B/E is -5 and projected price rise is about $31k. Earliest I’d cash in would be after the upcoming round and even then, I’d only consider it if he scored poorly.
I might have to go Watkins to Farrow then
Is Parish or Widsor to Coleman too sideways ???
Tu Yes…waste of a trade
Td Mad if you dont
I see Coleman as a potential keeper.
He has the role, he has got himself back into full swing after missing a year.
i see coleman as a keeper…get him
Team at the moment (before trades)
DEF: Sinclair, McCarthy, Windsor, Grlj, Jacques, Serong (Lindsay, ZZ)
Mid: Bont, Naicos, Butters, Walsh, Bruhn, Smith, Cook, Blamires (Watkins, Carroll, Macrae)
Ruck: Jackson, English (Xerri)
FWD: Sheezel, Rankine, Flanders, Lalor, Dev Rob, Lombard (Pou, Marshall)
Flex: McAndrew
55k itb, 4 boosts left
Do I fade max gawn given I have glaring holes elsewhere? Or sideways trade English?
Look at Gawn’s next 5 weeks. Grundy will be tough but the others he’s going to destroy
Although I did just notice you have Xerri R3 so that is a tough decision as LMac still has money to make and is scoring pretty well
I don’t think you’re looking too bad outside of the ruck situation, if I’m being honest.
What other trades were you thinking of doing?
Given Xerri is just 2 weeks away I would trade English, swing McAndrew to R2 (for 2 weeks).
I think focus on upgrading in defence.
Who comes in for Blakiston?
TU: Whitfield, fallen premo
TD: Ash, $50k more expensive, 120 BE, but possibly better scoring potential?
Comment: J.Daicos or Zorko
TU: Jaicos
TD: Zorko (Too old?)
Another week, another round of injury trades. This week it’s English and Richards.
I can’t ignore Gawn anymore, he’s going to be top 3 SC player barring injury, and GWS has a friendly draw over the next few weeks so Whitfield in for Richards via DPP.
Awaiting team selection for a potential third. Although my cows still have more fattening and I’ve often gone early in previous seasons then run out of trades so trying to show restraint this year!
Been near impossible to a kid them with injuries , reports , doing well if not using both every week
Torn on which way to go with English.
Already have Gawn R1 and could possibly run Lmac R2. The only other ruckman that interests me currently is Grundy.
TU: Grab Grundy and lock in the big rucks.
(Will also need to downgrade budarick to fund this)
TD: Play the value game and target someone like a Whitfield off their bye.
(Can keep Budarick and downgrade someone like a Watkins)
I’m also looking ahead to next week with Petracca possibly back. Budarick can still make money this round with a BE 45 but that may be it so I’m looking at somehow funding Budarick to Trac next week
34 trades left
Trade out: Richards english sellwood
Trade in : Whitfield gawn farrow
31 trades left
Tu good trades
Td need to save trades
Warning too all I’ve just brought in Gawn , Bont , and Coleman so if my form keeps up this year they will all get hurt , pull out last min , or get reported , just a heads up !!
Any remote chance you can dump Gawn and Bont??
Trading out
English, selwood, Watkins
Trade in
Grundy, farrow, Steele
T.u – good moves
T.d – dont do it
Only thing I can say is please don’t take Steele. I’ve been enjoying him as a POD
Johnno
Wrong Steele (i’d thimk) not the man of Steele but the Pies one
Trade Out:
English, Parish, Windsor
Trade In:
Sinclair, Pickett, Farrow
McAndrew to R2
Good trades or pick up a mid instead of Kossie and wait for the DPP’s?
TU – Good trades
TD – Mid and wait for DPP
Hey boys
McCarthey as Flex, do I rid him for another premo like Worrell or Steele? Or do I wait it out
Do we still think Flanders is a hold?
Good idea to double up and bring in both Ash and Whitfield? Early bye is done and GWS have the amazing round 13 bye.
TU – yep, both good scoring profiles and favourable bye
TD – no, diversify
TU: Gawn
TD: Grundy
For English replacement
English to:
TU: Gawn
TD: Jackson +100k
Better trade?
TU: Watkins > Callaghan
(Blamires will go off field)
TD: Lombard > Kozzie Pickett
(Philipou will go off field)
* I will be able to loop Blamires/ Farrow for my M8 position.
Hi all,
TU Grundy
TD Jackson
Have Gawn and McAndrew at flex..
or below
Out of the blue for cash and score
TU Sweet
TD no 1 of the above.,
Thanks….
Windsor – Parish
English – Gawn
80k Banked for Fonti to 550k premo next week along with another rookie downgrade.
Omg not Parish..
Farrow in!
do i move on walsh 4 bont
I have English and Richards
T/U: Gawn and N. Daicos with 300k in the bank
T/D: Jackson and Whitfield with 480k in the bank
Keep in mind I will want to do Buderick to trac next week. Jordy clark, mccluggae, anderson, rankine will all be heavy discounted in a few weeks time. Nic newman looked pretty good on return too at a cheap price
TU: Callaghan
TD: Serong
TU: Lachie Ash
Richards & English out :
TU: Gawn and Lachie Ash
TD: Bont and Brayshaw
Have to trade out English but what else do I do this week
TU: Windsor to Farrow
TD: Boost Windsor & Sharp to Coleman and Farrow
I already have Gawn so English to
TU: Grundy
TD: Jackson
TU – early trade out budarick who I believe still has money to make + decent scores for Pickett (should be close to top 6 forward)
TD – Selwood to Tim Kelly (massive pod, looks good but also potential trap)
What we reckon?
Out Lindsay, English and Carroll, sit Richard’s on the bench until he returns.
In Farrow, Whitfield and Callaghan…
Or
Out Lindsay, English and Richard’s.
In Coleman, Callaghan and Grundy….
Coleman up from sellwood
TU is it worth it
TD keep cash for a better upgrade next week…
Thanks…
DEF: Naish, Worrell, Mckercher, Grlj, Lacques, Lindsay, Serong, Sellwood
MID: Bont, N.Daicos, Butters, Holmes, Dawson, Serong, Bruhn, Jagga, Blamires, Duursma, Watkins
RUC: Jackson, Englinsh, Steene
FWD: Sheezel, Flanders, Cook, Robertson, Dovaston, Phillipou, Marshall, FMacrae
FLX: Lmac.
Pretty much nothing in the bank. Need to trade English – Gawn isn’t doable.
TU: Go for Grundy
TD: Move Lmac and try fix the forward line with someone like Kozzie.
Who would be a priority this week
TU Steene
TD Farrow
Thanks all
Farrow because has Def/Mid DPP. Meaning he can replace anyone in defence or midfield while also giving a swing set with Grij (if possible).
Steene can only replace either forward of Ruck, and at the moment we don’t have many that need trading out. If he sits at R3, that will need another trade to cash him out once he is fattened up (ie trade in another R3).
Farrow looks the better trade for structure, unless you have a forward or ruck that needs trading out.
The importance of your comment on cashing out steene cannot be underestimated.
“Caleb Windsor (still) only needs one ‘spike score’ and all will be well for a few more weeks.”
T/U: Right on, brother!
T/D: Get off the grass, hippy.
Fellow holder here and been saying that for the last 3 weeks as he sits on 290k churning out 60s… he will probably finally go big just as I trade him out so not convinced you can win either way on this one…… do whatever works best for your structure imo
It looks like he’ll have this week to prove himself in my side or he’s getting shipped out next week.
Hey guys
i’ve already traded in bont for 700k last week. I have a lot of cash in the bank can get anybody i want, and obviously gawn is the main man but i don’t know if i can justify spending 700k on players two weeks in a row when upgrade season hasn’t even started properly.
english to gawn is the play everybody else is doing but would it be smarter to trade english to jackson/grundy/sweet.
TU: jackson/grundy or sweet
TD: Gawn
either way i’ll have money in the bank for next week
Gawn has Blakiston, Fort/Draper, Lefau (?), Grundy, Flynn, Meek/Reeves, Emmet/Lobb (?), Riccardi/Briggs, Steen, Blakiston/Bryan in his next ten games.
That’s premeditated murder.
That lists represents like half the comp. Which only further makes the point.
Richard’s replacement:
TU: Ash
TD: Callaghan
Or McKercher?
Decided I’m holding Windsor as he plays Essendon (not that I trust him I just want to keep the trade)
Trading English for Steene and putting mcandrew R2, and keeping cash to upgrade Watkins to anyone I want via DPP.
Tu – good play
Td- can’t miss out on Gawn
English, poo, Sharp out, Gawn, Steene and Tracca in if named
TU Callaghan
TD Heeney
The idea of Parish being used as stepping stone to a Premo is out the window!
WIth the Dogs midfield missing Libba & Richards.. Surely Freijah will get a boost in midfield % and couuld be a nice swap from Parish?
Yes or No?
He might score okay over the next couple of weeks but hes not a long term keeper, so no.
TU- ASH
TD – WHITFIELD
Who is better pick?
Thinking of doing Selwood too
TU – Coleman (100k cheaper)
TD – Tim Kelly (more expensive but better avg)
Out:
Parish, Windsor, English (McAndrew to R2)
In:
Baz, Farrow, Steene
Leaves $380k ITB
TU or TD
Is it worth using a boost (I’ve only used one) to go from a dead rookie like Sharp / Lombard to Farrow?
TU: YES
TD: NO
Can’t take a trick with injuries. Have both English and Richards, but I think I’m going to hold and go
Windsor to Farrow
Watkins to Steene
This will enable Steene to be R3 when English is back, with Gawn at R1 and McAndrew at flex. And $200k in the bank for next week
T/U – Yes
T/D No
How secure is Oscar Steane
T/U should be around long enough to make good money
T/D could be dropped at any minute never to be seen again
I need some advice please.
My backline is
Sinclair,Worrell,Robert’s,Windsor,Jaques, Serong. {Selwood,Lindsay) 304,900 ITB
Need to get rid of Windsor but not sure for who.
Thumbs up::upgrade him to Short
Thumbs Down: down grade to Farrow
Comment: Other
Not sure where to go with Reid as I don’t have crazy cash, open to other options below 442k
TU: Tim Kelly
TD: Rachele
Also considering Coleman, CMac, Milera, Newman, Bice. So many options but none are really sticking out. Could also just hold and try to upgrade next week.
What to do with English
TU: trade
TD: keep
What to do with Ed Richards
TU: trade
TD: keep
Is Parish – Kerch worth a boost?
TU: Yes
TD: No
TU: Stewart
TD: Whitfield
Stewart feels the better option, but am worried about the Rnd 16 bye
Who is a better combo?
TU: Jackson + W.Ashcroft
TD: Gawn + Parish
Parish to Dunkley?
I suppose most supercoachites are in the same situation as me with injuries and suspension. Traded out include..Rozee, Gulden, Young, Petracca, Xerri, English with Marshall and Murdock injured..Still unsure with English trade as no period has been given for his injury…if we could have clarity I may reverse trade..have the Dogs given us a hint of length of his absence????
How long is Richards out for?
Tu trade
Td hold
Cheers
TU:
Bruhn –> Farrow
Watkins –> Murdock (likely back next week)
English –> Gawn
TD:
Find another way to get to Gawn
TU / fonti, parish, English – Gawn, Holmes, farrow
TD / parish, English, Watkins – Gawn, serong, schoenburg
Worth using a boost to go Parish to Whitfield (leaves me with 31 trades and 3 boosts)?
TU – Yes
TD – No
Who to trade out?
TD – Watkins
TD – Sellwood
Comment – Sharp
Sharp
Have English, but obviously want to trade for gawn. But was wondering is it worth considering jordan sweet. Cheap, and port have a easy draw. Any advice…
I’m stuck on this too. Can get Grundy. But Sweet allows an upgrade elsewhere. Is there an obvious reason not to get in Sweet at $499k and 115 avg?
You’ll be losing 10-15 points a week by not having Gawn or Grundy.
If you can make that up with an upgrade elsewhere, then it might be worth the risk.
English & Windsor out;
TU: Grundy + Kozzie Pickett
TD: Whitfield + Callaghan/Ash
(Lmac remains r2)
Trading out English, Budarick and Windsor to…
T/U: Grundy, Farrow and Sam Darcy
Can’t afford Gawn but gives me Jackson and Grundy with McAndrew in flex
T/D: Pickett, Farrow, Serong
Leaves me with McAndrew as R2 but in form Kosi and lock in Serong
McInerney, Connor MacDonald and Bailey are the alternatives for Sam Darcy, but think it’s probably a good time to buy him right now
Phillipou –> Murdock
Sellwood –> Farrow
English –> Gawn
TU or TD?
Looking for a POD as a corrective trade up from JDG. Both options are in great form and like their role.
TU: Worrell
TD: Steele
Sideways English + Richards to Gawn + Steele
Do I boost (2nd for the year) and go Windsor to Farrow
Or save the boost?
hold Richards. looks like he will just miss this week
T/U: English and Parish to Farrow and Grundy
T/D: English, Parish and Watkins to Grundy, Farrow and Oscar Steene?
Or comment. I have also thought about moving Lmac to R2 and just making the 2 trades of Farrow and Steene for Parish and Watkins and get Grundy the following week after the GCS game?
This fixes my team structure, but does mean I won’t have Gawn/Grundy yet and McAndrew will be at r2…
English > Kozzie Pickett
Phillipou > Coleman
Watkins > Farrow
TU: yes
TD: no, find a way to get Gawn/Grundy in immediately
Fade Coleman and get English to Gawn.
To decide whether to put Farrow in D def or Mid…
Who scores more this week:
TU: Lindsay Def
TD: Blamires Mid
Blamires was on the wing last week. His time in defence has been taken by McKercher. This will limit his scoring, depending on which side of the ground the ball is on.
I think Lindsay against Essendon is more likely to be a good score
Do’s anyone think Sharp will be named this week? (Need to make a call on something before Adelaide play).
TU: Yes
TD: No
Any update on English/Richards injury recovery timeframe? Thanks
talk is Richards might be a test next week.
Thoughts on Parish – Kiddy?
TU: Yes
TD: No
TU: Sellwood -> Steene and get Grundy
TD: Philipou -> Steene and get Gawn
What would you do ?? sitting 486
TU English,Carroll, Phillipou to Z Bailey, McInerney Steene 30K over
TU English, Carroll, Sellwood to Grundy, Steene, Farrow… 156K over upgrade next week
Thanks……
Looking to get Farrow, obviously wait and see teams but if neither are dropped, who do I trade out of;
TU: Windsor
TD: Watkins
to get him in? On-field team probably slightly better with Windsor still in but over 100k more if he is traded.
Do I trade Gawn in for English even though he’s full price? He’s in flex currently.
I’ve held Xerri and have Jackson in R1, McAndrew in R2.
So it means I’ll need to downgrade McAndrew when Xerri is back, probably leaving cash gen on the table.
Or am I better off trading English to a Steele or Holmes type and reduce the amount of rucks I have.
TU: get Gawn with his next few games looking juicy, sort out the rest later
TD: get someone else, don’t need 4 rucks and look for value instead
Using 3 trades…Xerri, English and Parish (have Jackson, McAndrew and ZZK) so in
TU: Gawn, Stewart and Lindsay
TD: Stewart Steele and Zorko
T/u – Heeney (Gawn R1, McAndrew R2)
T/d – Jackson (McAndrew flex)
T/u keep Sicily
T/d Turn him into Grundy using dpp
Will Tim Kelly be a top 8 mid?
FWD*
Boost for Donaston > Steen ?
TU- Yeah
TD- Nah
TU: Hold Reid one more week so I can upgrade to premo
TD: Side-grade this week to another midpricer
TU : Trade out Carroll for Farrow
TD : Trade out Watkins (even if he’s named) for Farrow
Thinking of keeping Watkins as hopefully will become a DPP
Similar to above actually, but I’m looking at tossing Windsor
TU : Trade out one of Carroll/Watkins and hold Windsor for now
TD : Trade out Windsor instead. Doing this means one more rookie on field though.
Groan. What to do with Richards?
Seems like he may only miss a week but I’m already holding Xerri.
It’s one of those ones where you hold him and he misses 4wks or you trade him and he goes over 140 for the next 6wks in a row isn’t it…
Got Bear Grlj as cover who got a 90 last time around so the hold is tempting.
Dumb game.
Woohoo! Richards is named!
might still be a late out
He trained well apparently but yep, will be keeping an eye for the late out and have a plan in place.
TU Houston
TD McKercher
TU English/Watkins to Grundy/Murdock
TD English/Watkins/Budarick to Sweet/Steene/McKercher (via DPP)
(Already have Gawn)
Windsor to NAS worth a boost?
TU: Yes
TD: No
I am looking at that trade for next week.
NAS’ break-even is 119, so he should hold his price (or go down by about 10k).
Windsor’s B/E is 51 (62 average), so unless he has a disaster day, his price won’t go down.
Parish to:
TU – Whitfield
TD – Steele
TU Steele
TD Callaghan
Or Heeney
Thoughts on keeping Ed Richards now he’s playing
TU: Keep
TD: Sell
Apparently he’s unlikely to play
Which rook to bring in?
TU – Marshall
TD – Farrow
Comment if it’s worth boosting to bring in the other
Boost to bring in Marshall / Farrow
TU/TD
Looking for help.
Last week’s trades were Parish → W.Duursma
Team before trades this week:
Def – Sinclair, McCarthy, Houston, Fonti, Jaques, Serong (Sellwood, Lindsay)
Mid – Bont, Daicos, Butters, Holmes, Bruhn,, W.Duursma, Smith, Blamires (Cook, Grji, Carroll)
Ruc – Jackson, English (McAndrew)
Fwd – Sheezel, Flanders, Budarick, Robertson, Phillipou, Lombard (Dovaston, Marshall)
Flex – Windsor
$$401,200 ITB (4 Boosts)
Thinking English, Carroll, Windsor to Gawn, Farrow, and NWM ($33,600 ITB). Thoughts?
Any thoughts or suggestions appreciated.
Or just English & Carroll to Gawn & Farrow ($305,800 ITB)
Tim asked above if it’s worth boosting to do Windsor to Nas which is essentially your question and it looks like everyone voted that it’s worth doing
Oh sorry, I didn’t see that.
Thanks for the heads up Johnno.
Forgot to mention 34 trades left before trades this week
English, Windsor, Parish > Jackson, Whitfield, Farrow
This might be overthinking things but English replacement:
TU: Gawn and $23k
TD: Whitfield and $176k to help with upgrades going forward
Have to vc one of these
Tu n daicos
Td jackson
Side trade Noah Anderson to better prem?
TU Yes
TD No
Hi Supercoacher’s.
I really want to use a boost to sideways trade Ed Richards to Nick Daicos, I can’t afford Marcus Bontempelli. Now that Ed is named to play, should I do it?
T/U – Do it! Nick will be top eight midfielder by the end of the season and Ed won’t.
T/D – Don’t do it! Sideways trades break the rules of supercoach, you’ll regret it.
Appreciate your feedback!
Regards
LeveeBreaker
TU Steele
TD Holmes
TU: English & Watkins > Whitfield & Serong (Freo)
TD: English & Budarick > Grundy & Pickett
Is it worth a boost to go dovaston to Steene
Tu yes
td no
Means I can go gawn over grundy
Options are:
Tu: trade out – english selwood
Trade in – Grundy farrow
Td: trade out – english selwood dovaston
Trade in – gawn farrow steene
Tossing up between…..
TU – Whitfield (547.5k)
TD – Grundy (661k)
Please allow prices into your decision
Yeah I think Whit mate, you know he’s most likely going to be a top 6 if not top 3-4 defender.
Assuming you already have Gawn, so wait and give yourself some time to pick who the next best ruck will be while McAndrew is doing well. You’re paying almost top dollar for Grundy too. The extra 114k or so will come in very handy.
Is Farrow a must?
If Farrow comes in, who to trade out?
TU: Gibcus (creates a swing with Grlj)
TD: Sharp
Comment Parish and bank $184K.
ZZ and Watkins out Steene and farrow in yes or no
TU: Windsor -> Whitfield
TD: Watkins -> Callaghan