Yeah I don’t think it’s heath. He just seemed to get a fair bit of attention and it was affecting his scoring around the ground, plus he took a niggle in the Richmond game. Maxy scores big when he’s taking lots of contested marks and scoring multiple goals. He came close last week with like 2-3 near goals on top of what I think was one actual goal.
Is it worth boosting Bruhn to Whitfield?
It will be my last one but I will look to upgrade 1 up 1 down over the next few weeks before the byes, whilst my rookies fatten up another week $$
Reason being, I am in desperate need of a defender and Whitfield suits my bye structure perfect. I currently have the likes of Murdock stuck on my midfield bench because my mid line is too stacked and I only have 2 premium defenders.
Looking at upgrade targets and the best bes relative to scoring are jhf, whitfield and Archie Roberts, but I don’t like jhfs byes. In terms of byes, whitfield and Roberts seem the most tempting. Watched the Essendon game and Roberts looks very very good on the eye test. Is he the real deal? I liked Whitfield’s performance which was great after the first quarter but Roberts has shown a higher ceiling. Is he the real deal? It’s no longer a bargain, but I can afford the spend.
Tu: Roberts
TD: whitfield
Comment: jhf and eat the terrible bye, but I doubt thats the best option.
The only good part is jhf gets rid of probably the lowest scoring rookie, on average in either Pou or steene. The other two I’ll have to push out Farrow, Anderson or grlj probably. Assuming Pou doesn’t go on a tear again, these seem like more consistent scorers.
Whitfield still for mine. Robert’s role currently looks great and had one of the easiest match ups for designated kickers on the weekend. However, what does it look like when Redman comes back? Will Scott move Robert’s back into the midfield and flick the magnets around later in the season?
Whitfield is cheaper and will out average him from now to the back end of the year in my opinion. He’s bye just makes the pick even better. Goodluck!
until he gets better TOG its a no. last round he had 86% TOG in first quarter and was on nearly 50. i though, he we go. but then he finished the game on 66 TOG
The challenge is the fwd rookie. Considering competition for spots at the Lions not sure you’d want to go early on McKenna. Arty Jones seems to be the only other realistic option right now, not sure if he’s back this week or not
I am looking forward at Rd12 bye. I am really short at the moment, with my current team 14 max on the field, most of the other bye rounds are OK. If it’s a toss up between two players the playing Rd12 player gets the nod.
Will have to re visit later in the week.
My first thought was to upgrade MacAndrew too but I’m pausing for thought. Gawn and Grundy play each other this week so one or both may be nullified. MacAndrew doesn’t have a crazy BE and might fire up for the showdown
I’m running McAndrew R2 (Gawn R1) so I’m more likely thinking to Grundy after Richmond as Derek mentioned. Then after Xerri’s bye, get him in as flex. Seems like the final team has to have 3 of the big 4 rucks this year
Hold Jagga, and trade him to Cumming next week when he’s on the bubble, otherwise you’ll be stuck in a loop of always going one week early on the best rookie.
Yeah legit only Reidy because I have Mitch Edwards whos cash gen is now shot after a 12 on the w/e. Can’t imagine theres any other rucks to grab other than maybe Kalani White. If Reidy plays this week just a bonus really, they could still play him and pitto in same team potentially
Depends a bit on byes. I was contemplating these two last week and realised I have way less players with the round 15 bye than 12 so went for Warner thanks to the more helpful bye
who is going to average more acorss the year?
thats the real desisicion, personally i think roberts will, playing the key role of an essondon defender, seeing lots of ball time
Tu: Grlj > Retcsko, Smith > Kozzie, Blamires > NAS or Bont.
TD: Do the Grlj and Smith trades, wait a week and then go Bont with the price drop or Bruhn to Xerri.
Unsure of which rookies to move, BE are low so more leaning towards JS being burnt in past later in the season.
Can also go Lombard instead of Smith in the 1st instance, just less cash in the bank.
is archie roberts still going to be good enough when robert’s comes back or should i go kozzie picket instead even though he may have the james jordan matchup this week. other option could be JHF
You are probably not getting any replies because your first part of the sentence doesn’t make much sense (as you have mentioned Roberts twice)?
Do you mean “when Redman comes back” or “when Ridley comes back” for Essendon?
Either way, Archie Roberts should be a good pick & he is a strong chance of being a Top 6 defender this year
And even though both are getting lots of CBA’s, I probably prefer Kozzie over JHF for durability reasons – but both are in very good form, and Kozzie is currently more expensive.
All of those 3 players named should be top 6 in their position, so I would suggest you trade in the one that best suits your team & that best suits your budget
I have to go another rookie this week, not hooked on Reidy, tempted to go for Cummings from Richmond. Any thoughts tu or td, I have no idea what is js is
Will most likely be sticking with these trades for the week it’s
Lombard, mc Andrew and bruhn for retechsko, Cummings and Archie Roberts.
The Lombard trade is allowing me to get him off the field which I have had previously, (sadly), and I would also like to see any other options for cummings
TU – Get rid of a poor bench rookie (Lombard) for a cheaper option (Chad Warner)
TD – Get rid of a good rookie (Blamires/Grlj) for a higher-end premo (Pickett/Walsh/Neale/Richards etc.)
Leaning towards first option right now as Warner suits bye structure and the higher end premos aren’t screaming out to me just yet, but want to get thoughts.
Was looking at Warner myself for the same reason, he’s proven for 4 years he’ll score around the 95 mark and has the role but he records a lot of clangers.
Was on track for a score in the mid 80’s before kicking 3 late in the game to boost his score (although junk time with the game over so scaling was low).
Considering using a boost to make a second upgrade this week. Already planning to bring in Petracca and Retschko. What’s the better play for the 3rd trade:
Ok so I’m having a crap year…
Backline has Mckercher at D4, Coleman at D5 and I can loop Jaques and Lindsay. Not great but not a complete disaster.
Mids has Parish at 5 and Bruhn at 6 plus some good rookies, not great.
Fwds is horrible, Pou at 4 and then rubbish rookies.
Which line would you focus on first?
Tempted to just get two fwds (e.g McInerney and JHF) in order to get the crap scores off field.
I am an owner of Colby and Tim Kelly.
These two I was pretty happy with two weeks ago however roles have changed and i don’t know where I sit
I am looking for some guidance
My Backline is Sinclair, Clark, Roberts, Colby, farrow, Jaques, Blamiers, Grlj
My forward line is, Sheezel, Mcinnerny, Flanders, kelly, Marshall, Lombard, Phillipou, Macrae (nuff Atm)
Is it worth me trading either out this week?
Do i view both as stepping stones?
I think McKercher needs to go more than Kelly. Backs are just so much better and more consistent so it’s easy to find a big improvement over him. Forwards are a bit less consistent and TK scores fine for a forward except for one outlier week which admittedly was the most recent one. He’s more of a luxury sideways trade at some stage while Colby is averaging 30 points less than what you need in defence
bont and someone that isnt stewart.
i personally dont see the hype in JHF, he was in a similar position last year, and let everyone down, i think gonna be a repeat of last year
if you only have the funds to get one premo, get one premo, and not 1 premo and a trade later on. save your funds for a premo, and not settling for what you dont want/afford.
I think Kozzy probably gets the third place there but otherwise, I think there’s a lot of forwards in the 90-100 range which I think comes down largely to personal preference and bye structure
Big issue I can see so far with future is the Round 12 & 16 byes- people considering them or just grabbing players like Xerri & Wanganeen Milera and don’t care.
Seems those two byes very keeper friendly!
I’ve picked up Whitfield over Nas this week and Warner over JHF last week for bye reasons. Each time it was a coin toss which way I went and the bye was the tiebreaker in the end but I wouldn’t be forcing in a player that I didn’t want just cause they have a better bye
Between Dunkley, Dale, and Warner, I’m really tossing up to go one or two of them as value picks. 460k range for those 3 seems insanely cheap, especially Dunks.
Feel like Rachele and Coleman haven’t worked out…..
Tu- out Rachele,Coleman,Macandrew for Neale,Whitfield and Retschko
Rd- Rachele and Macandrew out Grundy and Retschko in… Thanks!
Will he make you money? No. Is he worth using a trade on downgrading? Depends. If you trade him you’re cashing in a 6k gain for a trade. If you have other rookies to downgrade that will lock in 150k+ and don’t have much or any more money to make, do those first.
Josh Gibcus is one of my rookies not playing on the bench, news from Richmond is an ACL strain. Should I
TU: Gibcus > Retschko
TD: D.Sharp > Retschko (his BE has gone up to 48)
Is Milera toast as a potential top six defender, now that Fagsn the Brain has shown other teams a tag will destroy his elite effective kicking reflected in all his big SC scores, Adelaide’s wins and close loss to Freo?
Team looks good, Retschko is the must have this week. Personally I’m looking at Bailey Dale. Has had 3 low tons in the last 4 decent D6 at season end. You could go Jacques and Dev out for Dale and Retschko. Blamires is in for Wardlaw, but ZZ is playing VFL this week. Means you can loop Butters or Jackson tonight. Next week or 2 you want to target the Bont and Daicos who will both be cheap. I haven’t taken the byes into consideration.
bring in retschko mid clear out rookies that are failing to make the BE arthur jones also on bubble you should be clearing your poor performing players to premium your team not that bad clear the rookies that have achieved there BE check who is moving supercoach girl
Which mp to cash out this week
Tu: parish
Td: bruhn
I was thinking the same but now
TU. Parish out Bont in
TD. M. Reid out Petracca in
Is rachele a trade out to jhf or rankine
Tu: yes lost role so not a keeper
Td: give one more ween
Who to bring in
Tu: kossy
Td: whitfield
Sorry kozzy
I have both but probably Whitfield for consistency. Kossy doing great but never know if and when he might earn himself a enforced Holiday.
Whitfield for mine, Kozzy surely gets the Jordan tag
Not sure Jordan has the legs to stay with Kozzy but ♂️
both depends on who you need most both keepers
Bring in one
T/U. B.Dale
T/D. T.Stewart
Id bring in Stewart. Dale been struggling when tagged so far this season
Gawn to xerri – TU
Gawn to Jackson – TD
or comment if I shouldn’t
Dont trade Gawn
Edit – gawn has heath rucking with him, so thus why the low scores, imo
They very clearly said they were looking after max with a five day break. That and he’s sore.
Yeah I don’t think it’s heath. He just seemed to get a fair bit of attention and it was affecting his scoring around the ground, plus he took a niggle in the Richmond game. Maxy scores big when he’s taking lots of contested marks and scoring multiple goals. He came close last week with like 2-3 near goals on top of what I think was one actual goal.
find another way better than most mid u will need 3 of the 4 come final time they are out scoring most prem
Reidy tu
Heath td
Mcandrew out, he’s made his cash, have held English
Terrible name
This is not that place eh…
McAndrew has a few favourable match ups coming up though
When does Pittonet come back?
What’s the go with Reidy everyone? Is he a must have bring in?
Pitto had a broken hand. should be ok this week
Is it worth boosting Bruhn to Whitfield?
It will be my last one but I will look to upgrade 1 up 1 down over the next few weeks before the byes, whilst my rookies fatten up another week $$
Reason being, I am in desperate need of a defender and Whitfield suits my bye structure perfect. I currently have the likes of Murdock stuck on my midfield bench because my mid line is too stacked and I only have 2 premium defenders.
Thoughts appreciated!
Bruhn & Jagga Smith out
Retschko in, bank 100K and
TU – Kozzy
TD – Lachie Neale
Is JHF the real deal this year?
Own Sheezel, Trac, Pickett & Flanders.
Looking to get one of my fwd rookies off the field, but have some concerns from being burnt last season.
JHF, Mcinerny & Touk. Finding them tough to split. What does the community think?
*McInerny has the best bye
With 4 out of 6 forwards already premium, you’re not looking to upgrade other lines first?
Who should I trade?
TU – L.Jacques (BE 52)
TD – D.Sharp (BE 48)
Currently thinking Grlj, Mcandrew and Lombard to Robert’s, Retschko and Reidy
What if I bring in Jackson over Roberts. I’ll be running triple rucks with Gawndy
TU – Do it
TD – Bad trades
Trade McAndrew for:
TU – L. Jackson (74k in bank)
TD – L. Reidy (579k in bank)
Scored 2254 this week & will have 28 trades left after what I need to do this round.
TU – NAS
TD – A. Roberts
Looking at upgrade targets and the best bes relative to scoring are jhf, whitfield and Archie Roberts, but I don’t like jhfs byes. In terms of byes, whitfield and Roberts seem the most tempting. Watched the Essendon game and Roberts looks very very good on the eye test. Is he the real deal? I liked Whitfield’s performance which was great after the first quarter but Roberts has shown a higher ceiling. Is he the real deal? It’s no longer a bargain, but I can afford the spend.
Tu: Roberts
TD: whitfield
Comment: jhf and eat the terrible bye, but I doubt thats the best option.
The only good part is jhf gets rid of probably the lowest scoring rookie, on average in either Pou or steene. The other two I’ll have to push out Farrow, Anderson or grlj probably. Assuming Pou doesn’t go on a tear again, these seem like more consistent scorers.
Whitfield still for mine. Robert’s role currently looks great and had one of the easiest match ups for designated kickers on the weekend. However, what does it look like when Redman comes back? Will Scott move Robert’s back into the midfield and flick the magnets around later in the season?
Whitfield is cheaper and will out average him from now to the back end of the year in my opinion. He’s bye just makes the pick even better. Goodluck!
$571k to spend on a defender. Think out of these 2 for my byes structure
TU Ash
TD Whitfield.
Comment anyone else
27 trades – 2 boosts after this
Bruhn, Duursma, J.Serong > Trac, Whitfield, Retscheko
Too early to move on from those 3??
TU or TD?
i wouldnt trade Duursma from west coast, he’s averaging around 90 points, im sure you have bigger priorities to trade
Reckon I’ll go with:
Blamires to Retscko
Budarick to Kozzy
McAndrew to Xerr (Flex)
Yes – T/U
No – T/D – tell me why
Good trades although what if Blamires is picked? BE 28 I’m waiting for team selection before moving him on
Thanks, Harry. Perhaps trade Jagga instead as he also seems to have peaked…
Who to trade out this week to get Retscheko
TU Bruhn
Td Jagga
Who to Trade Out?
TU- Caleb Serong
TD- Josh Rachele
Thanks
I am looking at trading Serong in at discounted price
Mckercher
tu trade
td hold
I’m pondering the same. Clarko roulette in North’s backline
We were so used to being Bevod.
now we are being Clarkod..and the Scott’s playing roulette as well.
he has to go now
Have Dunkley ($462k) and Dale ($461k) shown enough to get them in at bargain prices?
TU – Yes, both are back on track and too much value to pass up on
TD – No, target others
McCluggage might be in the 460k mark next week. Still getting low TOG but surely that improves soonish. I’d have McCluggage before those two
until he gets better TOG its a no. last round he had 86% TOG in first quarter and was on nearly 50. i though, he we go. but then he finished the game on 66 TOG
i’m staying away until i see the TOG
Thoughts on these trades:
Out: Bruhn, McAndrew and Robertson
In: Xerri, Retschko and McKenna (could be anyone under 200k).
Already have Jackson and Gawn so going the triple Ruck setup (as I wanted to do before Xerri got suspended and I brought in Gawn).
The challenge is the fwd rookie. Considering competition for spots at the Lions not sure you’d want to go early on McKenna. Arty Jones seems to be the only other realistic option right now, not sure if he’s back this week or not
Which rookie should I trade out?
Tu: Farrow
TD: Jagga
Comment: Gril
tu: gril
Probably not the spot for this, but the live chat doesn’t seem to be working, last post is over a month old, is this the same for everyone?
its working, just no content as no one here anymore.
coming here for updated info and the last post is over 4 weeks ago….
go elsewhere everyone else has, dead zone here.
Hi Wet,
Keen to know where else you might go for SC intel if you’d be happy to share? ATM I rely on Supercoach talk and a few podcasts…
Cheers,
Wayne
OUT: Robinson, Blamires and Marshall out
IN: Reidy, Retschko and Bailey
Forward line is struggling at the moment.
Unless Port were fudging it, Marshall was sick so should be back and have BE 17.
Reidy is a popular trade-in at the moment but if Pitto is back isn’t he dropped?
Perhaps, worse case is Reidy is still a cheap DPP and loop option
I am looking forward at Rd12 bye. I am really short at the moment, with my current team 14 max on the field, most of the other bye rounds are OK. If it’s a toss up between two players the playing Rd12 player gets the nod.
Will have to re visit later in the week.
Who to bring in this week?
TU – Luke Jackson
TD – Archie Roberts
Who to bring in this week?
TU – Luke Jackson
TD – Archie Roberts
New trade plan:
Tu: Parish, Mcandrew to Jackson, Retschko
Td: Grlj, Parish, Bruhn to Kossy, Whitfield, Retschko
Note my current rucks are Gawn and Grundy, Mcandrew is flex
TU: Jackson this week
TD: Xerri in a week or two
Comment: Both
Gawn/McAndrew are R1/R2 currently
TU: Get both and sacrifice flexibility of FLX.
Needing to upgrade prem in def
Tu Wilkie
Td sinclair
Upgrade MacAndrew to:
tu Grundy
td Jackson
Comment Gawn
My first thought was to upgrade MacAndrew too but I’m pausing for thought. Gawn and Grundy play each other this week so one or both may be nullified. MacAndrew doesn’t have a crazy BE and might fire up for the showdown
i’m thinking the same, then give him the match up against Richmond and trade before he plays Xerri
..and trade him to get Xerri
I’m running McAndrew R2 (Gawn R1) so I’m more likely thinking to Grundy after Richmond as Derek mentioned. Then after Xerri’s bye, get him in as flex. Seems like the final team has to have 3 of the big 4 rucks this year
TU NAS
TD K Picket
Thinking of going
Mckercher to Roberts
And downgrading Jagga to bank some cash
Is cumming an option? I already have Retschko
Hold Jagga, and trade him to Cumming next week when he’s on the bubble, otherwise you’ll be stuck in a loop of always going one week early on the best rookie.
Or
Jagga, Mckercher and McAndrew out
In
JHF, Roberts and X.Taylor
Could also do
Lombard, McAndrew and Mckercher out for
JHF, Roberts and Taylor.
Keep Jagga another week
I kinda think Lombard is just a really slow burn that you have to wait a bit more before cashing out
Both Blamires and Grlj can still make $$$ but 1 has to go for Retschko
TU : Blamires
TD : Grlj
Then it’s McKercher to Whitfield
Thanks Coaches
Thoughts on best forward
Toby Greene TU
vs
McInerney TD
Thanks
After trades will have 22 trades (1 boost) – 7 upgrades left.
In – L. Jackson, P. Retchschko, L. Reidy
Out – L. McAndrew, M. Edwards, L. Lombard
TU – Yes
TD – No
i thought Pitto was only going to miss one game, maybe two
I think Reidy’s worth a shot even just as a loophole player with a super low breakeven that he’ll make cash if Pitto misses later in the year too
Yeah legit only Reidy because I have Mitch Edwards whos cash gen is now shot after a 12 on the w/e. Can’t imagine theres any other rucks to grab other than maybe Kalani White. If Reidy plays this week just a bonus really, they could still play him and pitto in same team potentially
I voted td cause I don’t love culling Lombard or McAndrew this early though but I do see the logic in Reidy
7 TU’s is crazy!
That’s not worth a boost dude
Tu – Jackson (625k)
Td – JHF (495K)
Prices taken into consideration!
Vsing bottom of ladder this week.
Can’t afford any premos unless I use a boost. 28 trades left. Thinking double downgrade;
Blamires > Ret
Marshall > Reidy
Marshall will be back with a super low breakeven. Hold him
TU – Warner
TD – JHF
Depends a bit on byes. I was contemplating these two last week and realised I have way less players with the round 15 bye than 12 so went for Warner thanks to the more helpful bye
TU: JHF
TD: Boost to NAS/Jackson (Leaves me with 1 remaining boost)
Need a forward this week
T/U JHF
T/D Bailey
Bailey suits my bye rounds better but more expensive with a higher round average.
Use last boost for:
Robertson –> Retschko
Jacques –> Whitfield
McAndrew –> Reidy
TU: Hell yeah
TD: Nah
Hell no
TU: Jagga & Bruhn -> Retschko & Roberts
TD: Jagga & McAndrew -> Retschko & Kozzy
who is going to average more acorss the year?
thats the real desisicion, personally i think roberts will, playing the key role of an essondon defender, seeing lots of ball time
Thoughts,sitting 280
TU McAndrew Farrow to Reidy and Whitfield
TD no saves trades,,,,
TU – D.Sharp (BE 48) > P.Retschko
TD – K.Coleman (BE 78) > P.Retschko
TU: Jackson (Move McAndrew to Flex)
TD: NAS + $63k
Tu: Grlj > Retcsko, Smith > Kozzie, Blamires > NAS or Bont.
TD: Do the Grlj and Smith trades, wait a week and then go Bont with the price drop or Bruhn to Xerri.
Unsure of which rookies to move, BE are low so more leaning towards JS being burnt in past later in the season.
Can also go Lombard instead of Smith in the 1st instance, just less cash in the bank.
Thoughts ?
Thanks
I’d maybe hold out on kozzy, I reckon he will cop the Jordan tag this weekend
Any other options you like ?
Can do NAS in def, I have Sinclair also.
TU: Out Phillipou for Trac
TD: Out lombrad for JHF
Other 2 trades i’ve done are out jagga and todd marshall. In reidy and retschko
Hold Marshall and Phillipou
Do you have McAndrew?
Jagga+MaAndrew>Trac+Retschko
mcandrew is my R2 so can’t do that sadly
Regretting Rachele at the moment- is trading him to jhf too sideways or could it be worth it with upcoming price drop/increase.
is archie roberts still going to be good enough when robert’s comes back or should i go kozzie picket instead even though he may have the james jordan matchup this week. other option could be JHF
thoughts?
Oscar – g’day!!
You are probably not getting any replies because your first part of the sentence doesn’t make much sense (as you have mentioned Roberts twice)?
Do you mean “when Redman comes back” or “when Ridley comes back” for Essendon?
Either way, Archie Roberts should be a good pick & he is a strong chance of being a Top 6 defender this year
And even though both are getting lots of CBA’s, I probably prefer Kozzie over JHF for durability reasons – but both are in very good form, and Kozzie is currently more expensive.
All of those 3 players named should be top 6 in their position, so I would suggest you trade in the one that best suits your team & that best suits your budget
Good luck!!
TU: Either trade Brodie/Gibcus out as they aren’t playing
TD: Trade Sharp as his BE is 48 and is unlikely to hit it
380 k itb, 1 boost.
TU: mcandrew – xerri, jagga – retschko
TD: mcandrew – retschko, jagga – premo, blamires – premo
Best use of $200k
TU: Farrow to Z.Bailey
TD: Bruhn to Bont
Locked in Jagga to Retschko so what’s next
TU: McKercher to Whitfield
TD: Robertson to Dale
Currently have 25 trades and 2 boosts remaining.
TU – Use 3 trades to get Jackson, Retschko & Reidy
TD – Use 1 trade and get Retschko
I have to go another rookie this week, not hooked on Reidy, tempted to go for Cummings from Richmond. Any thoughts tu or td, I have no idea what is js is
Arty Jones could be back
Will most likely be sticking with these trades for the week it’s
Lombard, mc Andrew and bruhn for retechsko, Cummings and Archie Roberts.
The Lombard trade is allowing me to get him off the field which I have had previously, (sadly), and I would also like to see any other options for cummings
TU – Get rid of a poor bench rookie (Lombard) for a cheaper option (Chad Warner)
TD – Get rid of a good rookie (Blamires/Grlj) for a higher-end premo (Pickett/Walsh/Neale/Richards etc.)
Leaning towards first option right now as Warner suits bye structure and the higher end premos aren’t screaming out to me just yet, but want to get thoughts.
Was looking at Warner myself for the same reason, he’s proven for 4 years he’ll score around the 95 mark and has the role but he records a lot of clangers.
Was on track for a score in the mid 80’s before kicking 3 late in the game to boost his score (although junk time with the game over so scaling was low).
Considering using a boost to make a second upgrade this week. Already planning to bring in Petracca and Retschko. What’s the better play for the 3rd trade:
TU: Bruhn for Nas
TD: Cook for JHF
Who’s your midfield group?, because I’d be holding Bruhn through this week to cover getting Bont and Callaghan once they bottom out next week
TU – Blamires and Jagga OUT, Retch and Sinclair IN
TD – Use last boost to also go Grill OUT, Daniels IN at F6-7
Few downgrade targets for me this week >>> Blamires, Grlj, Bruhn, Smith, & McAndrew
Out of those who are the locks to trade out?
The only person I’m set to bring in is Retschko.
1) TU: Do I then use a boost (2 remaining), to bring in Xerri, with Retschko and Jones.
2) TD: Save the boost, target Xerri the week after, and bring in Whitfield?
Comment on who to trade out.
xerri has to high of a brake even this week, put your money else where!
Breakeven*
he does play Geelong!!
Ok so I’m having a crap year…
Backline has Mckercher at D4, Coleman at D5 and I can loop Jaques and Lindsay. Not great but not a complete disaster.
Mids has Parish at 5 and Bruhn at 6 plus some good rookies, not great.
Fwds is horrible, Pou at 4 and then rubbish rookies.
Which line would you focus on first?
Tempted to just get two fwds (e.g McInerney and JHF) in order to get the crap scores off field.
Gotta be the forward line there I think
I am an owner of Colby and Tim Kelly.
These two I was pretty happy with two weeks ago however roles have changed and i don’t know where I sit
I am looking for some guidance
My Backline is Sinclair, Clark, Roberts, Colby, farrow, Jaques, Blamiers, Grlj
My forward line is, Sheezel, Mcinnerny, Flanders, kelly, Marshall, Lombard, Phillipou, Macrae (nuff Atm)
Is it worth me trading either out this week?
Do i view both as stepping stones?
I think McKercher needs to go more than Kelly. Backs are just so much better and more consistent so it’s easy to find a big improvement over him. Forwards are a bit less consistent and TK scores fine for a forward except for one outlier week which admittedly was the most recent one. He’s more of a luxury sideways trade at some stage while Colby is averaging 30 points less than what you need in defence
How do these 3 trades sound?
Budarick, Jagga, McAndrew -> JHF, Retschko, Rankine
Bringing in two players with the rd 12 bye. Can your team weather that?
Bye planning is overrated with the amount of carnage we get every week :-S
TU: Bont and T.Stewart
TD: Whitfield and JHF
bont and someone that isnt stewart.
i personally dont see the hype in JHF, he was in a similar position last year, and let everyone down, i think gonna be a repeat of last year
Can do Ash and Bailey instead? Both should be top 6-8
Unfortunately can’t get anyone other than Stewart if I go for Bont..
if you only have the funds to get one premo, get one premo, and not 1 premo and a trade later on. save your funds for a premo, and not settling for what you dont want/afford.
So who are the must have forwards outside of Sheezel and Petracca?
I think Kozzy probably gets the third place there but otherwise, I think there’s a lot of forwards in the 90-100 range which I think comes down largely to personal preference and bye structure
ive had mcnerny from the start who has averaged me 90+
Is it optimal to trade more capable scorers for better premos or leave them for points on field and get cheaper premium options?
T/u – Bruhn and McAndrew OUT
Retschko and Jackson IN
T/d – Hold Bruhn and McAndrew.
Trade 2 of Grjl, Farrow and Blamires OUT
Retschko and 500k premo IN
Who should I upgrade this week ?
TU – Parish
TD – Bruhn
TU: Lachy Neale
TD: Nassa w-Milera
Big issue I can see so far with future is the Round 12 & 16 byes- people considering them or just grabbing players like Xerri & Wanganeen Milera and don’t care.
Seems those two byes very keeper friendly!
I’ve picked up Whitfield over Nas this week and Warner over JHF last week for bye reasons. Each time it was a coin toss which way I went and the bye was the tiebreaker in the end but I wouldn’t be forcing in a player that I didn’t want just cause they have a better bye
2 bargain buys that I reckon have a history of finishing a season stronger than they start it.
TU: Dunkley
TD: Bradshaw.
P.S. Holding my last Midfield position for McCluggage when he bottoms out in a few weeks and gets more conditioning..
Between Dunkley, Dale, and Warner, I’m really tossing up to go one or two of them as value picks. 460k range for those 3 seems insanely cheap, especially Dunks.
Feel like Rachele and Coleman haven’t worked out…..
Tu- out Rachele,Coleman,Macandrew for Neale,Whitfield and Retschko
Rd- Rachele and Macandrew out Grundy and Retschko in… Thanks!
Coleman had 90 last week and back to back tons two weeks before that so I’m personally holding him for now
When zorko comes back should be back to 90’s, mcarthy was taking too much of his ball, which reflects the score
*coleman should be back to 90’s
Thoughts on Dyson Sharp, is he worth holding for a bit longer or an urgent trade?
Will he make you money? No. Is he worth using a trade on downgrading? Depends. If you trade him you’re cashing in a 6k gain for a trade. If you have other rookies to downgrade that will lock in 150k+ and don’t have much or any more money to make, do those first.
Seems to be a lot of love for Jackson this week. Are people still going there if English gets named for the dogs?
How confident are we he is a top 3 ruck?
Personal opinion, top 3 ruckemn this year will be
#1 grundy
#2 xerri
#3 gawn when he goes back to his usual self
jackson and gawn should be preety even later on in the season
Bruhn, Grlj, J.Serong > Whitfield, Horney, retschko
TU or TD
I think I am going
Jagga, Mckercher and McAndrew out
JHF, Roberts and Artie Jones in
I figure at some point Jones will come back and in the meantime he is a loop option.
I’m assuming yes but just making sure you already have Retschko? Just a bit more of a must than Jones otherwise
Jones 82 points was scoring at 1.3 ppm before injury second only to Bont 1.7
Merrett in the same game scored at 1.2 ppm for 116 points.
TU. Jones if named
TD. Retschko
Jones had a 21 in his first game right? What happened there? Just out of interest?
concussion..
Im a Bulldogs and I think if he’s in he’s my down grade…sitting 280…
Yeah, he played half the game, Andrew’s cleaned him up.
Concussion
Who to trade
TU: Robertson (a handy loop at the moment)
TD: Jaques (probably a little more cash to eke out)
Do I use my boost to trade Kalani for Reidy and get some cash gen or just hold?
I have only used one boost and still have 29 trades.
Use a boost to trade T. Kelly to Bailey?
Isnt a top 8 forward like I hoped. BE of 123 but has Richmond this week.
In a similar boat to Mitch, T kelly out with a boost to jhf or ride it out?
Josh Gibcus is one of my rookies not playing on the bench, news from Richmond is an ACL strain. Should I
TU: Gibcus > Retschko
TD: D.Sharp > Retschko (his BE has gone up to 48)
TU: Nas & Whitfeild
or
TD: Roberts & JHF
Tossing between going hard and saving coin
TU: Bruhn, McAndrew and Rachele out for NWM, Whitfield and Reidy (or other rookie, already have Retch)
TD: McAndrew to Dunkley/Warner
Best defender premo to buy now
i already have sinclair and whitfield
Tu nas
td ash
tu roberts
td clark
or use dpp and trade in kozzie
tu/td
TU: Whitfield
TD: Kozzie
Have the following:
Defenders: Nas, Sinclair, Clark, J Diacos, Farrow, Lindsay
Forwards: Sheezel, Petracca, Flanders, Cook, Phillipou, Marshall
Already own Gawn & Grundy
Who to bring in at flex?
TU: Jackson
TD: Xerri
who to trade out
tu – coleman
td – rachele
TU: Xerri
TD: NWM
Who to trade out first
TU M Sellwood
TD L Jaques
Coin toss there. One of those where if it was me whichever one, I trade will score 80 and the one I keep gets a 30
Is Milera toast as a potential top six defender, now that Fagsn the Brain has shown other teams a tag will destroy his elite effective kicking reflected in all his big SC scores, Adelaide’s wins and close loss to Freo?
TU. Yes
TD. No
T/U Stewart/NVM
T/D Ash/Petracca
Thanks
Hi,
Thinking of trading the following
Farrow,Grilj,McAndrew to
Retschko,Daniel’s,Whitfield
Leaving only 1 boost & 22 trades left?
Tu. Yes
Td. No
Hi,
Thinking of trading the following
Farrow,Grilj,McAndrew to
Retschko,Daniel’s,Whitfield
Leaving only 1 boost & 22 trades left?
Tu. Yes
Td. No
is this a good trade or should I keep both as they are both capable
Bruhn – retschko
Mccandrew – Jackson
TU – Do it
TD – save trades
Just jumped on Afl for team lineups.
29/04 8.00pm
How bad are they not showing ins and outs.
most teams get released on thursday, not wednesday 🙂
Went to Fox.
Two D. Moore’s in doesn’t happen too often.
Ash, Retschko/Coleman, Farrow
TU – Jackson
TD – Xerri
Already have Gawn & Grundy.
Ideally want Xerri but unsure if it’s wise to pay up or not.
Better trade this week?
TU: Dev Rob > JHF
(Gets Philipou off field and allows me to go 1 up 1 down next week)
TD: Bruhn > Xerri
(Locks in the 3 big rucks nice and early)
Dev Rob has to go
Who to field
TU: Retschko
TD: Tsatas
Who to field
TU: Grjl
TD: Blamires
I’m trading Mckercher this I can’t hack it anymore !!!!!
TU – Ash
TD – Whitfield
TU: Grlj & Blamires -> JHF & Retschko
TD: McAndrew & Bruhn -> Jackson & Retschko
Who is better to trade out this week for an upgrade?
TU: Bruhn
TD: McAndrew
i was concerned with McAndrews 60% TOG last week
Need Jacko…..too painful watching him!
Who goes out of these 2?
TU – Bruhn
TD – Cook
Bringing Kozzy in, but to make it happen do
I:
T/u – T Bruhn out
T/d – B Cook out
Hey boys, would love some help with my team this week. 31 Trades 3 boosts $104k itb
What would you do this week? Playing for leagues.
Sinc Ash Clark Serong Farrow Lindsay (Selwood Jacques)
Butters Walsh Holmes Nandos Young Brunh Jagga Murdock (Blamires Dev Rob Angry)
Gawn Jackson (ZZ)
Sheezel Bailey JMac Flanders Cook Poo ( Marshall Lombard)
Thank you 🙂
Flex?
Sorry McAndrew at Flex
McAndrew Flex
Retschko JHF. IN
Smith McAndrew. Out
Clearing the decks:
OUT: Parish, Bruhn and Mc Andrew
IN:
TU: Nas, Stewart and Retschko (Xerri after his bye)
TD: Get Xerri in?
Who is a bigger priority to bring in – Petracca (only have sheezel premo) or Jackson (have gawn and Xerri)?
TU – Trac
TD – Jackson
Do the unthinkable W.Duursma out along with Parish and M. Reid
In Retschko or Jones (DPP), Bont and Petracca (DDP) bargains
Or
Lombard out Jones in
Reid out Daniels in
Parish out Petracca in
TU. Do the unthinkable
TD. Trust the little voices, “get rid of Lombard, get rid of Lombard while you can”
Is Dawson a hold ?
TU – hold
TD – trade
He’s becoming a real headache, isn’t he? Out again this week.
Who to field?
TU- Jagga Smith
TD- Angry Anderson
Thanks
Trade Jagga or Mcandy first?
TU: Jagga
TD: Mcandy
Is Rachele a trade?
Thoughts on Arty Jones? Currently got Dovaston who looks dreadful with a tough run to come.
TU: Yes
TD: No
TU: Blamires (or relative rookie) + Mcandrew > JHF & Rat
TD: Use boost two downgrade 2x 300k rookies and get an uber premo
Last week’s trades were Fonti & Budarick → Trac & Murdock
Team before trades this week:
Def – NWM, Sinclair, McCarthy, Houston, Grji, Lindsay (Jaques, Sellwood)
Mid – Butters, Daicos, Bont, Holmes, Bruhn, W.Duursma, Smith, Robertson (Serong, Farrow, Blamires)
Ruc – Gawn, Jackson (McAndrew)
Fwd – Sheezel, Trac, Flanders, Cook, Phillipou, Marshall (Lombard, Dovaston)
Flex – Murdock
$46,400 ITB, 29 Remaining Trades. (3 Boosts)
Thinking of going Serong & Robertson to Retschko & JHF ($7,600 ITB)
Will move JHF forward and have Marshall Flex
Thoughts?
Any feedback appreciated!
Hi all
TU Whitfield
TD Ash
Thanks
Trade out
Tu blamires (can use as loop this week)
Td jaques (cannot use as loop this week)
I think you just answered your own question Jacko.
Better 119k bubble rookie to trade in:
TU – Arty Jones
TD – Reidy
Jones wont play the Bombers every week so the 21 he pumped out v the Lions is probably the true indicator of his 2nd year small forward output
TU: Xerri & NAS
TD: Grundy & Petracca
TU – Farrow, Watkins -> Kozzy Pickett, Artie Jones
TD – Blamires, Lombard -> NWM, Artie Jones
Trade in:
TU – L Jackson
TD – Boost to Rankine & JHF
No replies so going to try my luck again 🙁
Hey boys, would love some help with my team this week. 31 Trades 3 boosts $104k itb
What would you do this week? Playing for leagues.
Sinc Ash Clark Serong Farrow Lindsay (Selwood Jacques)
Butters Walsh Holmes Nandos Young Brunh Jagga Murdock (Blamires Dev Rob Angry)
Gawn Jackson (ZZ)
Sheezel Bailey JMac Flanders Cook Poo ( Marshall Lombard)
McA Flex
Thank you
Team looks good, Retschko is the must have this week. Personally I’m looking at Bailey Dale. Has had 3 low tons in the last 4 decent D6 at season end. You could go Jacques and Dev out for Dale and Retschko. Blamires is in for Wardlaw, but ZZ is playing VFL this week. Means you can loop Butters or Jackson tonight. Next week or 2 you want to target the Bont and Daicos who will both be cheap. I haven’t taken the byes into consideration.
bring in retschko mid clear out rookies that are failing to make the BE arthur jones also on bubble you should be clearing your poor performing players to premium your team not that bad clear the rookies that have achieved there BE check who is moving supercoach girl
should read MADE THE BE NO LONGER MAKING MONEY
SUPERCOACH GIRL i suggest you check out Jimmy Dee most traded column here it will help you
cash in Jagga and McA get retschko and Bont