Table For Two – Rd3

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 6 2017

In the spirit of the wildly successful “Thommo’s 2Up” over the pre-season, we’d like to offer the SCT Coaches a Table For Two on this Thursday afternoon.

Who do I take as VC loophole? Do I bring in Hoskin-Elliott at all costs? Should I trade out Hibberd? Do I need Preuss? Who starts at F6? Whatever your question, enter it into the Forum. Our Coaches will help out with the “Thumbs Up/Down” function……

2
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

27 thoughts on “Table For Two – Rd3”

  1. Jack Steven out for:

    TU: T. Mitchell – just the one trade don’t have Marchbank/WHE but have pretty much all the cheaper rookies

    TD: M. Murphy and either Marchbank/WHE

    Thoughts?

    25

    25
      1. We are a fickle bunch. If your rookie depth is good then you can get away with not having WHE/Marchbank. There are options coming through anyway.

        FWIW – I have T.Mitchell and I’ve been wrapped with him for the price I paid. Gold Coast this week too so should feast it up. Essendon also have named Hocking, so Murphy might be getting a tag… this is only one week so you can’t really read to much into this fixture for your decision.

        1

        0
        1. Thanks Hubba Hubba!

          My only reasoning in getting Murphy because he’s a proven mid and 100k cheaper even though he’s had his injuries. My backline consists of Docherty, Laird, Howe, Lloyd, Hampton, Otten and Stewart so I don’t feel that I HAVE to get Marchbank even though I’d like to. Getting rid of Steven depletes my midfield a bit so I need to replace him with a premo. Also WHE is going to skyrocket in price so even though every man and their rabbit are investing in him, I still think he’s a must have at that price.

          Decisions, decisions.

          0

          0
  2. I usually employ the “set-and-forget” rule for my ruck. Last year I decided to be naughty and pick Lobbe and it burnt me. This year I went with Sandi and it might go down the same way

    T/U Bring in a premo Ruck for Goldy
    T/D Keep him if he’s named

    1

    41
  3. Looking to trade out Jack Martin (58/77 b/e 96) for either Andrew Mackie or Lee Spurr.
    Mackie has 110/99 b/e 10 @380k & I add 20k to my 75k stash.
    Spurr has 110/89 & b/e 38 @410k & I lose 10k from the kitty.

    Give Mackie the thumbs up and Spurr the thumbs down. Comment if you think I shouldn’t make this trade at all. Cheers.

    2

    13
    1. I’m in a similar scenario with my 2nd trade this week. I looked at both, but something tells me – there’s a reason why they are both priced like they are accordingly. No point trading up if they then drop their average to 70. its a toughie.

      RoOSTA

      4

      0
  4. worth trading goldy to grundy to be able to bring in hoskin-elliot for simpkin? otherwise butler can play on field but i dont like the look of simpkin and really like the look of hoskin-elliot. grundy might score better than goldy and will be less of a worry in the injury department.

    3

    19
    1. i may just be thinking this because i lost my league game last week because goldy was out and my opponent had hoskin-elliot >:/

      4

      0
  5. TU: Trade out SPS for WHE
    TD: Keep the team the way it is

    I guess I’m lucky that this is my greatest issue.

    10

    11
  6. Due to downgrading NRoo to Hannan last round (probably a mistake seeing as how Roo’s back this week…) I now have bulk cash, looking to bring in a premium defender next week once price changes occur.
    Just one trade this round, need to bring in WHE.

    TU: Trade Roughy down to WHE
    (This leaves me with $605k, enough to bring in a top 6 defender next week, and lets me keep my rookie mid/fwd DPP).

    TD: Trade Pickett up to WHE
    (This moves Taranto into the mids, which means Dahl is my only DPP in the forward line. $362k remaining, which isn’t enough to turn Smith into a top 6 defender next week)

    3

    12
  7. I know it’s not that big of a trade but it will provide me with more cash just not sure if it’s worth it but,

    T/up – Pickett to Hannan

    T/down- just hold it won’t make too much of a difference

    1

    4
    1. Really depends on the rest of your team. With Newman on the bubble next week and Berry in the mix, I’m passing on Marchbank

      0

      0
  8. One of the skilled coaches to have Hannebery but not have Marchbank or WHE. Currently have Otten/Stewart/Hampton at D4- D6 and Taranto/Florent/Eddy at F5 to F7. I think my ideal trade would have been Hanners to Bont and Smith to Marchbank, but I just fall short of cash. So…

    T/U = Trade Hannebery for another expensive top 10 min & Trade a non playing rookie (hibbered/Smith/mountford) for butler.
    T/D = Trade Hanners out for a Wines/Murphy/Viney/Heppell type & trade Smith/Mountford for Marchbank/WHE

    Thanks for the help guys.

    5

    0
  9. first 2 trades of the year
    Bowes out-WHE in
    Simpkin out-Houston in
    I’m a bit worried about Houston’s JS but hard to ignore the $70k he will possibly make this week, but if he gets a couple of more games it will justify the trade, and then I suppose it will free up a fair bit of cash to get the next crop of rookies, EG: balic/Mcluggage etc, and 1st premo upgrade next set of trades possibly.
    and I’ve also started poorly, I’m well down the page in supercoach 50,000 ish, so I need to do something
    love to know what all the coaches reckon of these trades
    T/U Houston good trade
    T/d Houston bad trade

    3

    1
  10. Who to plug f6
    Butler (vs west coast)
    Or
    Taranto (vs north)

    Comment eddy (in the showdown) or Florent (vs the pies)

    0

    3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *