Trade Talk R4 2012

Written by Motts on April 23 2012

Had enough of looking at Dusty’s woeful scores? Maybe you can’t wait to see the ‘back’ of Mumford? Treloar on the bubble too hard to pass up?

You’ve only got a couple of days before partial lockout kicks in again this week so whatever you’re planning on doing, start thinking about it now.

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

163 thoughts on “Trade Talk R4 2012”

  1. Really want to trade out Gibbs and dusty but with only 20 trades left can’t bring myself to do it, hopefully they come good this week.

    0

    0
  2. Going to try and hold tight this week. Not enough cash to do any upgrades and cash cows dont have enough milk

    0

    0
  3. Mark Stevens just tweeted this
    “Ablett’s manager Liam Pickering says his knee pulled up worse than expected the morning after and confirmed nothing could be ruled out”

    this week has gone from bad to worse to hellish

    i scored 1949, mummy,fyfe, smedts,redden,smith,dusty all let me down

    now gablett is going to be out…shoot me now
    Reverse trades are done with from 2.40pm wednesday aswell…it will be rnd 4 all over again come friday arfternoon.

    FMSC

    Thats my vent for the day

    0

    0
  4. Not too concerned on Dusty yet. He was on for the ton but his last quarter was non existent. Looked good enough up to that point. Still think he knock out some decent scores soon enough

    0

    0
  5. What do we do if the little master is out for any more than 2 weeks
    Thumbs Up- Trade him out then bring him back later
    Thumbs Down- Dont waste a trade hell be right.

    0

    0
  6. Im bringin in Old mac this week for For Thomas I cant get a game Ledger
    With a break even of -113 his set for a huge price increase.

    0

    0
  7. Is it time to trade Couch to Treloar?

    Thumbs up if good decision
    Thumbs down if you think couch will get a run soon and hold tight

    0

    0
  8. 21 trades left, Plenty of cash
    Dusty has to go,
    got goodes buddy and PAv

    Need to get rid of dusty Martin,
    Sidebum? B Harvey ? Cloke ? Lewis?

    0

    0
  9. I wouldn’t flick the bald man. On the bench i Bet he still outscores Martin! Have sufficient cover and as only going for cash league win the next 3 matches I have are easy wins.

    0

    0
  10. want to bring in Old Mac or Treloar, but I worked out I have enough cash to go…
    IN: J.Selwood, Treloar or Old Mac
    OUT: Magner (or Shiel) D.Smith

    not sure if it’s to early to upgrade? but I have the cash so I’m thinking why not? really need some help on this because I’m new and not done this rookie upgrade stuff before. I was thinking of upgrading another position with a straight up rookie to premium and only using one trade (eg: Smith to Tippet and keep Magner) But it’s hard to pick who will be the top players in other positions, but I think selwood is a pretty safe bet to be a top midfielder.

    thumbs up- Do the trade now if you have the cash
    thumbs down- Don’t do it, milk every cent you can and wait a few weeks
    comment as well, cheers guys ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  11. I won’t do any trades in my main team unless Fyfe or GAJ are ruled out for 4-6 weeks otherwise I will keep em as I have already given up on overall and will focus only on league wins where trades are all important.
    In SCTTL I will need to ditch Carrots for sure and do the wait and see on Mummy, GAJ and Fyfe.

    0

    0
  12. Was going to put carrazzo in but there was a thumbs up/down someone had raised on Friday. Scotland won. Based on that I chose him. Thanks guys for making me not make the carrotS trade

    0

    0
  13. What a crazy week! was lucky enough not to have any doughnuts but i have a few premiums on the bench.

    ive already used a bunch of trades but im thinking of bring in old mac for either clay smith or coniglio. his BE is very hard to ignore and may just turn into a keeper.

    t/u trade smith, hes done for the season
    t/d trade coniglio, he wont be going up much higher

    im completely stumped so this will help me a heap. cheers lads.

    0

    0
  14. What does everyone think on enright, had a good game on the weekend, possibly back into form and maybe a good swap for Carrazzo?

    0

    0
  15. just looking through the players on offer this week ๐Ÿ˜‰ and was wonder if you guys think kurt tippett will be a top 10 forward by years end? started well with scores of 150, 82, 128, 126. The crows have played some pretty easy teams (GC, GWS, Dogs) but he did score 128 against hawks…

    thumbs up- Yes he will
    thumbs down- No he won’t

    0

    0
  16. I’ve got a midfield of Ablett, J. Selwood, Watson, Hayes, Masten, Magner, Coniglio and Greene. Going to downgrade either Coniglio, Greene or Magner to McDonald this week, as his breakeven is too good to ignore. And as I have over $300k in the bank already, am set to upgrade to Pendles next week. If Ablett is injured, I could upgrade to Pendles now, getting him in as captain and gaining a 130-odd. But I’d lose the rookie price increase and Pendles’ price decrease. If Ablett is healthy, I’ll upgrade to Pendles next week.

    If Ablett is injured:
    T/up: upgrade to Pendles this week
    T/down: upgrade next week

    0

    0
  17. Go for it. Ive had a poor start so no point going for real overall dip, therefore I have no issue keeping him knowing for some leagues as shocking as it is he may be a POD in a few weeks. Scary!

    0

    0
  18. hey guys
    Thinking that mcdonalds breakeven is too good to ignore
    so ive got ledger warming my bench in the mids and smedts in the fowards

    Thumbs up – go the straight swaps ledger for old mac and smedts for treloar
    Thumbs down – trade ledger for treloar so i have a mid/fwd dpp that i can swap with dusty, kennedy, smith and fyfe

    thanks guys comment any other options cheers ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  19. should i go..
    Fyfe for stanton in mids and carrazzo for suckling (thumbs up)
    OR
    Mumford for 211 and carrazzo for suckling/scotland (thumbs down)

    0

    0
  20. Is Porplyzia for Treloar a good trade? Made $80k from him, sacrificing anywhere from $50k -$100k more as well as a trade obv. Gaining a probable $250k from Treloar.

    UP: Yes
    DOWN: No

    0

    0
  21. I think everyone is mad to keep martin any longer, he is done! Price is indicating no way around dropping further then levelling out at around $430,000 to $460,000. If he starts getting 90 to 100 regularly, then IMO that’s not enough.

    I’m taking the $80k hit and bringing in Stanton then Pendles next week or even week after as his break even suggests he’ll fall over the next two weeks. Then you’ll get him for low $600,000s!

    0

    0
  22. Hmmm…just shy of 1800 this week – 6 donuts on the field, only two covered by emergencies. I swear to God(dard), if the SC website freezes up for the 10 minutes leading up to lockout again, you guys may see me in the news for all the wrong reasons.

    On the upside, I have 2 more trades now than I would have had…

    Have both Fyfe and Mumford to consider injury-wise at the moment. Can cover for Shaw for one more week, and Ablett can warm the bench for a while. Really don’t want $600k sitting on the bench every second week, though, so Mumford is target number 1. With Naitanui, Giles and Redden around him, is it worth trading him down, knowing that I’m gonna have to use another trade later to bring in a premium ruck (possibly even Mummy himself if he comes good…)?

    And Fyfe…considering trading him out for Goodes, but depending on what I decide with Mummy (hold or trade) I could trade out Fyfe for Treloar, and then upgrade Greene to Selwood or Judd or any number of gun mids.

    Then there’s Birchall – any info on him? Can’t see anything floating around on how serious his knee injury is, how long he may be rested etc.

    This round sucks balls!

    0

    0
  23. Made the SHAW to CARRAZZO trade last week….

    So now thinking of either Birchall or Suckling for carrazzo cant affored anyone above 500k

    Birchall thumbs up
    Suckling thumbs down
    Someone else comment

    0

    0
  24. Unbelievable!

    1. Sandilands missed training today. Possible calf injury
    2. Scott Pendlebury wore a bandage on left calf & limped around The Tan today.

    0

    0
  25. Fyfe and Carazzo.
    Will fyfe play this week?
    Scotland Thumbs Up
    Suckling Thumbs down

    Anyone considering duffield? Averaging 90 odd including a game where he got injured and subbed out, without that would be averaging 100 and he looks like freo’s designated kick out.

    0

    0
  26. At the moment, my main concerns are Wingard and Mumford…
    Wingards already dropping in price but I can’t afford to make another rookie trade.
    Mumford is a different story… Anyone else considering keeping him?

    Thumbs up – Definitely keep, he’s too good to trade out

    Thumbs down – No way, back injuries are too risky, he’s gone !

    0

    0
  27. Hey just wondering if anyone knows how to or if its even possible to do the following: I want to trade out Boumann from the backline and replace him with treloar in the forward line whilst changing smedts who i have in my forward line to my back line to cover boumann. Can this be done in one trade? if so how?

    0

    0
  28. N.Fyfe trade; Subbing him into the midfield and looking at these two guns.

    Who would you have?

    Thumbs Up – T.Rockliff ($577,400) (AV: 118) Next 3: GEEL, ESS, COLL

    Thumbs Down – J.P.Kennedy ($563,100) (AV: 124) Next 3: HAW, ADE, RICH

    Thanks ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  29. Would love a poll telling us how many of these posters are 1) under 18 (even under 15!) and 2) how many have actually played the game!

    Some of the comments posted are mind boggling!

    0

    0
  30. Traded Ledger > McDonald and Couch > Treloar… I know Couch may get game time soon and has good cash cow potential, but in the 2-3 weeks (or more) it takes for him to bubble, I will be milking other cows and his DPP lets me slot him in easily when he is ready to pop.

    0

    0
  31. got 500,000 on the side not sure to spend another trade yet considering im already down to 19 ๐Ÿ™ points ideas anything people my team has done all right but been hit with lots of injuries. have fyfe who should if not back this week i will be spewing and dempsey anyone no how long his out for?

    0

    0
  32. Just thinking preseason a team with these players would of looked not bad:
    Backs: Shaw, Carrazzo, Dempsey, Lake
    Mid: Ablett, Pentleburry (possibly out), Thomas, Ball, Morabito, Hodge
    Ruck: Mumford, Sandilands (possibly out),ย Leuenberger
    Forwards: Fyfe, LeCra, Goodes, Stevie J

    0

    0
  33. Do I trade out Hurley?
    He hasn’t been performing and now he’s probably out for 1-2 weeks
    If I do trade, who to?

    Help?

    0

    0
  34. Mumfords been averaging over 100 with an infection affecting his back… Once he’s all good he’s gonna be one SC machine, hopefully!

    0

    0
  35. So I’m trying to nut out a plan to pick up Pendles next week. One early downgrade this week. Another downgrade and a rookie up to Pendles next week. I’ve got porps, smith an Kennedy in mind. Who do we think is the smartest one to offload this week?

    0

    0
  36. Carrazzo out for malceski. $80k in the bank. Try and get Pendls next 2 weeks hopefully. Should I keep trade. Thanks guys

    0

    0
  37. Can anyone tell me how to calculate the break evens?
    Also if Pffiffer has another good game reckon its worth the trade
    for wingard?

    0

    0
  38. Hey Guys
    Trying to figure out what to do with stevie j, iv stuck with him thinking he’ll come good, but its starting to look more and more like didak all over again….

    Trade- Thumbs up
    Keep – Thumbs down

    who would be a good replacement?

    0

    0
  39. Anyone have any thoughts on how many trades left we should be aiming for. I’ve currently got 22, but thinking of using a couple this week.

    0

    0
  40. My team: 20 trades left, just shy of $200k in reserve

    SCTTL 20 trades left $46k left. I did note that in it’s public league my SCTTL team has a percentage of 147.11% (and not even a ton in the SCTTL#2) so yeah, they must be pretty bad! Ha! ๐Ÿ˜‰

    Holding fire in both teams. I hope. The only one I’d consider at the moment is Ledger to Old Mac, but I’m not going to do it. If Pendles is out too then I’ll be in a bit of a bother but I think I’d just have to bring in Clay Smith if he is around this week. But if he was out too I’d have to reconsider the Ledger thing. That’s a lot of ifs. My head hurts.

    0

    0
  41. 20 trades left is hapton to trelour a must in the midfield or should i hang onto hampton for a while?

    thumps up – trelour is a must!

    thumbs down – Hampton will come good, trades are gold!

    0

    0
  42. Questions to think ponder….
    Keep Ablett and hope for 1 week?
    Will Stanton get score 140 vs Pies?
    Is J-Mac a must (All my other rookies are making me stacks of cash already) !?

    Which option would you do?
    Ablett + S.Reid –> Stanton + Dahlhous/Tippett (Im sick of Reid already)
    Ablett + Shiel/Magner –> Stanton + Barlow (2 almost Premium mids)
    Shiel/Magner + Reid –> J-Mac + Dahlhous (Make some $$$)
    Sit tight on Ablett and just get J-mac in
    ————————————————————————————————-
    Deledio, Suckling, M.Clarke, Hombsch, S.Morris, Dempsey (Bower, Ellis)
    Gazza, S.Thompson, S.Selwood, JPKennedy, Masten, Magner (Shiel, C.Smith)
    Sandi, Hale (Giles, Redden)
    Franklin, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, Goodes, D.Martin, Fyfe, Reid (Kennedy, Hall)

    20 trades left….
    $110k cash spare….

    0

    0
  43. Apparently its been heard on radio in Perth that 211 confirmed to miss this weekend

    Dont know how reliable that is though. Someone posted over at TS

    0

    0
  44. hey guys

    what do you think of this trade
    S.Johnson – Treloar
    Coniglio – Stanton
    With Treloar expected to go up 80k+ next round

    T/U good trades
    T/D bad trades

    0

    0
  45. Carazzo for Michael Johnson (Freo)?
    And Coniglio for Josh P Kennedy (Swans)?
    Thumbs up for YES
    Thumbs down for NO

    0

    0
  46. traded hall out for treloar giving me my remaining salary cap at about 150 000.

    then in a few weeks when pendulbury continues to go down in price trade masten out for pendles that will leaves my mids at ablett,pendulbury,Watson,selwood and Boyd.

    0

    0
  47. I’m going to trade Kennedy (gws) out and tossing up between McDonald and treloar? Both set to have decent price rises, McDonald unlikely to play all games and relist being a dpp are making the decision harder…

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *