Sydney v North Melbourne at Giants Stadium, 4.20pm AEDT
SYDNEY
B: T.McCartin 30 D.Rampe 24 H.Cunningham 7
HB: J.McInerney 27 S.Reid 20 B.Campbell 16
C: J.Lloyd 44 J.Kennedy 12 N.Blakey 22
HF: I.Heeney 5 P.McCartin 39 E.Gulden 21
F: C.Warner 1 L.McDonald 6 W.Hayward 9
Foll: T.Hickey 31 L.Parker – C 26 J.Rowbottom 8
I/C: O.Florent 13 H.McLean 2 B.Ronke 25 C.Mills 14 D.Stephens 3 L.McAndrew 46 S.Wicks 15 M.Roberts 34
Emerg: A.Sheldrick 29 P.Ladhams 19 R.Fox 42 J.Bell 32
Notable absentees: Tom Papley, Lance Franklin
NORTH MELBOURNE
B: J.Ziebell – C 7 A.Corr 4 K.Turner 28
HB: L.McDonald 11 J.Walker 19 La.Young 17
C: B.Scott 8 H.Greenwood 18 J.Polec 13
HF: T.Thomas 26 N.Larkey 20 C.Taylor 5
F: J.Mahony 1 J.Stephenson 2 J.Horne-Francis 6
Foll: T.Xerri 38 L.Davies-Uniacke 9 J.Simpkin 12
I/C: T.Goldstein 22 T.Powell 24 W.Phillips 29 J.Goater 31 C.Lazzaro 35 K.Hayden 37 E.Ford 40 C.Zurhaar 44
Emerg: A.Bosenavulagi 15 P.Curtis 25 M.Bergman 27 P.Walker 33
Notable absentees: Jed Anderson
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Couple of watches for me here.
The three rookies Goater, DStephens & Roberts. Disappointed too not see Gould feature today. also watching Heeney for that midfield role and CBAs.
Interesting too see mills named I wonder if he’ll be on managed minutes. Hopefully not id like to see him play to get a true idea of the Sydney midfield
Sydney
3 Dylan Stephens $167.8k MID
34 Matty Roberts $117.3k MID
39 Paddy McCartin $157.8k DEF/FWD
North Melbourne
6 Jason Horne-Francis $207.3k MID
13 Jared Polec $246.9k MID
29 Will Phillips $260.9k MID/FWD
31 Josh Goater $117.3k MID
35 Charlie Lazzaro $201.4K FWD/MID
37 Kyron Hayden $199.6k DEF
38 Tristan Xerri $208.2k FWD
40 E Ford $206.8k FWD
Does anybody have any info on Charlie Comben ?. He was looking good early for rd1 start .
I believe his fallen down the pecking order behind xerri and CCJ. I wouldn’t be banking on him to play R1
Gidday M
thanks, makes the cheaper FWD rookies even harder
Heeney played this quarter FWD. No Franklin, Papley or Ladhams. Only 1 CBA so far as well.
Stephens found a fair amount of it but game has been pretty soft.
If heeneys not injected into that midfield asap for the remainder of the match I’m not touching him with a 10ft pole and he will be exiled from my team.
Yep me too, not worth the risk. Will upgrade him to treloar.
Heeney is a gun forward and is no longer welcome in my SC team.
i’ve always thought Heeney was a better forward than a midfielder
Treloar has a shoulder injury
Do you have a source for this?
I heard a vague reference that he went for scans for his shoulder but unable to verify?
Would be interested for any clarification?
The best source I’ve encountered is that Treloar was sent for scans on a pre-existing shoulder injury (Source: The Salty Bulldog – Twitter page)
Thanks, HC.
I saw The Salty Bulldog post but waiting for official confirmation.
Dusty ?
Ha ha.. Just jokes… Everyone nervous about Heeney . Horse isn’t even coaching. Swans know their game. All those Forwards missing. There just giving the kids a go in the middle , JPK back. Heeney has trained as a Mid all Preseason. Mills probably won’t play a full match. Heeney should see some mid time in the 2nd Half. I’m still on the Heeney train.
I am looking for a reason to not have him – I really don’t want injury-prone players this season!
I hear you Thommo.
All the forwards come with issues. Its him, Dusty or DeGoey ???
Or back a Breakout in Thomas or Bailey.
I’ll take Heeney thanks..
Dusty for me
I have been weary of Heeney (past owner). GD’s preseason write up on him was excellent, however, mid field minutes will be key for consistent high scoring.
Yes, Papley and Franklin not playing but Heeney is Horse’s go to man to push deep forward. He will snag a few goals which will help his scoring but won’t rack up big weekly scores playing a split role. Just because he trained with the mid group preseason doesn’t mean he will be stationed there full time.
Jury still out for me on Heeney because Syd play such a team orientated game. And likelihood of Franklin playing every game is doubtful as is Papely’s potential durability this season. And the much spoken about move of Mills to full time mid.
For me, De Goey or Treloar at this stage but they both have their issues also. Bring on round 1.
Good points T- Rex . My issue with Heeney has also been his durability in the past but seems to have had an injury free pre season . Still prefer Heeney to Martin and Trealor given injury sustained to Martin late last year and Trealor’s durability.
Agreed PBuzz.
I have De Goey at M2 ATM but and he didn’t set the world on fire (scoring wise) today). I reckon he has huge potential to consistently go big each week.
Heeney is making a bloody good case to be picked today though. Like GD – I just hope the Syd forward line solidifies come round 1.
As a Collingwood fan i’d love Degoey to star but still needs to be a consistent performer week in week out . Contract year and past indiscretions may be the motivation he needs .
Good luck in your final choice
Half time Supercoach Scores:
Isaac Heeney 76
Callum Mills 67
Jack Ziebell 64
Dylan Stephens 51
Jason Horne-Francis 50
Jake Lloyd 47
Paddy McCartin 45
Tarryn Thomas 27
lol. I’ve already got too many Swans in my team, but what the hell, one more won’t hurt.
Welcome to the Champs, Dylan.
Ha ha Chillo, how many is that now ?
I think I have 4 ?
Yep, same. Heeney, Lloyd, McCartin and now Stephens.
I am tempted to go Lloyd to Whitfield though, that extra 80K is going to be useful with the impending cowpocalypse
Yeah Chillo..
I’m desperate to hold onto 4 uber mids with Berry at M5.
JHF / Daicos/ Ward / Stephens. MacDonald . long.
The cows ( at least the cheap ones ) are looking dire. We may have to pay up for bench rookies ..
Something has to give.
I have both Lloyd (D1) and Whitfield ( D3)
My mystery D2 will be revealed in time 😉
Heeney has had more Mid time in the 2nd qtr then i’m guessing?
Moved on ball in the last 5 minutes of that quarter, yeah. 2x CBAs and up to stoppages.
Scores well anywhere when fit, just really want that MID role to materialize.
Hopefully the Swans key FWD stocks are replenished come Round 1.
Patty McCartin might be worth the risk down back with the way the Def rookies are looking right now.
He’s in my side Jam.
His DPP and probable JS make him too hard to pass up.
Yep same here FT, this I popped him in after the last practice games with a mix of other rooks dropping off the list and the scarcity of any others who look like they are locked in for round 1.
Hopefully he keeps the floating back role that be seems to be playing.
As long as he stays fit he has the style of game to score ok in that role
Hey FT & Jam,
Hoping O’Driscoll can cement a spot with Freo – $34k less and currently D7 for me. Got Sinn at D6 ATM, same price as McCartin.
Thoughts on JS for McCartin v Sinn v O’Driscoll?
I was keen on O’Driscoll, but with him missing today’s game has warning bells ringing loudly.
Was only named as an emergency.
CT and T Rex.
Its with a heavy heart I have had to drop O’Driscoll.
He will get a game at some stage this year. It seems Brodie is ahead of him 🙁
I have Gibcus and Sinn D5-6
McCartin and Rachelle F5-6
And that includes 8 on the benches, so really not quite next in line even.
T-Rex I’m also actually a little concerned about Sinn’s JS after only playing a half yesterday. Came on late and did some nice things but doesn’t fill with confidence of a round 1 berth in a team vying for top 4 again.
He sits D5 for me at the moment but I’m not confident he will be named round 1
Gents,
Yep, my thinking as well for Sinn. I brought in Gibcus at D5 yesterday and likely to replace Sinn with McCartin at D6.
The D bench is a worry with few likely starters.
Got Rachelle at F5 and Durdin or Macginess (Haw) at F6. Again F bench is a worry.
Just need a couple of low priced rookies to materialise. Too many potential non playing bench rookies ATM.
What do we think of Lloyd? They don’t seem to be going through him as much as first thought.
Looks fine to me? TOG a little ass but hasn’t been a whole for him to do tbh.
Lloyd is taking the piss. He is not in defence. Playing on the wing, running fwd..don’t read anything on this game. He is letting the kids have a run
Anyone considering Mills?! Seeing Him and Josh Kelly today makes it a bit tempting to go for a cheaper premo to fit in all these expensive rookies. I know it’s a trap (Kelly, not Mills), but it’s tempting
Mills was locked in my team in the pre-pre-season. then his injury. won’t risk him now.
M
Try not to judge Premo’s on preseason games. Lloyd will be fine.
On another note no Hollands named for Gold Coast tomorrow which is a shame as his availability as a rookie forward could have helped solidify backline rookie shortage with an extra premium down back
Has anyone had a look at who their “choices” are up against in round 1……..
Final Supercoach Scores
Justin McInerney 127
Isaac Heeney 113
James Rowbottom 110
Tristan Xerri 96
Jason Horne-Francis 86
Jake Lloyd 83
Paddy McCartin 74
Dylan Stephens 63
Heeney knocks out 113 and everyone’s scrambling to get him out of their team due to role.
Wild, huh? Fitness is much more important than role for Heeney. He’s had multiple seasons of averaging 90+ as a full time forward. If he can stay on the field, then extra midfield time is just the icing on the cake.
Who would you choose for around 450000?
TU: Heeney
TD: Sicily
Comment: Cripps
Looks like the Lizard will be taking Dawsons role a lazy 19 kicks, 9hballs, 5mks and almost 600 metres gained in 80% TOG for an attractive 115 in SC @325k he could make 150k just as fast as any of high priced rookies