Progress Scores – Rd5

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 22 2018

Where do you stand with one game left to go?

Score / # of players played / VC or C

1
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

109 thoughts on “Progress Scores – Rd5”

  1. 233/2/Heeney VC into Fyfe

    Loving the consistency of Heeney and Laird. Ruing overthinking the bench options figuring Swans would grind their way through on the small confines of the SGC and Doedee would not get a run at it and Bonner would at Home. Oh well, Bonner still may!!

    Heeney VC score ??

    4

    2
  2. When will we know if Fritsch is definitely playing VFL tomorrow? Need to know because if he does I’ll be able to VC Fyfe/Danger into Gawn. Cheers

    1

    1
      1. I don’t think VFL teams work the same as AFL; being named on-field doesn’t mean you’re definitely playing. Not 100% on that though.

        2

        0
        1. Fritsch was also named on field for Melbourne’s VFL side in the previous rounds but he still played for Melbourne in the AFL.

          2

          0
    1. Currently have Fritsch, Giles-Langdon and Ryan. With Melbourne not naming teams until Monday, I might have to go early and trade Ryan to Guelfi. Otherwise I can wait and do Fritsch to Guelfi on Monday if he’s not named, but feel like thats a waste given Fritsch still has money to make. Melbourne has lots of competition between small forwards (Garlett, Fritsch, Bugg, Hannan, Kent, Kennedy Harris, Harmes, Melksham, Spargo), so if he’s dropped he may go to the back of the queue.

      TU: Trade Ryan to Guelfi today
      TD: Trade Fritsch to Guelfi on Tuesday if he’s not named

      (There’s no way for me to get Coffield with one trade)

      13

      0
  3. top of the morning lads.. sorry I know this isn’t the right place but last week I traded out Stephenson but I was flummoxed to see that 840 coaches traded out Doedee this week.. not as bad as my stupid move last week but jeez why, 1 so so game in conditions that didn’t suit him last week, he’s been very good for the Crows..

    9

    0
  4. Buddy as VC was a mistake, although FUJL is going to become a thing if he allows Buddy to keep getting double teamed like that

    0

    0
    1. I feel your pain.
      Robbie Gray 146 rd 4
      Buddy 146 Rd 4 plus rd 5
      Guess who traded Lambert for Buddy last week ?
      Grrrrr.

      0

      0
      1. Tossed up Grey versus Hogan. Went Hogan.

        Pain is my middle name this year.

        On the upside had Zac Fisher rather than trading him out so that was a nice little bonus.

        Waterman to JJK straight swap in a few weeks?

        1

        0
  5. 1430/12/Fyfe C

    Hoping for my highest score for the year and hopefully crack into the top 10,000 sitting just outside ATM

    2

    0
  6. I’d be happy with mid 23’s TBH. I rekn Mitchell and Martin won’t pump out huge scores this week, hoping I’m wrong but!!

    1

    0
  7. 1384/13/Cripps

    Finding it hard to judge what a good score will be this week.

    Dunkley 42 (who i’ve been happy with so far) and Waterman 44 the let downs so far, the rest acceptable or great
    May look at bringing in Sicily if he goes well again this week

    2

    0
    1. You would have to be happy with that and happy you chose Cripps.
      Also have Dunkley and will have decisions to make in next few weeks. Bulldog forwards didn’t have much of a chance in this game.
      Have luxury of having Dunkley at fwd 6
      and Garlett and Fritsch on bench but don’t own Gray or Heeney.

      1

      0
      1. 1299/15/Fyfe
        Lucky I chose Fyfe , however still set for avearage score as my players with relatively low ownership ,
        Dunkley, McLean, Savage have not done well this week. Can’t complain as these players are part of reason I am in the 300’s so far.
        Zorko will make or break how many of my leagues I will win this week, and ironically how Tich and Dusty and Gawn perform . Own all however all set to be captains choices for many .
        Good luck all and enjoy ride

        1

        0
  8. 1,180 / 13 / Undecided
    Embarassed to post this score here.
    Buddy vc and Garlett on field.
    With the Jacobs tag on Mitchell who is the better captain option:
    T/u Dusty
    T/d Gawn

    3

    10
  9. 1277/12 ( capt martin Mitchell or gawn)
    Mitchell s martin petrecca fritsch (Stephenson) hibbered gawn d martin smith Holman

    0

    0
  10. Hey guys,

    I’ve been playing SC for a few years now but have never really grasped the old loophole option.

    Hoping someone can get me on the straight and narrow.

    This week I’ve got the C on Stef Martin and the VC on Fyfe.

    I am keen to take Fyfe’s score so would I be correct in saying that if I were to move the C on to Bailey Fritsch (assuming he does not play, I will keep an eye on final teams on Tuesday night) that I will get Fyfe’s score as my C?

    Thanks heaps guys, sorry if my wording is a little cloudy.

    7

    0
  11. T/u take danger’s 135
    T/d risk titch or dusty
    also because of device issues I couldn’t bring on keefe for naughton to take doedee.is it unwise to trade in a future def to take doedees score?

    21

    3
  12. 1367 / 13 / Fyfe

    So Fyfe paid off.

    I’ve had a lot more individual performers this week, but been screwed by others.

    – Franklin
    – Garlett
    – Henry
    – McLean

    Henry has been terrible since I moved him in. Garlett is on my most hated list, McLean I moved in for Billings this week and am disappointed for doing it with his score.

    2

    1
  13. 14/1394/Gawn

    Projected 2266.

    Brought in Gray this week for Fritsch and Mirra (yes yes I know) for Guthrie who had been absolutely pissing on the field the last two weeks. Has been my worst start to a season travelling at 40K 0/a.

    Hopefully this will be change required to kickstart the season again….now with a full-premo forward line IMO.

    1

    0
  14. With Fritsch, if he does line up for Casey, they play this afternoon. Will he be locked out if he does play for them or is it only from when the Dee’s game starts?
    Hoping he is dropped to Casey so I can get Fyfe’s VC score. Miscalculated with my non-playing players.

    1

    0
    1. He’ll only lock out on Tuesday night. In theory, he could play today for Casey and then Tues night as well.

      3

      0
    2. News is Fritsch not playing for Casey today.

      Could still be named. they also may just hold him back as an emergency.

      Those hoping to loophole Fyfe beware.

      3

      0
  15. 1554 / 15 / Fyfe is Life.

    Dusty, Titch, Hibberd, Smith, Gawn and Murray.

    Hoping for 2300+

    I really need it after a couple of average weeks.

    currently ranked 22 242.

    2

    0
  16. 1336/12/ S Coniglio
    T Kelly, B Banfield and J Henry only players under 85 currently.
    S Coniglio, N Fyfe, I Heeney, S Lycett and K Simpson with 115+.

    Left to play: T Mitchell, J Sicily, A Christensen, N Holman, D Martin, C Oliver, M Gawn, S Murray, D Smith and M Hurley.

    Hoping for a score around 2300 to 2400.

    4

    0
    1. I’ve got the same dilemma. My opponent has tich as captain, and no dusty at all. I’m not sure whether to match him or go all out?

      2

      0
  17. Absolute c#^* of a day!! F#$^ing dogarse c#^* of a computer shit itself,f#$^ing phone wouldn’t let me do the necessary adjustments to take fyfe as captain,stuck with titch!!
    And I follow hawthorn.F#$^ me!!!!!

    10

    0
      1. Thanks nonna, I really felt down yesterday, its like my whole world was falling apart, sc means the world to me. At the end of the day though, you just gotta put things in perspective, the homeless, cancer sufferers ..etc, my bad day pales into insignificance

        4

        0
        1. Agreed… Sooo frustrating but we are all in the same boat – just have to ride the highs with the lows and learn those little lessons for next time.
          I had Gray’s awesome score (after pulling the trigger on J Kelly and nearly choosing Macrae) and the low of VC Buddy (and I knew Crows def would double team him, ignored my gut!)… 1413/16 w Capt Dusty to come… v average 😐
          Good luck with the rest of your round.

          0

          0
  18. 1884/19/Danger

    Looks reasonable on paper but 8 scores so far of 70’s or less if you include Garlett’s 21 if Fritsch doesn’t play.

    Almost balancing the ledger is 8 scores of 110 or more. Dusty, Max and Murray to play and touch and go in most leagues. Downside of that is half my opponents have Max or Dusty as Captain. Only one I will win for certain had Titch as Captain.

    1

    0
  19. 1741 / 17 / coniglio vc loophole
    I have gawn/nank/petracca/murray & Smith left.
    Hope they all go huge…
    Pred 2217 so need some big scores

    1

    0
  20. 1636/17/Dusty coming in as captain

    Have Gawn, Smith, Hurley and Murray to come in as well as Dusty (let’s hope he can go big).

    1

    0
  21. 1876/17/Danger
    And this includes Garletts 21, wasn’t happy with that, but Dusty, Gawn, Hibberd, Murray and D Smith to come; aiming for the 2300 mark

    2

    0
  22. Just thinking buddy for heeney or smith.
    Feedback please.
    Can someone go through the abbreviations
    And is there any reason to have player listed as f1 f2 etc.
    Only new to sc(supercoach ) got that one.
    Thanks

    0

    1
    1. Forward_f
      Defence_d etc
      The number is their position on super coach field. I.e r1,r2 and r3 are rucks from left to right.
      More value placed on lower numbered players.

      1

      0
  23. 1820 / 18 / Dusty

    Still to come – Dusty (c), Gawn, Petracca, Murray

    Getting in Gray and Cogs as a double ‘sideways’ trade worked brilliantly this round.

    Projected score is 2331. Should be enough to beat The Salamander in the Contributors League and should see me leading Matteo in our SCT Cup H2H.

    1

    0
  24. 1853/17/Cogs

    Very happy so far premos scoring well. Garlett was a letdown fielded. Loving the Gray trade for Billings not looking back at all.

    I took Cogs score over Dusty hopefully doesn’t turn back to bite me if Dusty goes huge but i’m reasonable happy with 116 from him.

    Projected 2314 with 3 premos and 2 rooks to go 🙂

    1

    0
  25. 1691/16/Fyfe

    Loving my decision to trade out Billings for Robbie Gray, not happy with my decision to field Garlett instead of Henry, although his 48 hopefully won’t make much difference.

    I took a chance on Fyfe as captain as was worried about the tag on T Mitchell & Dusty’s prior form against Melbourne, but disappointingly not one of my opponents this week went T Mitchell as Captain. All 9 of my leagues still to close to call.

    Projected 2283

    4

    0
  26. 1710/16/Fyfe

    Benched Sicily to use Fritsch as my loophole (yes I know, very silly) so I’ve factored Sicily’s score as emergency and Fyfes extra 151 into my score otherwise I’m 1436 from 15

    0

    0
  27. 1428 with 7 players remaining along with Dusty as captain. Should get around 2200 but dont think that’ll keep me in the top 10k.

    1

    0
  28. 1921/20/Titch. Projected 2087 (Murray, Smith)

    Looking like Buddy’s gonna cause me heartache with his injury.

    Did NOT want to have to sideways trade yet another premo

    3

    0
  29. I am currently receiving the mother of all hidings from Father Dougal this week. Maybe I’m dreaming but I think he could go close to the Round top score.

    3

    0
      1. Posted my team in the Trade Talk thread. Not even close to too proud to hear advice!

        Leaning towards Bonner and Garlett to Deledio and Jack Higgins……

        0

        0
    1. Thanks mate. My internal monologue this week has been “Stupid Priest, messed up the Captaincy, gonna pay for that.” (Ended up leaving the VC on Coniglio) I probably will pay for it, but perhaps not as much as I first thought.

      1

      0
      1. And 20, not 19. It would appear that I need a bit more practice at counting.

        In my defence, it was 3 AM.

        3

        0
  30. 1,997, Titch, 19

    Still got grundy, murray and smith to play.
    Wondering what could have been if I didnt switch my captain from gawn to titch 2 min before the hawsk game 🙁

    1

    0
  31. 2163/20/Gawn
    Projected 2341 which should be enough to improve in the rankings.
    Pendles and Murray to come, will have my eye on Zerret today. Couple of Fallin premiums in the gun, Yeo being the other. Higgins might be a good downgrade target if Mirra gets the flick .
    2341

    3

    0
  32. 2143/20/Gawn

    Murray and D Smith to come. I just may crack 2,300 for the first time this season and lift the Bratpack from the doldrums after Gawn sent the C button last night into overdrive.

    Made up for Caddy pulling out again and having to cop Gowers score.

    3

    0
  33. 1912/19/Oliver

    A lot of areas could be going better again. The plan I’m sticking to heavily of the ‘no premo’ trades and conserve the ‘1up1down’ trades for now is biting me in the butt a bit. That and missing the supreme C scores for the last 3 weeks has me in ‘meh’ form. Still a chance for a decent return with Merrett, Murray and D. Smith to come.

    The only thing keeping the vibe positive is seeing that I still have 28 trades left!

    (It’s hard sticking to this ‘first time’ game plan of trade conservation, but it was a heavy focus during the preseason and I can take it as another positive that I’ve got the will power to stick true to that. The mind is right, the results are difficult to take, but I’m the coach for the job to move this team along!)

    2

    0
    1. 1890/cripps
      Hurley, Murray, Smith and Guelfi to come

      What is the point with the live ladders in SC? Surely a waste of space that serves no purpose other than to give you a false indication of where you will sit once the round finishes.

      4

      0
  34. 2146/20/Fyfe.

    D.Smith and S.Murray to play proj 2312. Currently 3893 overall so hoping to improve on that. Could have been better if not for Fritsch omission and having to take Garlett’s 21 yuck! Have 28 trades left and 150k in the bank so there is hope.

    3

    0
  35. 2022 / Fyfe / 20 played.

    Smith and Murray to come.

    Heros: Gawn, Cripps, Fyfe.

    Good: Cogs, Mundy, Westhoff,Laird, Doedee,

    Ok: Holman, Finlayson.

    I can forgive Titch Dusty and Mclean after a great start to the season. The rest of my boys need to lift!

    Hibberd is really starting to test my mettle.
    He started well (25 at 1/4 time)before getting smacked in the face and dropping off badly.

    Why didn’t we know Buddy has been playing Injured since round 1?
    He hasn’t even been training. 🙁

    I’m hoping for close to 2200.

    1

    0
  36. 1834,16,Dangerfield
    Zerrett, Hurley, Grundy, Dev Smith, Murray & Guelfi to play.
    projected is 2353 but surely zerrett will pump out more than 67?
    Could be looking at a juicy 2400 everything goes allright…

    1

    3
    1. To be honest Ollie that score will be uuuge! I’m tipping with those players left you’ll be 2400 +..Good work!!

      1

      0
  37. 1939/Fyfe/20 played
    Jets: Fyfe,Cripps,Gawn
    Guns:Laird,Doedee,Cogs,Oliver
    Peashooters:Buddy,Greene,Titch,Hibberd
    Honourable Mention:Finlayson,Holman

    2

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *