Scoring Anomalies – Round 23

As promised last week, I’ve run the numbers on the scores from Round 23. As usual, simply type the name of the player you want to look up into the table below to see how they were affected by scaling on the weekend; for a more in-depth breakdown, download the spreadsheets attached at the bottom of this post.

 

Name	Club	Raw	Linear-Scaled	Actual	Difference
Ben Keays	ADEL	210	173	173	0
Nic Naitanui	WCE	192.5	153	165	12
Ollie Wines	PORT	200	158	161	3
Max Gawn	MELB	199.5	157	159	2
Clayton Oliver	MELB	211.5	167	159	-8
Jordan Dawson	SYD	188	148	158	10
Jake Lloyd	SYD	175	137	154	17
Callan Ward	GWS	182	148	150	2
Rory Laird	ADEL	202.5	166	149	-17
Devon Smith	ESS	161	134	148	14
Touk Miller	GCFC	197	155	148	-7
Tarryn Thomas	NMFC	179	147	139	-8
Aaron Hall	NMFC	143.5	118	139	21
Isaac Heeney	SYD	158	124	135	11
Travis Boak	PORT	156.5	123	134	11
Lachie Neale	BL	172.5	137	133	-4
Jack Steele	STK	155	127	129	2
Mark Blicavs	GEEL	123.5	97	128	31
Nic Newman	CARL	153	125	128	3
Lance Franklin	SYD	126.5	99	127	28
Tom Mitchell	HAW	167.5	131	127	-4
Robbie Gray	PORT	153	121	126	5
Tom Hickey	SYD	171.5	135	126	-9
Jake Lever	MELB	156	123	126	3
Josh Kelly	GWS	153.5	125	124	-1
Luke Shuey	WCE	153	121	123	2
Jaeger O'Meara	HAW	158	124	120	-4
Zach Merrett	ESS	134.5	112	120	8
Rowan Marshall	STK	165.5	136	120	-16
Kieran Strachan	ADEL	161.5	133	119	-14
Daniel Rich	BL	159	126	119	-7
Joel Selwood	GEEL	166.5	131	118	-13
Nick Coffield	STK	128.5	105	117	12
Scott Lycett	PORT	136.5	108	117	9
Chad Wingard	HAW	157	123	117	-6
Jayden Short	RICH	138.5	108	117	9
Harry Schoenberg	ADEL	147	121	115	-6
Cameron Guthrie	GEEL	142	112	115	3
Ed Curnow	CARL	134	109	113	4
Rory Sloane	ADEL	144.5	119	113	-6
Jarryd Lyons	BL	157	124	113	-11
Jamie Elliott	COLL	130	108	113	5
Jack Macrae	WB	141.5	112	113	1
Andrew Brayshaw	FRE	144.5	118	112	-6
Hayden Young	FRE	124.5	102	112	10
Zak Jones	STK	137	112	112	0
Ned McHenry	ADEL	128	105	111	6
Chris Mayne	COLL	130.5	109	110	1
Luke Parker	SYD	138.5	109	110	1
Caleb Daniel	WB	132.5	105	110	5
Jacob Hopper	GWS	133	109	110	1
Jack Higgins	STK	120.5	99	109	10
Dayne Zorko	BL	143.5	114	109	-5
Connor Rozee	PORT	123	97	108	11
Tom Lynch	ADEL	124.5	102	107	5
George Hewett	SYD	126.5	99	106	7
Jake Stringer	ESS	121.5	101	105	4
Jack Madgen	COLL	111	93	104	11
Caleb Serong	FRE	146.5	120	103	-17
Taylor Adams	COLL	140.5	117	103	-14
Blake Hardwick	HAW	117	92	103	11
Alex Witherden	WCE	117.5	93	103	10
Ben McEvoy	HAW	132.5	104	102	-2
Jonathon Ceglar	HAW	132	103	102	-1
Tom J. Lynch	RICH	122.5	96	102	6
Jordan De Goey	COLL	112.5	94	102	8
Sam Taylor	GWS	114.5	93	101	8
Tom Cutler	ESS	125	104	101	-3
Jack Sinclair	STK	119.5	98	101	3
Bailey Dale	WB	112.5	89	101	12
Jack Henry	GEEL	112.5	89	100	11
Jack Ross	RICH	139	109	100	-9
Tom Hawkins	GEEL	118	93	100	7
Shane McAdam	ADEL	117	96	100	4
Daniel Howe	HAW	132.5	104	100	-4
Conor Nash	HAW	126	99	99	0
Peter Wright	ESS	107.5	90	99	9
Luke Ryan	FRE	128	105	99	-6
Brodie Smith	ADEL	121	99	98	-1
Isaac Smith	GEEL	119	94	98	4
Charlie Cameron	BL	118.5	94	98	4
Mitch Crowden	FRE	128.5	105	97	-8
Tom De Koning	CARL	130.5	106	97	-9
Elliot Yeo	WCE	138	109	97	-12
Jack Crisp	COLL	113	94	97	3
Nick Hind	ESS	129.5	108	97	-11
Mason Redman	ESS	129	108	97	-11
Lachie Fogarty	CARL	113.5	93	96	3
Oscar McInerney	BL	130	103	96	-7
Dyson Heppell	ESS	124.5	104	96	-8
Justin McInerney	SYD	137	108	95	-13
Errol Gulden	SYD	118	93	95	2
Jesse Hogan	GWS	101.5	83	95	12
Kysaiah Pickett	MELB	112.5	89	94	5
Noah Anderson	GCFC	120	94	94	0
Jimmy Webster	STK	102	84	94	10
Jack Viney	MELB	107	84	94	10
Christian Salem	MELB	108	85	94	9
Jacob Weitering	CARL	116	95	94	-1
Zac Bailey	BL	118.5	94	92	-2
David Mackay	ADEL	113.5	93	92	-1
Daniel McStay	BL	124	98	92	-6
Tim Taranto	GWS	125	102	92	-10
Trent McKenzie	PORT	121.5	96	91	-5
James Harmes	MELB	121	95	91	-4
Tom Papley	SYD	106	83	91	8
Ryan Burton	PORT	105	83	90	7
Harry Perryman	GWS	117	95	90	-5
Jamie Cripps	WCE	97.5	77	89	12
Toby Greene	GWS	103	84	89	5
Joe Daniher	BL	95.5	76	88	12
Brayden Fiorini	GCFC	112.5	88	88	0
Keidean Coleman	BL	109	86	87	1
Sam Walsh	CARL	110.5	90	87	-3
Brad Crouch	STK	120.5	99	87	-12
Jy Simpkin	NMFC	118.5	97	87	-10
Rhys Stanley	GEEL	116	91	86	-5
Jed Anderson	NMFC	97.5	80	86	6
Will Snelling	ESS	93.5	78	86	8
Liam Stocker	CARL	108	88	85	-3
Aliir Aliir	PORT	111	88	85	-3
Paul Seedsman	ADEL	103.5	85	85	0
Karl Amon	PORT	124	98	85	-13
Christian Petracca	MELB	110.5	87	85	-2
Brandan Parfitt	GEEL	114.5	90	85	-5
Kieren Briggs	GWS	111	91	84	-7
Lachie Henderson	GEEL	113	89	84	-5
Darcy Byrne-Jones	PORT	103	81	84	3
Andrew McGrath	ESS	109	91	84	-7
Jarrod Berry	BL	118.5	94	84	-10
Xavier Duursma	PORT	99	78	83	5
Brodie Grundy	COLL	102.5	85	83	-2
Callum Mills	SYD	89	70	83	13
Josh Rotham	WCE	103	82	83	1
Bailey Smith	WB	116	92	82	-10
Zac Smith	GCFC	114	89	82	-7
David Astbury	RICH	116	91	82	-9
Sam Frost	HAW	102.5	80	82	2
Alec Waterman	ESS	102	85	82	-3
Steven May	MELB	93.5	74	81	7
Sam Menegola	GEEL	109	86	81	-5
Lachie Hunter	WB	105.5	83	81	-2
Nick Haynes	GWS	87	71	81	10
Harry Himmelberg	GWS	97.5	80	81	1
Dan Houston	PORT	111.5	88	81	-7
Jack Scrimshaw	HAW	123.5	97	81	-16
Nick Larkey	NMFC	91.5	75	80	5
Jordan Ridley	ESS	103.5	86	80	-6
Dylan Grimes	RICH	110.5	86	80	-6
Adam Treloar	WB	113	89	80	-9
Dean Kent	STK	93.5	77	80	3
Shai Bolton	RICH	95.5	75	80	5
Andrew McPherson	ADEL	97	80	80	0
Isaac Cumming	GWS	106.5	87	79	-8
James Worpel	HAW	101	79	79	0
Liam Ryan	WCE	90	71	79	8
Riley Thilthorpe	ADEL	90.5	74	79	5
Todd Goldstein	NMFC	109	90	79	-11
Kamdyn McIntosh	RICH	98	77	79	2
Griffin Logue	FRE	94	77	79	2
Oliver Florent	SYD	105.5	83	79	-4
Josh Daicos	COLL	91.5	76	78	2
Dom Sheed	WCE	95.5	76	78	2
Riley Bonner	PORT	114.5	90	78	-12
Daniel Rioli	RICH	100.5	79	77	-2
Jack Riewoldt	RICH	79.5	62	77	15
Tom Jonas	PORT	112	88	77	-11
Nick Vlastuin	RICH	100.5	79	77	-2
Jack Graham	RICH	108.5	85	77	-8
Matt Guelfi	ESS	93.5	78	77	-1
Matthew Kennedy	CARL	104	85	76	-9
Max Holmes	GEEL	99.5	78	76	-2
Zach Sproule	GWS	92	75	76	1
Zac Fisher	CARL	86.5	71	76	5
Luke Davies-Uniacke	NMFC	91.5	75	75	0
Steele Sidebottom	COLL	97	81	75	-6
Josh Thomas	COLL	92	77	75	-2
Tom Liberatore	WB	95.5	75	75	0
Brandon Starcevich	BL	98	78	74	-4
Jack Bytel	STK	99.5	82	74	-8
Robbie Tarrant	NMFC	81.5	67	74	7
Tim Membrey	STK	94	77	74	-3
Luke McDonald	NMFC	65.5	54	74	20
Darcy Parish	ESS	91	76	74	-2
Patrick Dangerfield	GEEL	100	79	73	-6
Jack Darling	WCE	80	63	73	10
Tim O'Brien	HAW	93.5	73	73	0
Roarke Smith	WB	94	74	73	-1
Travis Colyer	FRE	77.5	64	72	8
Lincoln McCarthy	BL	92	73	72	-1
Jack Lukosius	GCFC	82	64	71	7
Brayden Cook	ADEL	82	67	71	4
James Stewart	ESS	82.5	69	71	2
Callum Wilkie	STK	88.5	73	71	-2
Paul Hunter	STK	82	67	71	4
Dougal Howard	STK	78	64	71	7
Matt Rowell	GCFC	100	78	70	-8
Levi Casboult	CARL	86.5	71	70	-1
Luke Dahlhaus	GEEL	83	65	70	5
Marcus Adams	BL	107	85	70	-15
Jayden Laverde	ESS	93	78	70	-8
Taylor Duryea	WB	84	66	69	3
Dane Rampe	SYD	93	73	69	-4
Alex Pearce	FRE	76.5	63	69	6
Jamaine Jones	WCE	76	60	69	9
Curtis Taylor	NMFC	90	74	68	-6
David Mundy	FRE	84	69	68	-1
Dylan Shiel	ESS	91.5	76	68	-8
Lachie Whitfield	GWS	77	63	68	5
Sam Collins	GCFC	84	66	68	2
Jake Kolodjashnij	GEEL	82.5	65	68	3
Dan Butler	STK	85.5	70	68	-2
Ryan Lester	BL	85	67	67	0
Adam Saad	CARL	98.5	80	67	-13
Marcus Bontempelli	WB	93.5	74	67	-7
Lewis Melican	SYD	68	53	67	14
Riley Collier-Dawkins	RICH	85	66	66	0
Jaxon Prior	BL	90	71	66	-5
Matt de Boer	GWS	78	64	66	2
Josh Dunkley	WB	93.5	74	66	-8
Lachlan Bramble	HAW	86.5	68	65	-3
Lachlan Murphy	ADEL	70	58	65	7
Jaidyn Stephenson	NMFC	88.5	73	65	-8
Lochie O'Brien	CARL	78.5	64	65	1
Ben King	GCFC	70	55	65	10
Liam Shiels	HAW	80	63	65	2
David Swallow	GCFC	97.5	77	65	-12
Jeremy Cameron	GEEL	77	61	65	4
Bailey Williams	WB	80	63	65	2
Sydney Stack	RICH	92	72	64	-8
Liam Henry	FRE	78.5	64	64	0
Shaun Burgoyne	HAW	73	57	64	7
Jordan Roughead	COLL	71.5	60	64	4
Andrew Gaff	WCE	73.5	58	64	6
Daniel McKenzie	STK	69	57	64	7
Harry Morrison	HAW	75	59	63	4
Connor Idun	GWS	72.5	59	63	4
Brandon Walker	FRE	79.5	65	63	-2
Dan Hannebery	STK	75	61	63	2
Mitch McGovern	CARL	80	65	63	-2
Tom Barrass	WCE	85	67	63	-4
Tom Phillips	HAW	77.5	61	63	2
Lewis Young	WB	83.5	66	63	-3
Mitch Hannan	WB	84	66	62	-4
Luke Foley	WCE	70	56	62	6
Cody Weightman	WB	72	57	62	5
Alex Davies	GCFC	88	69	62	-7
Bradley Hill	STK	60.5	50	62	12
Darcy Cameron	COLL	67.5	56	62	6
Aaron Francis	ESS	56	47	62	15
Darcy MacPherson	GCFC	81.5	64	62	-2
Oliver Hanrahan	HAW	71.5	56	61	5
Charlie Spargo	MELB	77	61	61	0
Todd Marshall	PORT	73	58	61	3
James Rowbottom	SYD	78.5	62	61	-1
Lachie Ash	GWS	78.5	64	61	-3
Grant Birchall	BL	84.5	67	61	-6
Alex Neal-Bullen	MELB	96.5	76	61	-15
Angus Brayshaw	MELB	72	57	61	4
Tom Wilson	COLL	57	48	61	13
Sean Darcy	FRE	64.5	53	61	8
Tom Sparrow	MELB	76	60	61	1
Harry Edwards	WCE	65.5	52	60	8
Jarrod Harbrow	GCFC	81.5	64	60	-4
James Aish	FRE	69.5	57	60	3
Sam Switkowski	FRE	56.5	46	60	14
Ben Long	STK	70.5	58	60	2
Peter Ladhams	PORT	69	54	60	6
John Noble	COLL	68.5	57	59	2
Bayley Fritsch	MELB	60	47	59	12
Hayden McLean	SYD	83.5	66	59	-7
Tobe Watson	FRE	76	62	59	-3
Chayce Jones	ADEL	62.5	51	59	8
Tyler Brockman	HAW	72	56	59	3
Harry Cunningham	SYD	73	57	59	2
Brad Close	GEEL	92	72	59	-13
Hugh McCluggage	BL	87	69	58	-11
Jeremy Howe	COLL	70	58	58	0
Tom Atkins	GEEL	85	67	58	-9
Archie Perkins	ESS	63	53	57	4
Alex Keath	WB	66.5	52	57	5
Patrick Cripps	CARL	67.5	55	57	2
Tom McCartin	SYD	78.5	62	56	-6
Eddie Betts	CARL	60	49	56	7
Colin O'Riordan	SYD	65	51	56	5
Liam Baker	RICH	61	48	55	7
Laitham Vandermeer	WB	75	59	55	-4
Shaun Atley	NMFC	71.5	59	55	-4
Trent Dumont	NMFC	67.5	55	55	0
Jake Waterman	WCE	68	54	55	1
Dylan Clarke	ESS	67	56	55	-1
Jy Farrar	GCFC	80.5	63	55	-8
Callum Coleman-Jones	RICH	80.5	63	54	-9
Mitch Lewis	HAW	67	52	54	2
Matt Taberner	FRE	63	52	54	2
Ed Langdon	MELB	78.5	62	54	-8
Jason Castagna	RICH	57	45	54	9
Charlie Curnow	CARL	57.5	47	54	7
Tom Doedee	ADEL	68.5	56	53	-3
Josh Corbett	GCFC	55.5	44	53	9
Rory Atkins	GCFC	72	57	53	-4
Nakia Cockatoo	BL	62.5	50	53	3
Mabior Chol	RICH	68.5	54	53	-1
Brodie Kemp	CARL	59	48	52	4
Adam Kennedy	GWS	69	56	52	-4
Lachie Plowman	CARL	64	52	52	0
Chris Burgess	GCFC	79.5	62	51	-11
Jed Bews	GEEL	64	50	51	1
Ben Ainsworth	GCFC	85	67	51	-16
Mark O'Connor	GEEL	69	54	50	-4
Tanner Bruhn	GWS	64	52	50	-2
Ben Davis	ADEL	46	38	50	12
Oscar Clavarino	STK	54	44	49	5
Ben Miller	RICH	51.5	40	49	9
Tim English	WB	61	48	49	1
Charlie Ballard	GCFC	64	50	49	-1
Jack Newnes	CARL	61.5	50	49	-1
Lloyd Meek	FRE	74	61	48	-13
Harrison Petty	MELB	59	46	48	2
Steven Motlop	PORT	62.5	49	48	-1
Jackson Nelson	WCE	60.5	48	48	0
Zak Butters	PORT	64	50	47	-3
Xavier O'Halloran	GWS	55	45	47	2
Will Martyn	RICH	60.5	47	47	0
Will Phillips	NMFC	61.5	51	47	-4
Brayden Maynard	COLL	50	42	47	5
Darcy Fogarty	ADEL	45.5	37	47	10
Sam Simpson	GEEL	53	42	46	4
Miles Bergman	PORT	69.5	55	46	-9
Nathan Vardy	WCE	57	45	46	1
Jarrod Brander	WCE	60	48	45	-3
Jake Bowey	MELB	70	55	45	-10
Jason Johannisen	WB	54	43	45	2
Billy Frampton	ADEL	57.5	47	45	-2
Zaine Cordy	WB	53	42	45	3
Marlion Pickett	RICH	70.5	55	45	-10
Will Hayward	SYD	67.5	53	45	-8
Willem Drew	PORT	60.5	48	44	-4
Joel Smith	MELB	49	39	44	5
Oscar Allen	WCE	56	44	44	0
Jordon Butts	ADEL	63	52	44	-8
Ben Brown	MELB	64.5	51	44	-7
Tom Williamson	CARL	57	47	44	-3
Sam Wicks	SYD	62.5	49	43	-6
Wil Powell	GCFC	52	41	43	2
Ben McKay	NMFC	51	42	42	0
Aaron Naughton	WB	51.5	41	42	1
Sam Draper	ESS	54	45	42	-3
Jake Stein	GWS	43	35	42	7
Jack Ginnivan	COLL	52.5	44	42	-2
Gary Rohan	GEEL	54	43	42	-1
Trent Rivers	MELB	50.5	40	41	1
Braeden Campbell	SYD	44.5	35	41	6
Easton Wood	WB	46.5	37	41	4
Thomson Dow	RICH	50	39	40	1
Kyle Hartigan	HAW	47.5	37	40	3
Daniel Lloyd	GWS	54.5	44	40	-4
Brett Bewley	FRE	44.5	36	40	4
Jacob Koschitzke	HAW	44	34	39	5
Josh Walker	NMFC	36.5	30	39	9
Gryan Miers	GEEL	63.5	50	38	-12
Cameron Zurhaar	NMFC	37	30	38	8
Eddie Ford	NMFC	45.5	37	37	0
Lachlan Gollant	ADEL	51.5	42	37	-5
Sebastian Ross	STK	60	49	37	-12
Kayne Turner	NMFC	58.5	48	37	-11
Nathan Murphy	COLL	49	41	36	-5
Mark Hutchings	WCE	49	39	36	-3
Sean Lemmens	GCFC	45.5	36	36	0
Darcy Gardiner	BL	40.5	32	36	4
Darcy Tucker	FRE	38.5	32	36	4
Bailey Banfield	FRE	49	40	36	-4
Will Hoskin-Elliott	COLL	50.5	42	35	-7
Mitch Georgiades	PORT	45.5	36	34	-2
Aiden Bonar	NMFC	44	36	32	-4
Luke Jackson	MELB	40.5	32	32	0
Atu Bosenavulagi	NMFC	36	30	31	1
Josh Treacy	FRE	44.5	36	31	-5
Alex Sexton	GCFC	35	27	31	4
Tom Fullarton	BL	38	30	30	0
Charlie Dixon	PORT	30.5	24	30	6
Blake Acres	FRE	46.5	38	30	-8
Callum Ah Chee	BL	35.5	28	30	2
Tom Cole	WCE	35	28	30	2
Corey Durdin	CARL	37.5	31	29	-2
Trent Bianco	COLL	50	42	28	-14
Oliver Henry	COLL	24	20	28	8
Sam Mayes	PORT	29.5	23	27	4
Jay Rantall	COLL	38.5	32	25	-7
Robbie Fox	SYD	39.5	31	24	-7
Ryan Byrnes	STK	48	39	22	-17
Josh Honey	CARL	28.5	23	21	-2
Jake Aarts	RICH	36	28	20	-8
Bailey Scott	NMFC	29	24	17	-7
Tom McDonald	MELB	20	16	15	-1
Jack Petruccelle	WCE	20.5	16	14	-2
Stephen Coniglio	GWS	23	19	14	-5
Phoenix Spicer	NMFC	13.5	11	12	1
Paddy Dow	CARL	15	12	11	-1
Joel Western	FRE	16	13	11	-2
Jeremy Sharp	GCFC	14	11	5	-6
James Jordon	MELB	0	0	0	0
Nik Cox	ESS	0	0	0	0
Shaun Higgins	GEEL	0	0	0	0
Rhys Mathieson	BL	0	0	0	0
Josh Schache	WB	0	0	0	0
James Rowe	ADEL	0	0	0	0
Joel Jeffrey	GCFC	0	0	-1	-1
Beau McCreery	COLL	-4	-3	-3	0
Matthew Parker	RICH	54	42	41	-1
Connor West	WCE	53	42	45	3
Sam Durham	ESS	59	49	49	0
Cooper Sharman	STK	113.5	93	103	10
Jai Newcombe	HAW	6.5	5	7	2

 

LEGEND:

Raw: SuperCoach points, added up according to the formula put out by Champion Data, before any scaling.

Linear-Scaled: Raw points, multiplied by a multiplier (3300 / total raw points for the match) to get the scores in each game to add up to 3300.

Actual: Actual SuperCoach points, as awarded by Champion Data.

Diff: Difference between actual and linear-scaled points. In practice, this is how favourably or unfavourably a player was scaled – this is ultimately what I’m setting out to investigate.

 

Download the full breakdowns:

Round 23 Summary (General Categories)

Round 23 Full Breakdown (Stat-By-Stat)

 

Download the time-based scoring breakdown:

Round 23 Fine-Grained Scores

 

---

Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom