Table For Two – Rd6

Written by Schwarzwalder on April 28 2016

During the pre-season, ‘Thommo’s 2-UP’ was a wildly popular thread on SCT.  Table For Two is fast becoming a permanent fixture for a Thursday afternoon, helping you with those difficult trade decisions.  Once again, we’ll open it up to you, the SCT Community.

It’s come to that moment yet again.  You’ve scoured the BreakEvens, you’ve mapped out a trading plan for the coming weeks……..and now you’re stuck on two players.  Type their names into the comments below and the SCT Community will point you in the right direction with the Thumbs UP / DOWN.

Just a few things to keep in mind before posting:

** On Tuesday we ran a poll for possible/best replacements for Nat Fyfe (The AfterFyfe)

**  On Wednesday we ran a poll on this weeks rookie downgrade options (Bubble Buster)

Your answers might already be waiting for you there.  Otherwise, the floor is yours…………

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

61 thoughts on “Table For Two – Rd6”

  1. Bringing in Boyd this week
    Who to trade out
    T/U Ben Kennedy
    T/D Matt Dea
    Note: if I trade out benKen It opens up D/F dpp link and would still get to have Weitering, Adams, DBJ & AMT on field

    If I trade Dea then I’d have to bench one of AMT, Weitering, Adams or DBJ & have to field one of benKen, Papley or McGovern

    26

    8
    1. Fyfe, Crouch, Rocky all struggling after an injury riddled pre-season. I wouldn’t be rushing to bring Selwood in.

      2

      0
  2. TU: Dea to Petracca then B. Kennedy to Parker.
    TD: Dea to or Lee then B.Kennedy to Parker.

    Or perhaps I don’t trade this week but with Wingard in my team I really want to get another premo in ASAP.

    12

    15
    1. weitering can still grow a bit – maybe give a good 75 score
      simpson/docherty is still an even split – simmo is old but docherty is young, need more evidence before I can make a decision

      4

      0
  3. I have Weitering, Kennedy, Menadue and Dea, but only 100K in the bank, so I would need to downgrade one to upgrade another. Should I just wait another week until some decent rookies are on the bubble?

    T/U Trade em
    T/D Keep em

    2

    30
    1. Alriiiiiighty then. Usually I’m a tradeaholic, but this year I’ve managed to get through the first six rounds with only 3 trades. Only ranked around 14K, but trying REALLY hard to stick to the plan!

      9

      0
  4. Got to trade Fyfe.

    T/U Parker. Gun but everyones going to trade him in?

    T/D Lachie Neale. Big POD should score well with Fyfe out.

    28

    13
    1. My current mids are, Gaz , Danger,Wines, Libba,,Ward, Mills and Rocky.
      Yep I kept Rocky. If he comes good he should also be a great POD.

      6

      0
    2. Had neale from the get go last year and was solid all year. Barlow and neale will pick up fyfe slack hopefully. Extra 60 odd points for both of them each week. Haha that would be nice if it worked that way anyway. Can dream

      2

      0
  5. T/U Pendles
    T/D Sidebottom

    Trading for Fyfe and leaning towards Sidebottom for a POD and as I’m not sold on Pendles being back to the mids permanently. Keen to get one of the pies over Selwood as I already have Danger and like to spread the load a bit.

    21

    16
  6. Fyfe to Sloane and dea to Lee hopefully move the rankings up everyone goin Parker already got hannberry mills don’t want another Swan in there especially byes are not far away

    6

    6
  7. T/U – Lonergan/Weitering to Priddis
    T/D – Dea to Zorko

    If option 1, which of the two? Was initially going to trade Lonergan but now that Rischitelli’s out he may get more midfield time so considering trading Weitering instead.

    8

    1
  8. BenKen/K. Tippett OUT & Zorko/T. Greene IN

    Tippett as a POD hasn’t worked out I think & BenKen looked a good choice early on, but hasn’t really produced much since!

    Leaves me with 26 Trades & $11.5k

    T/U Go for it son! Both will produce consistent scores from here on end!!!

    T/D Nah, hold on to Tippett for now, but maybe trade out BenKen!

    TIA Everyone.

    1

    5
  9. Only used 3 trades and my hand has been forced. time for a trade.
    Fyfe and Dea out
    Pendels and Simpson t/u
    Dahlhaus and shaw t/d

    3

    15
  10. Fyfe and Lonergan OUT
    Bringing IN Dahlhaus and…

    T/U Shaw, will be top DEF but has Hawthorn this week and still a relatively high BE
    T/D Ward, consistent performer who will be top 10 mid

    2

    9
  11. Can’t decide on which premium mid to include in the team this week as a t/u.

    – Priddis
    – Sidebottom
    – Ziebell

    Thoughts ?

    0

    0
    1. Priddis 132 break even so would wait a week. Ziebel a good POD at the moment and scoring very well
      But sidebum would get my vote he is on fire even while the pies are not (last weeks win aside)

      5

      0
  12. Moving Dea on this week. He might still have a bit of cash to make, but it works better for my plans over the next few weeks to upgrade him now.

    TU: Simpson
    TD: Docherty

    4

    4
  13. Trades pre teams was Fyfe to Priddis and Dea to Heath Shaw, but I have both R.Gray and Wingard

    Will reverse Dea trade and hold him for one more week, so who should i trade out of the two with the following information

    T/U Gray – (will miss 2-3 weeks)
    T/D Wingard – likely only miss 1

    Comment- If hold both and just ride it out to save trades

    2

    6
    1. I was tossing up the exact same decision this week. I ended up choosing Hanners. Parker is cheaper and is averaging more, but I think come season’s end, Hanners will have the better overall score/average, and be more consistent than Parker.

      2

      0
      1. Thanks bAps

        I’m torn because I know I should have had Parker from r1 and he is cheaper, but he is more likely to go down for a few matches than Hanners at some stage

        0

        0
  14. Going Fyfe to Parker, second grade have enough for almost any premo so who to cull first?

    T/u ditch J Lonergan

    t/d ditch Dea

    6

    1
  15. TU – Trade out Dea with high B/E
    TD – Trade out Oliver who hasn’t been picked for last two (with Petracca coming in and looks firm to hold)

    1

    3
  16. Already burned through a bunch of trades – need some help trading out Ben Ken.

    t/u dpp and bring in Martin
    t/d dpp and bring in Barlowe

    5

    1
  17. Unsure whether to bring a defender either M Boyd or R Laird or bring in a mid such as S Pendlebury or M Priddis for M Dea.
    Def premiums- Shaw, Bartel, Rich
    Mid premiums- Dangerfield, Hannebery, Ablett, Shiel
    Want to bring Boyd in due to the injuries to his other running defenders but with the news of Adams missing should I bring Pendlebury in this week. Both are upgrade targets and should be in my team before the byes.
    Thumbs up- M Boyd/ R Laird and 272,000-262,000 in salary
    Thumbs down- S Pendlebury. 180,000 in salary

    0

    1
  18. I made this trade first thing on Monday and stuck with it, until now.

    Fyfe to Zorko into fwd via dpp.
    Bennedy to Duncan.

    Reasoning here is that Zorko is still a POD being owned by only 6%. He will be a top fwd and will sooner than later be owned by everyone, making his scores somewhat obsolete in the near future. I want to cash in on his scores before that happens.

    Duncan has an ave of 105 when you take out his mummification. Wanted to stay quiet on that little fact and can’t believe it’s not hot press, thank me later.

    BUT! I reaaaaaally want Selwood in my mids! Can’t afford he and Zorko and can’t bring in both said Cats with Danger and Bartel already in.

    TL;DR..

    T/U Original trade – follow your gut!
    T/D Fyfe to Selwood
    Bennedy to Cripps

    Comment thoughts or suggestions. Cheers!

    0

    1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *