My proposed trades for round 3.
Out – Leake Boxshall (or FOS if Boxshall plays) Gawn
In – NOD Lindsay and Rankin.
I am holding Sanders this week as he has a very achievable BE
I still have Perryman (who won’t lose value this week) and will probably become Bice if he is named for round 4.
I have also changed my philosophy on the flex position.
Better to have an extra consistent rookie scoring 80’s earlier in the season to enhance $ generation.
Later in the season better to have someone one like Flynn who gives ruck cover when you are running low on trades.
I’m very worried about Rankine’s hammy “awareness” when he was subbed on the weekend. I’m avoiding him now for that reason but not a lot of options for premium forwards. Hopefully with DPP in a few weeks, there maybe better variety.
I’m a bit surprised the majority have said FOS. I know He has shown a wore scoring potential but Tsatas is guatanteed to not make money for 2 weeks and then isnt even a lock to return with Parish available by then. What am I missing?
As a Richmond fan the role he used to have isn’t there anymore which is a worry. Not taking kick-ins getting minimal on the run handballs. It says a lot when you have Ben Miller taking kick-ins over him. Ive started him in my team the last 3 years and it’s always been a trap. Could I see him scoring well this weekend, yes but not consistently moving forward.
Was planning on trading WAshcroft to Callaghan this week. Haven’t been impressed at all with Will, especially up until 3qtr time on the weekend. But a massive last qtr and a bit of a bake from Llordo might get him going. I am a little concerned about some attention Callaghan may get in the future too, but he’s so smooth.
Anyway, should I trade WAshcroft -> Calaghan?
TU – Yes, trade WAshcroft -> Callaghan
TD – No, too sideways, back WAshcroft in a little longer.
Is Sheezel a worry for you? He’s getting plenty of possessions but about half are handballs. Is it because he’s in heavy traffic or copping a tag ? Plus I wonder is he getting enough CBA’s as last season? Can’t help but think the inclusion of Parker and Daniel along with some improvements from Simpkin and Powell affecting him around the ground. Thoughts?
Currently ranked 37k after a terrible Round 2 which saw me tumble 31k spots… needless to say I’m giving my team a serious look this week for ways to improve not only this week but through the entire season.
1. My premium picks haven’t fired (Sheezel, Gawn, and JHF)
2. The mid-price picks are duds (Perryman, Peatling, Sanders, and Flynn), and
3. I don’t have Levi Ashcroft who I think is a must have rookie.
So this week…
OUT: Sheezel, Gawn, JHF
IN: Sinclair, Rozee, Ashcroft
Move Flynn from Flex to R2 through the early byes; if he plays great, if not it’s best-18
Next week…
OUT: Perryman, Peatling, Paton
IN: Whitfield, Dawson, Bice
Following week…
OUT: Flynn, Sanders, Rookie TBC any line
IN: Xerri/RoMa/Briggs, Rookie TBC any line
Coaches Verdict…
Tu: Don’t do that, you’ve lost the plot
Td: Give it a whirl, you can always start planning for next year early
I had considered bringing in 3 premos for outgoing underperformers. I really didn’t want to hamstring my cash generation over the course of the season, hence the Levi inclusion this week. Plus, felt that I might be able to get away without a fully fielded team over the next 2 rounds given it’s Best-18.
however, you have given me food for thought that maybe I should consider Xerri as a direct replacement over Sinclair or Rozee in this round… so, thanks for that!
TU FOS Tsatas Hastie > Henderson Lash Lindsay + $80k
Probably Perryman to Bice next week or can upgrade Perryman
TD FOS Perryman Tsatas > O Sullivan Lash Lindsay + $240k
Can also get Bice next week for Prior if needed or upgrade Flynn or Short with the $240k
The O Sullivan in TD refers to COS!
Hi everyone – just wondering best combo to bring in?
T/U Dunkley and Dale (with $14 200 itb) or
T/D Callaghan and Zorko (with $107 900 itb)
My proposed trades for round 3.
Out – Leake Boxshall (or FOS if Boxshall plays) Gawn
In – NOD Lindsay and Rankin.
I am holding Sanders this week as he has a very achievable BE
I still have Perryman (who won’t lose value this week) and will probably become Bice if he is named for round 4.
I have also changed my philosophy on the flex position.
Better to have an extra consistent rookie scoring 80’s earlier in the season to enhance $ generation.
Later in the season better to have someone one like Flynn who gives ruck cover when you are running low on trades.
Who are you running at R2 with Gawn going out?
I had Gawn as my flex.
My rucks are Xerri and TDK
I’m very worried about Rankine’s hammy “awareness” when he was subbed on the weekend. I’m avoiding him now for that reason but not a lot of options for premium forwards. Hopefully with DPP in a few weeks, there maybe better variety.
No love for Simpkin ?
On the watch list Wighty.
Just a lot of players to fit into Norths midfield.
Let’s not forget Wardlaw will return within a month
Crom website says it was about “managing his loads”. Thought I read elsewhere it was a hip issue…
Anyone got solid intel on this?
Who to prioritise trading out first
Tu: Tsatas
Td: FOS
I’m a bit surprised the majority have said FOS. I know He has shown a wore scoring potential but Tsatas is guatanteed to not make money for 2 weeks and then isnt even a lock to return with Parish available by then. What am I missing?
Asked this in the previous one, still can’t make a decision.
Jayden Short:
TU – get rid of him
TD – one more week
Any insight from those who watched him would be handy.
As a Richmond fan the role he used to have isn’t there anymore which is a worry. Not taking kick-ins getting minimal on the run handballs. It says a lot when you have Ben Miller taking kick-ins over him. Ive started him in my team the last 3 years and it’s always been a trap. Could I see him scoring well this weekend, yes but not consistently moving forward.
reid – osullivan
tsatas – lindsay
currently ranked 4k
already have nod bice and all other good cows
Thoughts maybe hold tsatas but cant loop him this week as essendon play first
Who goes first for Lindsay?
TU FOS
TD Tsatas
JHF > Rankine
Hastie > Lindsay
FOS > O’driscall
Allows me to get JHF discounted for Sanders when Treloar / Bont return
TU or TD
Trading out JHF with the plan to get him back in, for a player with hamstring history who was subbed last week for “injury awareness”?
TU: Salem
or
TD: Bowey
TU: FOS Hastie Tsatas > Lashcroft Lindsay Henderson + $81k
TD: Perryman FOS/Tsatas Hastie > COS Lashcroft Lindsay +$230k
Trade: Garcia, Tsatas and Paton
Bring in: Callaghan, Lindsay, Henderson
TU – Yes
TD – No
Short>Dale
Day>Callaghan
Sanders>Salem via DPP
TU: Yes
TD: No
Yall reckon will day to fin
sideways trade tu
good trade td
Is it worth bringing in Connor O’Sullivan?
Concerned slightly with Kolodjashnij 1 week away and Stewart a test this week.
Tu or Td
FOS a hold now over Tsatas?
Fos only needs one spike score to get his cash gen moving, also likely to gain DPP and should be safe job security wise in that side.
Tsatas on reduced minutes as it is, with Parish set to return shortly, becomes a bit of a job security risk.
Who goes out this week:
Tu: Fos
Td: Tsatas
Who to target
Fin
Dale
TU – Zorko
TD – Dale
If you want to boot one, which one would it be
TU FoS
TD Kako
Comment neither, instead do paton and hanily
kako
TU – Dale/Zorko (Bice next week)
TD – O’Sullivan (Any premo next week)
Want to boot one
TU- Short
TD- JHF
neither,short doesnt ton up against saints then trade
jhf is a keeper
Tom Stewart a test this week. I’ll likely hold if he’s given the green light. Should I trade if not?
TU: Trade him before he drops in price.
TD: Hold, he’s a premo, injury sounds minor.
Really struggling with this decision…
Was planning on trading WAshcroft to Callaghan this week. Haven’t been impressed at all with Will, especially up until 3qtr time on the weekend. But a massive last qtr and a bit of a bake from Llordo might get him going. I am a little concerned about some attention Callaghan may get in the future too, but he’s so smooth.
Anyway, should I trade WAshcroft -> Calaghan?
TU – Yes, trade WAshcroft -> Callaghan
TD – No, too sideways, back WAshcroft in a little longer.
Thanks
Callaghan probably make you some cash to upgrade to a uberpremo faster
Last trade
T/u short to dale
T/d sanders to rankine
Should max gawn go?
T.u no just leave him for year and cop money loss
T.d yes trade and go down to tdk or Witts
T/U = Anderson
T/D = Liberatore
T/U = Sinclair
T/D = Whitfield
Who to get rid of first
TU – Tsatas
TS – Hastie
Perryman replacement
TU : Zorko
TD : Whitfield / Sinclair
Who to bring in for Tsatas?
TU: Campo
TD: Henderson
Who to get for Perryman?
TU – Freijah
TD – De Koning
Thanks
Is Sheezel a worry for you? He’s getting plenty of possessions but about half are handballs. Is it because he’s in heavy traffic or copping a tag ? Plus I wonder is he getting enough CBA’s as last season? Can’t help but think the inclusion of Parker and Daniel along with some improvements from Simpkin and Powell affecting him around the ground. Thoughts?
Sheezel losing money and JHF losing money.
Is this an issue for Supercoachers?
TU: Tsatas -> Lindsay
FOS -> Henderson
Perryman -> Dale
O’Sullivan and Bice next week
TD: Tsatas -> Lindsay
Paton -> O’Sulivan
Perryman -> Freijah
Henderson and Bice next week
TD
Garcia to Lindsay
Perryman to Dale
Pattern to Bice
TD
Garcia to Lindsay
Perryman to Dale
FOS/tsatas to COS
(Leaves Ried/prior/trainer down back to trade in bice)
COS this week, Bice next week
Appreciate feedback on this thought bubble.
Currently ranked 37k after a terrible Round 2 which saw me tumble 31k spots… needless to say I’m giving my team a serious look this week for ways to improve not only this week but through the entire season.
1. My premium picks haven’t fired (Sheezel, Gawn, and JHF)
2. The mid-price picks are duds (Perryman, Peatling, Sanders, and Flynn), and
3. I don’t have Levi Ashcroft who I think is a must have rookie.
So this week…
OUT: Sheezel, Gawn, JHF
IN: Sinclair, Rozee, Ashcroft
Move Flynn from Flex to R2 through the early byes; if he plays great, if not it’s best-18
Next week…
OUT: Perryman, Peatling, Paton
IN: Whitfield, Dawson, Bice
Following week…
OUT: Flynn, Sanders, Rookie TBC any line
IN: Xerri/RoMa/Briggs, Rookie TBC any line
Coaches Verdict…
Tu: Don’t do that, you’ve lost the plot
Td: Give it a whirl, you can always start planning for next year early
Magic, did you consider – Sheezel Gawn Perryman >> Dale Xerri Rossi
hey FJW – It’s a great prompt…
I had considered bringing in 3 premos for outgoing underperformers. I really didn’t want to hamstring my cash generation over the course of the season, hence the Levi inclusion this week. Plus, felt that I might be able to get away without a fully fielded team over the next 2 rounds given it’s Best-18.
however, you have given me food for thought that maybe I should consider Xerri as a direct replacement over Sinclair or Rozee in this round… so, thanks for that!
Hypothetically if I was trading my Petracca (Pending upon rookie selections). Who to bring in
T/U: Dunkley (Monster R1, May be too hard to get in future, super consistent)
T/D: Dawson (started on fire but crows have been dominant, goes up forward to avoid the tag, but is 50k cheaper)
Comment: Someone cheaper Callaghan/Cerra/Rozee etc
Luke Ryan
T/u – Hold
T/d – Trade to a Dale/Clark
Hi all
Tu trade in l Ashcroft
Tad too late
Thanks
Trade out which one
TU : Kako
TD : FOS
Trading in which one would you prefer (as Perryman replacement)
TU : B Dale
TD : Whitfield or Sinclair
Thinking Dale as he is due to increase by the most this week, and then if Short sucks again, he can be traded up next week to Whitfield or Sinclair?
If you can only bring in one:
Tu: O’Sullivan
Td: Henderson
Have already done:
1. FOS to Ashcroft
2. Flynn to Linsday via Flex
Do I boost to trade Paton to Connor O’Sullivan before the price increase?
TU: Make the trade
TD: Not worth a boost