Thinking:
OUT – Trainor, Humphrey and C Hall.
IN: Carroll, Flynn and Long
.
Not the best use of a boost, I know, but I have one in reserve for later and lets me get Martin to finish FWD and Clark (leaving Bice last DEF rookie) over the next two weeks.
C O’Sullivan to Ned long
F O’Sullivan to carroll
Davies-uniacke to Newcombe
Going to take a risk and skip Flynn and go long instead. I’m just not a fan of the run coming up for Flynn I know he is going to make bulk cash but I can’t see him being more than long in 3 weeks time. These trades still leave me 105k for future trades. Would be going daicos if I didn’t already bring him in last week allows me to go Newcombe this week with a nice little run coming up
If Trainor doesn’t get the sub vest is he worth holding given Carlton don’t play until Sunday and don’t know Carrols JS?
TU: Hold
TD: Cash him out, time to trade. Can always update Carrol if he doesn’t play.
Want to bring in Daicos and my only options are Oliver/Maric. I know the talk is holding Oliver for his next couple fixtures, but I’ll be upgrading him eventually so realistically who makes more $$ over the next 2 rounds?
Like many, wanting to bring in Daicos this week.
Currently running Gawn/Xerri/TDK ruck combo.
The only way to facilitate Daicos without compromising the rest of the side is to go
TDK(flex)/Davidson >Flynn/Daicos
Ok, I’ve found a way to get Naicos without losing Oliver…
(Already done Trainor > Flynn (Flex), so will be using a boost)
Moraes + M Hall > Naicos + Tunstill
Has to be either Tunstill or Carroll, so hoping Tunstill gets another couple of games at least and generates a bit of cash while warming my bench.
TU: Good Moves, Naicos essential
TD: Don’t be daft
I did briefly consider this trade:
Out Gawn Humphrey and Moraes
In Flynn NDaicos and Holmes
but Instead I have settled on keeping Maxxy in the Flex position missing out on Flynn and doing
Out Humphrey and Moraes
In NDaicos and Carroll
Good or bad decision?
Get Daicos in this week or wait until next week and get Bont when he is on the bubble. To get Bont my trades will need to hit their BE this which is only 35-40 for both.
Would love any thoughts from Collingwood supporters… is Ned Long with a BE of -26 a good short term ca$h gen play? Or, does the inclusion of Houston off suspension mean that Perryman goes back into the middle, sending Long forward reducing his scoring?
Tough to say Magic but I’d be surprised if Long doesn’t stay on ball after the last two games.
Perryman more likely to go to half fwd I’d say. But not confidently.
Houston and possibly Membrey to come in.
Moore will miss.
Hi all,
TU Trainor, Hall, short – Carroll, Flynn DAICOS..using boost
TD just Trainor morales – carroll Flynn…keep boost and short..
Thinking go for it…
Thanks…
It may be with Darcy out at the WBD that Mr Magnets swings Davidson into the forward line where he played a bit when in the VFL the last couple of years, meaning his scoring may be a bit more volatile. Just something to think about with this transaction.
Currently thinking I’ll trade Trainor, Davidson and Humphrey for Carroll, Daicos and Flynn. Would rather not trade Trainor and Davo but they are the he fattest of my rookies and allow me to get Daicos
Want Daicos but do not really want to get rid of TDK.
TU: Out – Kako, Davidson, Trainor –> In – Daicos, Carroll, Some random 99k player who may play. This leaves me ultra thin on the bench and no cash in bank.
TD: Out – Moraes, Trainor, TDK –> In – Daicos, Flynn, Carroll and about 200k in bank and some ok bench options.
Trading one of Trainor or Z.Reid. Of course Trainors 2 will stall his CG for a couple of weeks, but am I the only one thinking he might still be a better hold until the byes than Reid?
TU Trainor should score better than Reid until their byes
Is it worth trading Davidson and Hall over Moraes and Kako to fund Flynn over Tunstill. Don’t like getting rid of the better rookies just yet but have fomo over Flynn and don’t like going early on Tunstill. Currently leaning towards Moraes and Kako
Thinking:
OUT – Trainor, Humphrey and C Hall.
IN: Carroll, Flynn and Long
.
Not the best use of a boost, I know, but I have one in reserve for later and lets me get Martin to finish FWD and Clark (leaving Bice last DEF rookie) over the next two weeks.
TU
TD
TU: move my highest rookies in Sinn, lashcroft & Trainor to Daicos, Caroll and Flyn
TD: straight trade Dan Rioli & Rookie to Daicos and Flynn.
Rioli not premo (kinda .. yet) but still sideways and the other options burns trades. I also have the likes of Berry, Gross, Tstas and Cleary ..
Help please and thanks
I’d hold rioli
TU: Stone, Kako, Humphrey >> Carroll, Flynn, Naicos
TD: Kako, Humphrey, Oliver >> Carroll, Rowell, Naicos
Who to trade out for Flynn:
TU – Hall, ceiling is hit, leaves $322k itb
TD – Leake, dead rookie, leaves $192k itb
C O’Sullivan to Ned long
F O’Sullivan to carroll
Davies-uniacke to Newcombe
Going to take a risk and skip Flynn and go long instead. I’m just not a fan of the run coming up for Flynn I know he is going to make bulk cash but I can’t see him being more than long in 3 weeks time. These trades still leave me 105k for future trades. Would be going daicos if I didn’t already bring him in last week allows me to go Newcombe this week with a nice little run coming up
I’d be surprised if Newcomb scores more points than ldu from here, even with his slump ATM
If Pittonet is named for Carlton do you trade out TDK…his average is 117 which is his breakeven…would trade for Xerri.
Is using a boost this week smart
We’re gonna need a little more context than that mate lol
What to do with Crippa trade or keep?
Crippa, Trainor, O’sullivan to Naicos, Carroll, flynn/long TU
Trainor, o’sullivan to Petracca, Carroll TD
Out: COS, NOD and Davidson
In: Carroll, Daicos and Flynn
Will leave 2 boosts left, 28 trades, and 16.6k
Team would look like:
D: Sheezel, Holmes, Roberts, Short, Bice, Reid, Stone, Carroll
M: Brayshaw, Daicos, Merrett, Neale, Oliver, Callaghan, Moraes, Lindsay, FOS, Tsatas, Hall
R: Xerri, Meek, Boyd
F: JHF, Macrae, Smith, Daniel, Maric, LAshcroft, Kako, Cleary
Flex: Flynn
If Trainor doesn’t get the sub vest is he worth holding given Carlton don’t play until Sunday and don’t know Carrols JS?
TU: Hold
TD: Cash him out, time to trade. Can always update Carrol if he doesn’t play.
Can update, but to who…
True. Nobody else seems worth doing.
Hopefully Trainor plays and scores big
Idk about ‘scores big’ but he’ll play w Balta on curfew.
Want to bring in Daicos and my only options are Oliver/Maric. I know the talk is holding Oliver for his next couple fixtures, but I’ll be upgrading him eventually so realistically who makes more $$ over the next 2 rounds?
TU: Oliver (BE 100)
TD: Maric (BE 54)
Who goes out:
Tu: Henderson
Td: Tsatas
Obviously if Tsatas is named I will hold him for sure. Dons fans, why isn’t he getting a game?
TU: TDK Davidson > Naicos Flynn
TD: TDK Moraes > Flynn Petracca
Neither, hold TDK and fit flynn in your flex/r3. Worry about upgrading the rookies next week if you have to.
Trainor to
Up- Carroll and $90k extra bank
Or
Down- E.Hewett
Gotta move a couple of guys – have no dead rookies or non playing players so cash gen is looking ok.
TU: Darcy & Humphries >> Flynn (flex) & Naicos
TD: Darcy & Humphries >> Carroll & Bont (100k itb)
To trade in?
TU Laird
TD Petracca
Trade OUT:
TU Moraes
TD Stone
Who to trade out?
TU: Lynch who finally had a spike game but probably can’t generate much more than another $50k
TD: Clay Hall who might be a dead rookie
Is Flynn a must have?
With Caroll maybe falling through due to Cowan back early, who else is there to make money? Tunstill next week?
I think he’s necessary for CG. -73 BE @ 261k is solid. 2x 80s and he makes 110k~.
Trade out Oliver for Daicos?
TU – Yes
TD – No
Dale > Whitfield
TU: Yes
TD: No
Can’t see any reason why not, so please leave reasoning if No.
TU: Holmes (Top 6 Defender)
TD: Nic Martin (Top 6 Forward)
Who is more likely to be top 6 and who should i bring in? HELPPP
I think Martin’s DEF/FWD will give you more benefit than Holmes’ DEF/MID
Trainor Moraes > Flynn Hewett
TU Good Trades
TD Bad Trades
Guidance please on these two ideas. Please tell me which is better
First set of trades is
TU out SHORT, TRAINOR, REID
In FLYNN, NAICOS, CARROLL
Second set of trades
TD out TRAINOR, REID, M HALL ( stk)
In FLYNN, ROZEE, CARROLL
Basically I have gone value in 2nd set, rozee over naicos whilst retaining Short. I am trying to get rookies off the ground asap
Which do you prefer
Soligo:
TU: Trade
TD: Hold
Currently have 28 trades, 2 boosts left
Thinking:
Moraes, C.Hall & Soligo > Carroll, Flynn & Petracca?
Like many, wanting to bring in Daicos this week.
Currently running Gawn/Xerri/TDK ruck combo.
The only way to facilitate Daicos without compromising the rest of the side is to go
TDK(flex)/Davidson >Flynn/Daicos
TU: Worth the punt
TD: Hold TDK
Getting Naicos this week, plus either 1 or 2 others…pending boost.
TU – Worth using my 3rd boost to get Flynn and Carrol?
TD – Just pick one of Carrol and Flynn
Hi team,
Currently have TDK Gawn Xerri Trio, with cash gen slowly drying up I don’t know what to do:
T/U Trainor/Moraes/Kako > Carroll/Tunstill/Naicos
(10k ITB)
T/D Trainor/Moraes/TDK > Carroll/Naicos/Flynn
(240k ITB)
Thanks all
Is it worth boosting to go
TU Oliver, Darcy, Trainor -> Naicos, NMartin, Flynn
Or hold the boost and just go
TD Darcy, Trainor -> Naicos, Flynn
T/U Trainor, davidson and SDK to Carroll, Daicos and Petracca (Stone moves to defence)
or
T/D Moraes, Stone, SDK to Carroll, Daicos, Flynn (L Ashcroft moves from flex to midfield)
tempted by trac vs tigers but FLynn will have good cash generation and means i can hold onto to decent scoring rookies in trainor and davidson.
who to trade cos or luke trainor
Lashcroft – Long
Shezzel – Daicos
Paton – Flynn
Not a fan of losing LAshcroft yet. I’d hold Sheezel too, annoying as he has been.
Ok, I’ve found a way to get Naicos without losing Oliver…
(Already done Trainor > Flynn (Flex), so will be using a boost)
Moraes + M Hall > Naicos + Tunstill
Has to be either Tunstill or Carroll, so hoping Tunstill gets another couple of games at least and generates a bit of cash while warming my bench.
TU: Good Moves, Naicos essential
TD: Don’t be daft
Stu, I would go Carroll as not sure about tunstill JS and you are are also going early on him. A bit of a risk IMO
agree. Tunstill can be our next week’s trade in
I see the risks going early on Tunstill. What about Cowan being a test? Not sure on Carroll
I did briefly consider this trade:
Out Gawn Humphrey and Moraes
In Flynn NDaicos and Holmes
but Instead I have settled on keeping Maxxy in the Flex position missing out on Flynn and doing
Out Humphrey and Moraes
In NDaicos and Carroll
Good or bad decision?
Who are your other rucks? Surely keep gawn, drop one of your other 2 rucks for Flynn?
which is better
out TRAINOR, REID
In ROZEE, CARROLL and not boost, still have 3 boosts left
Or
Use boost and get in Flynn by selling M hall
Which do you prefer
TU- Moraes > Tunstill
TD- Trainor > Durdin
Rest of season better pick
TU: Whitfield
TD: Tom Green
Get Daicos in this week or wait until next week and get Bont when he is on the bubble. To get Bont my trades will need to hit their BE this which is only 35-40 for both.
Is Moraes > Hewett worth a trade?
Already doing Trainor > Flynn
TU Yes
TD No
I think so Chompers. Moraes dead on a wing – that 1 good game sucked us all in but clearly wasnt real.
Hewett’s looking like a CBA mid, -8 BE which will only go lower once the sub-affected 22 drops out of his cycle next week.
Reposting as limited response in last thread.
TU: Trainor, Kako, Davidson -> Carroll, Naicos, Flynn (gets it done with ~3k itb to spare)
TD: Short, Moraes, Tsatas -> Carroll, Naicos, Flynn (leaves ~100k itb spare)
1 boost remaining after this.
OR
TU: Fade Flynn altogether, save the boost and just go for Trainor/Kako -> Naicos Carroll.
Would love any thoughts from Collingwood supporters… is Ned Long with a BE of -26 a good short term ca$h gen play? Or, does the inclusion of Houston off suspension mean that Perryman goes back into the middle, sending Long forward reducing his scoring?
Tough to say Magic but I’d be surprised if Long doesn’t stay on ball after the last two games.
Perryman more likely to go to half fwd I’d say. But not confidently.
Houston and possibly Membrey to come in.
Moore will miss.
TU: Bailey Smith
TD: Petracca
TU – C.O’Sull & Trainor OUT / Rankin & Carrol IN
TD – C.O’Sull & Trainor OUT / Flynn & Carrol IN (Bank 250k for next week)
Hi all,
TU Trainor, Hall, short – Carroll, Flynn DAICOS..using boost
TD just Trainor morales – carroll Flynn…keep boost and short..
Thinking go for it…
Thanks…
Does anyone have insights into Carroll’s job security?
Cowan was listed as 3-5 weeks away last week, now it is a ‘test’.
Hmmmm I am becoming less convinced. But have not seen him live to know how good he actually is and if Cowan takes his spot once fit.
same here, wouldn’t know him from a bar of soap
Best way to get to Daicos:
T/u – No boost, trade Murphy Reid and OSullivan to Daicos and Carroll
T/d – Use a Boost. Hold Murphy Reid.
Trade O’Sullivan, Trainor and Morares to Carrol, Daicos and sub 170k rookie (Spargo, Erasmus, etc.)
T/u – No boost, get Rowell
T/d – Use a boost to get to Daicos
Have Gawn, TDK and English as a 3 ruck flex setup.
Should I trade English to Flynn, O’Sullivan to Daicos
T/u – Yes
T/d – No too sideways, focus on upgrading rookies
Better trade out:
T/u – Clay Hall
T/d – Moraes
If you needed a second downgrade and couldn’t afford Flynn.
Thought on Charlie Spargo?
150k fwd, -28 BE, Tigers and Eagles next 2, named on field.
T/u – Don’t mind it
T/d – Avoid
even when Spargo was a regular in team, he never scored very well, 50’s at best
Keep an eye out on teams. Erasmus a strong chance to come in for O’Meara who could be out a few weeks with a hammy injury.
Sub-risk, but we play Friday Night so will know nice and early.
nice shout, he is on the bubble
Dilemma time for the Pork Chop Express, thoughts on the better move:
T/U – Daicos & Tunstall
T/D – Jai & Hewitt
to get Petracca this week, i can trade out either Davidson BE 37 or M Reid BE 44
toss of the coin, but if i was splitting hairs i would say Davidson has a tougher run of games.
Both can still make $30-$50k
TU: Hold trade and have another look at Petracca
TD: Petracca will be a top 6 forward, get him now with easy games coming up
If TD and Get Petracca, who to trade out?
TU: Davidson
TD: M Reid
Reid seems to have a solid and stable role.
It may be with Darcy out at the WBD that Mr Magnets swings Davidson into the forward line where he played a bit when in the VFL the last couple of years, meaning his scoring may be a bit more volatile. Just something to think about with this transaction.
thanks magic.
Davidson & Reid were both gone last week, until Gross was sub. i traded them both back in and and traded out Knevitt and Roberts to buy Daicos
so their scores last week were a little bonus and keeping one for a bit more cash generation is also a bonus.
i watched davidson close last week and it all depends on which side of the ground the Dogs decide to go, if davidson is involved or not
Currently thinking I’ll trade Trainor, Davidson and Humphrey for Carroll, Daicos and Flynn. Would rather not trade Trainor and Davo but they are the he fattest of my rookies and allow me to get Daicos
Exact same situation here – will likely pull the trigger as Naicos is a must have with his BE and Flynn for cash gen.
See the experts are trading out TDK for Flyn
TU TDK time is over
TD Keep him…
Thanks
The million $ question! TDK likely to go big and be a keeper, but Flynn could generate cash! A lot depends on Pittonet
teams would have to do that if they have Gawn and Xerri at R1 and R2, with TDK at flex
its all about Pitonet. when does he get named?
Want Daicos but do not really want to get rid of TDK.
TU: Out – Kako, Davidson, Trainor –> In – Daicos, Carroll, Some random 99k player who may play. This leaves me ultra thin on the bench and no cash in bank.
TD: Out – Moraes, Trainor, TDK –> In – Daicos, Flynn, Carroll and about 200k in bank and some ok bench options.
tia
Could someone give me some ideas for trades this week. I have 30 trades + 3 Boosts and very little ITB.
Defenders: Sinclair, Sheezel, Zorko, Bice, Reid, Trainor
( Paton, Leake )
Midfielders: Daicos, Serong, Neale, W. Ashcroft, Cerra, Oliver, O’Sullivan, Lindsey (knevitt, gross, camporeale)
Ruck: Gawn, Xerri, (Boyd)
Forwards: Macrae, Smith, Daniel, Maric, Humphrey, Cleary ( Kako, Hewitt )
Flex: TDK
Thanks
Reid or Trainor to Carroll and then Humphrey to Tracca
Cheers legend
Who to trade OUT?
TU: Moraes
TD: Kako
Trading one of Trainor or Z.Reid. Of course Trainors 2 will stall his CG for a couple of weeks, but am I the only one thinking he might still be a better hold until the byes than Reid?
TU Trainor should score better than Reid until their byes
TD Trade Trainor and keep Reid instead.
Who to trade out first:
TU: Trainor
TD: Z Reid
TU: Daicos
TD: Petracca
Who to trade out?
TU: Knevitt
TD: FOS
Is it worth trading Davidson and Hall over Moraes and Kako to fund Flynn over Tunstill. Don’t like getting rid of the better rookies just yet but have fomo over Flynn and don’t like going early on Tunstill. Currently leaning towards Moraes and Kako
TU: Trade Davidson + Hall
TD: Trade Moraes + Kako
the reason you would hold davidson and/or hall is because they can put a decent on field score and he will make a bit more cash.
Flynn should score better and make a heap more cash
Who to field?
TU: Sam Davidson
TD: Murphy Reid
is it worth trading a premo ruck (de koning , gawn or xerri) for flynn?
Went Hastie to C.Cleary last week.
Def – Holmes, Dale, Roberts, Short, Bice, Reid (Trainor, Stone)
Mid – Sheezel, Neale, W.Ashcroft, Rozee, Oliver, L Ashcroft, Moraes, Lindsey (Kako, C.Hall, Henderson)
Ruc – TDK, Xerri (Boyd)
Fwd – JHF, Macrae Rankine, Smith, Daniel, Davidson (E.Hewett, C.Cleary)
Flex – Knevitt
$268,000 ITB, 31 trades left, 3 boosts
TU: (Play it safe) Moraes to Flynn – means I keep Trainor
TD: (Risky with Carroll on extended bench) Moraes & Trainor to M.Carroll & N.Daicos
Thoughts / advice / feedback appreciated
Who to field
T/U- Sam Lalor
T/D- Levi Ashcroft
Thanks