77 thoughts on “Trade Talk – Rd22”

  2. 2 Trades left
    Was going to go Rookie to Rookie which left me cash to go Rookie to Hall, leaving Greene on the bench as cover. But thats all changed.
    Now need to worry about,
    Danger
    Brayshaw
    Hurn
    Greene
    Walsh
    After planning this over a month its really heart breaking.

    7

    0
    Reply

    1. km
      Zorks and Marshall are top options…Collingwood would not tag Nathan Buckley if he ran out against them at his best or even Cazaly so…???
      However Marshall will score plenty if he takes the ruck without Ryder again…Either way you are set…
      Marshall versus Geelong… if rucking alone… by a nose.

      2

      1
      Reply

  6. Into Prelim: 2 trades left: team

    Laird, Lloyd, Stewart, Short, Whitfield, Ridley ( Durham, Murphy)

    Steele, Lyons, Macrae, Merrett, Mitchell, Jelly,
    Oliver, Sharp( Bruhn, Newcombe, Bianco)

    Gawndy(Reeves)

    Zorko, Danger, Hall, Bolton, Heeney, Ziebell (FMacrae, Waterman)

    TU: Reeves/Sharp > 102k Ruck/ Parish or mid under 556k

    TD: Reeves/Sharp > 102k Ruck/ Marshall( Via Danger ddp)

    10

    14
    Reply

  7. Thanks for the season of great content SC, and all the contributors. Brilliant site.

    2 trades left / $176k in the bank / weakest links are Daniher and Taranto.

    TU:
    Daniher > Zorko, Hold Taranto, 1 trade available for GF

    TD:
    Daniher > Butters, Taranto > Guthrie or Parish, 0 trades available

    Thanks!

    27

    5
    Reply

  10. Lost a lot of hair the past few weeks. Thanks Shite Bolton!

    Who do I trade for him?
    T/U – Tom Hawkins
    T/D – Josh Dunkley

    Comments – Anyone else? Already have Hall, Dangerfield, Marshall, Zorko and Ziebell.

    15

    15
    Reply

    1. This may help
      (player, 50% above, 80% above)
      Hawkins, 89, 61
      Hind, 88, 75
      Sidebottom, 92, 74
      Dale, 93, 72
      Dixon, 95, 70

      Dunkley has not returned to pre injury form so not worth the risk (scores of 87, DNP, 65, 75)

      3

      0
      Reply

  11. 1 trade left and in Prelim final.
    Who is the best fwd option for under 388K (trading out shite Bolton)

    Can choose between
    Luke Jackson Melb,
    Butters PA,
    Bailey Bris,
    McCartin Syd,
    Papley Syd,
    Jamie Cripps WCE,
    McCarthy Bris

    Who is going to be a safe bet to give me good points and hopefully win my way into the GF. Thanks in advance

    2

    0
    Reply

    1. This might help
      (player, 50% scores above, 80% scores above)
      Jackson, 60, 44
      Butters, 85, 49
      Bailey, 83, 55
      McCartin, 66, 56
      Papley, 72, 51
      Cripps, 64, 50
      McCarthy, 75, 50

      4

      0
      Reply

        1. Sure, if we take all of their scores for the year, 50%/80% are above that number. It gives us an idea of how reliable they are to score.

          2

          0
          Reply

  12. So I’ve got Sharp and Bolton on the field, 2 trades and 256k. Am wondering:

    TU – sharp to Bont (keep Bolton..
    And 1 trade)
    TD – sharp and Bolton to either Guthrie & butters OR Adams & Greene. (Use both trades)

    Thanks!

    15

    3
    Reply

  14. With hopefully no injuries to deal with I think I should upgrade O’Brien with my last trade. Can afford anyone except Darcy. Who would you get?

    2

    1
    Reply

  15. 3 Trades left planning to use 2 this week, needing to get Bolton off field as F7/M9 cover, who to bring in
    TU – Dunkley
    TD – Marshall

    0

    25
    Reply

  16. Got one trade left for the season, torn between Hall or Marshall who are both in great form:
    TU – Hall
    TD – Marshall

    11

    9
    Reply

  18. brayshaw and toby suspended with no trades left 🙂

    fairly lucky given I have bramble and waterman as cover

    7

    0
    Reply

  19. Have one trade left and in prelim cash league, have 26k to spend

    TU sell Bramble or Bramble
    TD save the trade for the gf if I make it

    1

    7
    Reply

    1. If I did use my final trade,

      TU sell Bramble or
      TD sell Bolton

      This gives me 388k to spend on a better mid or fwd

      3

      8
      Reply

  23. have danger, walsh, greene and brayshaw. assuming first two play at this stage. should i trade greene and brayshaw to bont and dunkley for eg, or hold fire and use ginnivan and durham as cover. have 2 trades and mainly playing league
    cheers
    T/U use two trades it’s a knockout semi
    T/D hold fire if the match up looks good

    6

    3
    Reply

  24. TU:
    Shite Bolton+Reeves>102k loop and Zorko

    Uses my last two trades. Need to use both as I have no cash. Hope Danger, Walsh, Mills get back up and no1 else gets injured for the season

    TD:
    Keep two trades purely for injuries.

    8

    0
    Reply

  25. Which under 550k DEF should I bring in? Already have Lloyd, Whitfield.
    Options include Sam Taylor, Jordan Dawson, and Caleb Daniel

    1

    0
    Reply

    1. Some options
      Player, 50% above, 80% above, lowest since bye
      Ridley, 105, 80, 52
      Dawson, 95, 79, 85
      Short, 99, 77, 65
      Daniel, 99, 66, 68
      Andrews, 98, 76, 67
      Ryan, 95, 86, 62
      Taylor, 93, 72, 79
      Weitering, 97, 69, 80

      Hopefully this helps

      1

      0
      Reply

  26. Have Mills, Brayshaw, Walsh and Danger. Two trades left, $104k itb

    Thinking Brayshaw -> Toukan
    Upgrading May in the last round to someone not playing on Tom Hawkins, worried about Mill’s and am playing someone without him. Any other moves?

    2

    0
    Reply

  27. Have one trade left and in prelim cash league, have 26k to spend

    TU sell Bramble or Bolton
    TD save the trade for the gf if I make it

    3

    1
    Reply

  28. Need urgent help,
    1 trade left and gnna trade Brayshaw because need to win league game to make it to grand finals.
    Highest scorer below 616k
    Tu- petracca
    Td- bont
    Comment if u think I should be going for someone else like parish , Guthrie or Lyons.
    Just want the player I pick to be scoring a big score 🙂
    Thank you

    4

    5
    Reply

    1. TYCA
      Petracca versus Crows at The G…
      Forecast is promising…maybe a shower and 9-19c and he can go big…
      The Bont takes on Hawthorn in Tassie with the forecast fair to ok. Mids go large against them and they rarely tag…Lineball… but Petracca by a pimple.
      Petracca 116 versus Crows round 10…Dogs play Hawks first time this season…last season round 17 and Bonts had 28 disposals… contested 17 with 8 clearances…so a big supercoach day….is this a perfect flip of the coin?

      4

      0
      Reply

  31. 1 trade left with Brayshaw out.

    Will just hold and take Bramble’s cover just in case any other injury disasters come up for the last round.

    4

    0
    Reply

  34. Last trade. Finally getting rid of Cripps!!
    Unfortunately just shy of getting Touk. Already have Steele/Oliver/Macrae/Merrett/Mitchell. So I’m tossing up between the following 4:

    Bont (TU)
    Petracca (TD)
    Mills via Laird (comment)
    Marshall via Zorko (comment)

    Cheers!

    5

    0
    Reply

  37. Trading in Rich for who ever is not back next week
    So who’s not playing next week

    Tu Lloyd
    Td Mills

    Any swanies out there in the know! Cheers

    1

    2
    Reply

  42. Which one of Jake LLoyd (knee soreness) and Callum Mills (achilles soreness) is more likely to play next week in The SC Grand Final?
    TU: Lloyd
    TD: Mills

    6

    0
    Reply

    1. I would like to know this as well thanks Stevo. Want to bring in Rich for one of them this wk but that said need the other to be named next week not the one I trade out this wk. stressful. Can’t seam to find any information on the severity of either injury. Is it just a case of resting players as the swans are in a position to do so. Any help appreciated. Cheers

      2

      0
      Reply

  43. need a forward under 550k to replace greene- bets options seems to be dunkley, de goey, bailey bale or hawkins. yhink ive narrowed t down to the first two
    T/U dunkley
    T/D de goey
    please comment of you think the others are better options, cheers

    2

    1
    Reply

  47. Really unsure about the merits of this

    TU Trade Bolton/ Bramble and get in one of Butters/ Bailey / Jackson
    TD save last trade

    0

    2
    Reply

  48. Should i use my last trade to get rid of either Mills or Lloyd.

    Or field both Bianco and Durham in defence and save my last trade for the grand final (if i make it)

    Anyone know if they are both expected back next week?

    1

    0
    Reply

    1. Callum Mills – Achilles
      Sydney update: “Will continue to be monitored but the club is optimistic about him returning for finals, if not before.”

      Sydney update: “Lloyd will miss the game due to knee soreness.”

      1

      0
      Reply

      1. Thanks CT, now with Stewart also out i dont have much choice but to use this last trade. Its just choosing who of the 3 to trade out. Im thinking of Mills out so i can bring in Rich. Hoping lloyd and stewart are both back next week.

        0

        0
        Reply

  50. Alright legends, was super stingy with trades and now with a bit of luck I’ve got 4 trades left and will be full premo with no injuries this week. This week I am trading out Dusty/Highmore
    T/U – Miller/Titch and Sam Taylor (and which one?)
    T/D – Bont and Harris Andrews

    1

    1
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *