Who else is on your radar?
2
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Skip to content
The original and the best. Your #1 resource for daily AFL SuperCoach tips and analysis.
Unfortunately I’m going to have to miss Bailey Smith this week. I’m forced to make a Pittonet to ruck trade (Probably Gawn). My other trade will probably be a downgrade, likely Green or McInerney for a rookie. Is Simpson still a viable pick up even after the 50-60k rise in price?
T/U: Yes! Job security looks pretty good with more injuries to the Cats
T/U: Nope, look elsewhere
JS was already decent with injuries to the Cats and two good performances, now very solid with Ablett out. Bring him in.
Culling Pittonet and bringing in Ridley this week, but don’t know which rookie to get rid of. Got a playing Starcevich @ D6 and a non-playing Butler @ D7. Would be nice to push Starc to down to D7 and get rid of a dead rookie, but it’ll cost me an extra 110k~.
What to do?
T.U: Cash is key, get rid of Starcevich and bank the 110k for upgrades next week.
T.D: Starc will be useful during the byes, clear out the dead wood in Butler.
Im carrying Starc for a bit longer. Yes he is losing cash but he is still in our best 22 and he will come in handy as m/d swing with butler during byes
Overwhelming consensus in favour of holding Starc lol. Hold it is then.
Cheers, all.
If you got the cash, is Gawn a must?
T/U Yes absolutely!
T/D No, use the cash and make up in other areas
Depends on your team Dew, give us a look and itll allow us to make a better judgement.
B – Doc, Sic, Rid, Laird, Starc, Hill. Bench – Brander, Gould
C – Neale, Titch, Steele, Danger, Cripps, Cogs, Pickett, Simpson. Bench – D.Robertson, T.Green, Rivers
R – Grundy, Pitt. Bench – Conroy
F – Simpkin, Martin, A. Brayshaw(Freo), D.Smith, Vandermere, Rankine. Bench – Budarick, D.Cameron
Sitting in top 2% and scored 2200 this week so still waiting for rank change. Have 470k in bank, still need to upgrade rookies
Your cash generation is running thin, Dew.
No one on your DEF or MID bench is playing and neither is your F8. While Gawn’s the obvious choice, you could grab Rankine and Simpson this week instead to sure up your side, both in terms of warm bodies and cash gen, for the byes.
I have most of the good midfield rookies (and midfield coverage), with no coverage in the backline. With 560k in the bank from last week’s double downgrade, I can either go:
TU Macrae, Smith in for Brander (FWD), Brown
TD Ryan, Smith in for Brander (FWD), Starcevich
Thoughts coaches?
Whats more important to you, Gawn and downgrade a rookie or move pitt to English as a stepping stone and upgrade Starc Hill or even D Smith albeit i think the previous 2 are more pressing issues.
Any rookies with good JS to target this week?
Rankine and Simpson.
Thoughts on Sam Mayes or Eggmolese-Smith? If you’ve already got Rankine and Simpson?
Hi Zac, Mayes was an emergency about 17 times before having his debut. During that time they had few injuries In the mids as well. JS is not solid but he could just be a nice rookie POD downgrade. Get Eggmolese-Smith.
Okay week 1 of taking out the trash.
McInerary > Simpson (Keeping Budarick/Starc as bench cover since their JS is solid)
Rozee > Bailey Smith.
Brought Rozee the week before he scored the 145 and since then his been a disaster. Lost his midfield time and more importantly lost me money. Swapping Pittonet for Gawn last week was clutch so hoping for more of the same.
Did some reshuffling and if i go:
Brander > Simpson (via Rivers dpp)
I can get C.Taylor > Bailey Smith
This gives Rozee another chance but leaves me with 100$.
This week going T.Brown to Treloar
Then thinking;
Tu; Budarick to Bailey Smith
Td; Budarick to Simpson (even after price rise)
Is Steele a must? Ranked top 10 overall and dominating in the saints engine room..
TU he’s a bull…get him before he tops 620+
Td he won’t last. Wait for the lull to hit
Who to trade out for B.Smith
TU: C.Taylor
TD: M.King
Tough.
Taylor has the higher BE (80) but might hit that v Blues. King’s BE’s is only 53 and he might struggle v Port. Taylor probably the better on-field option through the byes, so maybe send King packing.
Simple one for me this week (pending teams)
Brander —> Simpson
M King —> Bailey Smith
Thinking of going McInerney and S Hill out. Bailey Smith and Will Day in??
Hill still has cash to make and obvious JS…have any other rookies? Perhaps non playing?
Who to trade out for Bailey Smith
TU: Bewley
TD: Curtis Taylor
Does anyone see Derek Eggmolese-Smith ($246.9k) as a viable option in the defense?
He looks to have the Houli role, and could be a good cash generator before moving him onto one of the clear Top 6 defenders.
Is it just me or is it impossible to have confidence in any players being clear top 6/8 of their position this year…
Serious question. Need to bring in a ruck (have Gawn) for Pittonet. Is there any real alternative to Grundy?
Probably not, unless one of the second tier ruckman get given a JUICY run the fixtures tmmrw.
score of 2347 this week with $285K in bank, which i believe is more good luck than good management. Team is
Haynes, doc, ridley, saad, day,macpherson (rivers,gould)
neale, cripps, macrae, titch, steele,simpkin,viney,pickett (mcinerney,bennell, robertson)
gawn, grundy (cameron)
whitfield, greenwood,dsmith, vandermeer,king,rankine (taylor,aarts)
bench is shit defence wise – do i
t/u trade to get bench coverage or
t/d trade to upgrade on field?
Thinking of double upgrade
King -> Bailey Smith
T.Brown – > Whitfield
Big call this week, definitely an upgrade needed. Stuck between Treloar and Bailey Smith, both should comfortably beat the breakevens. King will probably go out. Whichever player I don’t get, should have enough cash to get the week after.
TU: Treloar (via DPP)
TD: Bailey Smith
Season is shot. Had a minimum of one premo per week going down injured and well out of the race. It’s been so dire I’ve been stuck with a donut the last two weeks.
Cash is no object – Looking at one of Whitfield/Petracca/ Greenwood for the forward line.
WWYD?
Got 850k to spend before trades
Still need to upgrade
Starcevich / noble , 1 onfield
Buderick / Pickett , 1 onfield
Taylor / king ( stk ) 1 onfield
Defiantly bringing in Smith this week
& not sure what to do with Ceglar ?
TU: Sam Mayes
TD: Sam Simpson
???
I’d be wary of Simpson now. JS is good, but had 0 CBA and with Ablett missing weeks, Simpson could be a permanent forward. Was only on 13 or something at HT, and if he drops a 30-40 now, it’ll kill his cash gen.
So my plan to get Gawn in this week took a massive hit with Pittonet’s pitiful score. My trade out targets for this week are Townsend and Pittonet’s and this was supposed to net me both Gawn and Macrae.
My current midfield consists of Neale,
Mitchell Greenwood,Cripps,
Yeo,Viney,Pickett and Simpson
If I go Gawn it only leaves me with 533 k for a midfielder. If I go Goldie I can have any midfielder I like. The same if I went English. Do I
TU Gawn and Cogs
TD Goldy/English and Macrae
Gawn and Gaff in the Perth hub.
tim kelly
I like that Jo! Matt, Unfortunately Gaff has a super high BE and Kelly looks to be settling in at Optus stadium, question is , do WCE go back to Qld and how long do they stay in Perth for?
Gawn is a must. I’m stuck with Goldy/Grundy and if I would dearly love to grab Gawn for Goldy but can’t waste the trade right now.
traded in neale 3 weeks ago fully expecting a bit of a price drop going fwd
but 100 k in 4 weeks
f u lachie
is aaron hall a viable option /
365k mid , BE of 17
scored 109 after zeibel’s hammy went twang
TBrown -> Bailey Smith
Pittonet -> Gawn
And unless someone breaks a leg, I’m logging out of Supercoach for the rest of the week…
978k in the bank where’s the smartest place to spend this week plz???
B- Lloyd, Docherty, Ridley, Maynard, Hill, McPherson, Gould
M- Neale, Mitchell, J.Kelly, Serong, Pickett, Stephens, Bennell, Simpson, Rowell, T. Green, McInerney
R- Gawn, Grundy, Cameron
F- Greenwood, T.Greene, Whitfield, Keays, Rankine, Taylor, Sturt, Kelly
Far too many rookies in the midfield, Antos. Trade Rowell and one of the others for two premiums – take your pick as you should be able to afford any of them.
Is Danger gonna be bumped forward now Ablett gone?? Hes this obvious pick for me and Mcrae. T.Kelly should do better now West Coast are back home too
Shuey may stuff that thought process up!
TU Gawn + No Bank
TD English + $$ for Mid upgrade
Thanks
Thanks, thinking the same, defs need to clean up all the non playing cheapies will bit me sooner or later. Any PODs out there or just grab Simpkin after his low score last week and one of the usual Ie: Danger/Fyfe/Bont etc?
Would appreciate thoughts, contemplating whether to keep D Smith (BE 89):
T/U: Trade D Smith to Bailey Smith
T/D: Keep D Smith and Upgrade C Taylor (BE now 80) to Bailey Smith.
Cheers everyone, good luck!!
Double upstage or double downgrade
Butler, D.Smith- Petracca, J.steele TU
Or
Brander, T.Green – S.Simpson, S,Mayes
Do we have a definitive call from SC on the double game round for dons/dees ?? I’m thinking Saad for D5. Already have Ridley.
I think we’ll have rolling byes. 2-4 teams having byes per week for the next 5 or so rounds. Dees and Dons are considered to have had their bye so there won’t be any more, Saad is worth considering for this reason
TU Whitfield
TD Smith
Cheers!
Looking to rebound after a drop in the rankings…
TU: King > B. Smith and D. Smith > Petracca
TD: King > B. Smith and Brander > C. Daniel / Maynard
Smith and Maynard
Heys guys need some help.
TU: Taylor/King to B Smith and Tom Green to Whitfield
TD: Trade Budarick to Rankine then just do one upgrade.
So either double upgrade or 1 up 1 down. Not too sure what to do
Double up. Budarick could come in handy as cover during the next period.
TU English + Bailey Smith
TD Gawn + Cody Weightman
Cheers
Would like to get Gawn in for Pitt, could easily trade in Starc, T Green, McInerney, King, Taylor. Who should I dump?
My Team:
Def: Haynes, Doc, Sicily, Ridley, SPS, Starc (Rivers, BZT)
Mid: Cripps, McRae, Bont, C Oliver, Simpkin, Whitfield, D Smith, Pickett (T Greenm McInerney, Robertson)
Ruck: Grundy, Pitt (D Cameron)
Fwd: Petracca, Martin, Taylor, King, Rankine, Aarts (Brander, Sturt)
$264k ITB
Brodie Smith is killing me. Two tonnes out of the past three games then pulls out a 13. THIRTEEN!!!
TU – Dump him, he’s too inconsistent
TD – Hold, he’ll bounce back and be a suitable D6
Can someone please tell me where I can find stats which tell you things like midfield minutes, how many centre bounces started etc?
Just looking to do some more in depth analysis on some players before bringing them into my side/
Hey Razor.
The AFL website posts CBA’s every week and I use FanFooty to check stats and that also has TOG.
FanFooty is very useful if haven’t heard of it before.
Thoughts on Ben McKay’s JS?
Need a good DEF downgrade for Young to bring in Gawny, and can’t afford Day since Pitto had a shocker. Already have McPherson and Hamill. Alt is Butler.
TU: McKay
TD: Butler
Got 1million to spend on 1 defender and 1 forward after trading out starc and d.smith. Got Grawndy and 6 premo mids with nice rookies so I’m happy there.
Current lineup is:
Def: Lloyd, doch, sicily, s.hill, mcpherson
For: Walters, A.brayshaw, whitfield, king, rankine
I’m thinking dusty and houston.. I’ve already got bont and macrae so not sure about smith.. but it would allow me to then get any defender (Haynes I like)
Cheers
Keep D Smith and trade out King. If you end up with D Smith at F6 then you are not in bad shape.
So King and starc for b.smith and Houston is a better option? And hope Smith starts to perform
Any love for Dayne Zorko?
Only 487k with a BE of 55 due to his injury-affected score in R4 (where he was on track to go huge before the injury). Only in 1.5% of teams.
TU: Might be a good POD
TD: Just get Bailey Smith
zork is gna kill neales scoring
Who to trade out for Bailey Smith this week? Curtis Taylor has a BE of 80 and will lose a little bit of of cash but is averaging better than max king who is creeping towards his culling point.
T/U : trade Taylor
T/D: trade King
Comment cut Darcy Cameron from my bench (ill net ~140k less)
Going to turf Starcevich.
TU: Ben Mckay (146k) with his debut of 86
TD: McPherson (158k) with his 76, 52.
Comment: Get in EGG (247k) and hope for good JS with his 119 he pulled out.
Alternatively I upgrade Starcevich…
TU: Sicily
TD: Ryan
TU
Pittonet>Gawn
T Green > McPherson
TD
T Green>Simpson
M King > Steele/Treloar/other mid
Tu: Sam Mayes
Td: Bailey Smith
Best trade target for a fallen premium mid; Tim Kelly, Coniglio, or Yeo?
TU: T. Kelly ($511k)
TD: Coniglio ($501k)
Comment: Yeo ($499k)
Yeo
Trade Fyfe out
TU: Yes out
TD: NO
TU
– Pitt > Gawn
– King/Taylor > Rankine
TD
– Pitt > Gawn
– King/Taylor > Bsmith
have 500k in the bank atm but need to start bringing in premos, but also rankine seems like too much cash to give up and could potentially score well anyway as he has so far
Pittonet > Gawn
??? > Bailey Smith
I’m trying to figure out who would be the best upgrade candidate for Smith, I have plentiful options due to DPP magic.
Here are my eligible candidates: Budarick, Sturt, Townsend, Taylor, McInerney, Rivers
Obviously best to wait til teams on Thursday, but would love to hear who you all think is a priority upgrade (if there is one).
I would be getting rid of any non-playng rookies. Warm bodies on the bench should be vital over the next few weeks.
Looking to build my defence can’t afford lloyd
TU: Sicily
TD: Daniel
Comment:
Maynard
Doedee
got him at the start already
McInerney and C Taylor for S Simpson and B Smith
Trade 1: Brown > Simpson
Trade 2: ???
T/U: Naismith > Bailey Smith ($11k Bank)
T/D: Non-playing rookie > Rookie
eg. Brander/Sturt/Rivers > Mcpherson/Day/etc for bigger bank and get Smith next week.
I have Budarick,Starc and Taylor but can’t afford to offload them as they are my only playing bench atm.
To the tiger army
Will Jake Aarts survive after kicking a couple that could easily been four ?
makes me nervous not having bench cover for next week if he gets dropped
TU- yeah he did enough to cling to a spot
TD-players coming back , could be shakey
Going two premo mids in this week I think, already have Bazlenka and Gawn. Have 600k in the bank so can grab basically any two I want. Using DPP, I’m going Taylor and King out for Luke Parker and another fallen premo. Thinking either:
TU: Gaff, usually consistent but can be tagged out of games.
TD: Zorko, high ceiling and 1% ownership, super cheap but injury prone?
Keen to hear peoples thoughts.
Sorry but who is Bazlenka – have seen this moniker a few times but can’t figure out who it is?
It’s Bailey smith, people say that instead of b smith as to not get confused with adelaides b smith
Hi, was just wondering on your guys thoughts and trades for my team
Currently
Def- Haynes, Maynard, Ridley, Weller, Docherty, Daniels (BZT and Gould)
Mid- Neale, Kelly, Mitchell, viney, whitfield, pickett, budarick, bennel (Brown, mcinerny, rivers)
Rucks- gawn grundy (conroy)
Fwds- Martin, dev Smith, Bradshaw, King, Taylor, rankine (cavarra, bedford)
Tu- King and Bzt for Mackay and trealor
Td- king and Bzt for eggmolese and bailey smith
Need advice!
Should I get rid of green & pittonet for Simpson & O’Brien
Or
Green & rozee for Simpson & b.smith
T/U option 1
T/D option 2
Thanks everyone and good luck with your teams
TU: Max King to B Smith
TD: Curtis Taylor to B Smith
Finally trading out Rowell.
TU: Bailey Smith
TD: Hugh Greenwood.
Also considering Steele. Can afford anyone though. Thoughts appreciated.
Jack Steele
Pit – Rob
Brown – Rankine
300k banked
Next week
Budda- Bailey Smith
and possible Taylor, Brander downgrade if possible
Cancel Rob yucky draw English time
SOS (Son of Shaggi) wants to know coaches thoughts on his trade for this week.
Devon Smith and Pittonet out
Parker and Coniglio in
Only leaves 5k in the bank though
Shaggi, hard to say. I’ve got D Smith in my lineup aswell. Right now, he’s scoring, below expectations, but scoring. I’ve decided to hold him for now….suitable for F5 or 6.
I’d be losing Pittonet for sure.
Smith depends on your team list. I dropped King and Green for Greenwood and Simpson.
I’m going all guns blazing from here on in. Points or bust!
ripper round for me, 2,328 points with grundy captain instead of gawn, pretty happy about that, ive got 100k in the bank and am looking to get another star backman, already had maynard, doedee, docherty, daniel, starcevich and w. day in the backline, thinking of trading out either starcevich now or waiting on days price to increase and trade him, thoughts
TU: wait on days price to go up
TD: get rid of starcevich now
how’s McKay’s js with the carnage down at Arden St?
I would say JS is pretty good.
Brown needs support in the forward line and Walker looked okay up there.
Therefore we need another tall back and he had a good game against Lynch holding him goalless.
He wont pick up many possies but will rely on defensive actions like spoils and 1%’a to score.
The only down side I can see is Msjak must be getting close to a return
You guys are probably sick of me posting every week, but I’m just trying to do what I can to improve on having some kind of success this year (which is highly unlikely at this point).
So I did a lot better last week, but again I’m in a pit of fire with the amount of people I need to get rid of.
My current team:
DEF – Docherty, Laird, Doedee, Hurn, Starcevich, Williamson (Brander, Rivers)
MID – Treloar, Macrae, J. Kelly, Bontempelli, Cripps, Whitfield, Budarick, Pickett (Green, McInerney, Brown)
RUC – Grundy, Pittonet (Conroy)
FWD – Simpkin, Martin, D. Smith, Taylor, King, Rankine (Aarts, Cameron)
$357k remaining
I was originally thinking of doing Starcevich and Devon Smith out for Ridley and Bailey Smith, but I just think of the full list that I need to get rid of:
Starcevich, Williamson, Brander, Rivers, Green, Budarick, McInerney, Brown, D. Smith, Taylor and Cameron. I’m not sure which ones I should get to bugger off out of my team first.
So the question again this week is the same as last week. Which people should I trade in/out, or should I just quit and give up because I suck?
Hey man don’t stress about posting, the whole point of this website is for everyone to help each other out and be each other’s soundboard!
As for your team I think pitto is gotta be a big point to upgrade this week so go pitto to Gawn and start getting some bench cover and cash generation. As your second trade I think it’s gotta be Brown or McInerney down to a rookie possibly Simpson if you think he’s your best choice. If you get Simpson I think you can move budarick onto bench and pray Simpson gets time in the middle rather than up forward
Would you blame me if I got Goldstein instead of Gawn?
Not that Gawn’s anywhere near being a bad player, not doubting his legendary skills. And I don’t mean to brush off your advice with any disrespect either. But I don’t think spending around $800k on someone is worth it. I’d rather wait a few weeks for his price to go down if I was to get him. Goldstein hasn’t gone below 107 this year, and averages more than Grundy. So he’s very consisent too, plus he saves me another $107k. Only 5.8% of people have him too, so he could prove to be a very handy POD.
I don’t think anyone would fault you for going with Goldy but you have to make the extra cash work for you. Obvious I know, but it’s a bit more than ‘just get a better player’ – it’s a math problem.
Assuming Goldy and Gawn continue around their current averages (which is reasonable given that both are veterans with long histories of good scoring), then you are giving up 200 points for the rest of the season (20 ppg x 10 games) but saving 107k.
Is there another spot on-field where that 107k can gain you an extra 200 points over the remaining 10 games? Probably – just need to be reasonably certain that the increase will hold for the season (and / or the cash increase will be sufficient for upgrades – in regular years, that target is 150k but I think most coaches are going with 100-125k this year).
*Side note – this is why these moves matter more earlier in the season – it’s harder to make a 50 ppg trade in round 14 than a 20 ppg trade in round 8.*
For example: Budarick is averaging 50 @ 223k . Mayes / Simpson / Pickett are all under 330k and should average 70 from here (Mayes / Simpson’s scores will certainly drop from their current averages). You can do the same for Starcevich, Williamson, Taylor, and King.
It’s harder to find a 20+ ppg increase for a mid-priced or premium player. Take Devon Smith as an example, he’s averaging 80 for the year. Priced at 390k, you’d need someone under 500k that’s averaging 100 in order to get the same ‘points return on-field’ – and there isn’t a player that fits that bill at the moment. If you consider 3- or 5-round averages, you’d find Dixon, Lambert, and Jack Martin would fit the bill. Will they maintain a 100+ average? Dixon has only ever achieved a 90 average twice (2013 and 2017) and has been in the league for 10 years – unlikely he’s a break-out candidate. Lambert’s been a high-80’s average for 3 years but is in the right age-range for a break-out (more likely, his increase is due to the injuries at Richmond). Martin also doesn’t have the history on his side (low 80’s average most years) but he played for the Suns, who were not great over that period of time. His age (25) says potential break-out and his current role at Carlton is a good fit for his skill set. Of the three, I’d be most confident with Martin but having said that, I’d be more confident that Pickett or Simpson can maintain a 70-average.
* I’m ignoring clearing out your bench even though that is also necessary.
TU – Mayes
TD – Simpson
T/U Trade in Gawn & Day
T/D Trade in English & premo
Hutta , question for you.
Macrae has had a very average
( by his standards) start to the year. He seems to be just hitting his straps now, any coincidence that both his poor start and recent form return is due to Bailey Smith? In a nutshell is Bailey Smith taking points off him?
TU Ben McKay (providing he’s named)
TD Will Day
TU: Trade out Fyfe out for 2-3 Weeks .
TD: Bench him rookie to cover
13 trades left / 5 rookies on field
Tu:
Starcevich/Brander > Eggmolesse Smith
Tyler Brown > Sam Mayes
Td:
Max King > Bailey Smith
Tyler Brown > Darren Minchington / Elijah Taylor
Comment:
Brander / Starfish > Eggmolesse
Brown > Minchington
120k to help get Bailey Smith in next week.
T/U – Louis Butler to Crisp/Sicily
T/D – Sturt to Bazlenka
Fyfe and King to Petracca and B Smith. T.U yes. T.D. no
Tu; Treloar & B. Smith
Tu; Ridley & Walters
T/U Pitt & Starc for Gawn & Day
T/D Pitt & D.Smith for Gawn & B.Smith
F2: Petracca, Simpkin, or Walters?
TU for Gawn and 140k
TD for English and 3310k
If i go english i can possibly get 2 premos next week
if i go gawn its only one premo
Gawn has a game in hand and is going to be in the mix for captaincy duties each week. That’s worth the extra cash
Current mids: Fyfe, Cripps, Oliver, macrae, bont, Simpkin, Pickett, simpson
Tu:
Fyfe > Greenwood (Can dpp swap your fwd line
Brander > Petracca
Td:
Fyfe > treloar
Cameron (via Williams ruck dpp) > eggmolesse-smith
(Gets starc off the field but I can keep him as emergency and have the egg as a healthy d6)
Looking to bring it Bazlenka like everyone else. Tossing up between Max King who has mostly peaked or Tom Green who isn’t getting a game but might with these shorter breaks. Also considering just cutting ties with Devon Smith but the bombers not having a bye is appealing to keep him around a bit.
TU: M King
TD: T Green
Comment: D Smith
Cut bait with a poor scorer
TU: D Smith
Hi all,
Probably time to upgrade someone in my midfield or forwards. As my DEFs are fine.
Would probably trade out Budarick and Mclnerney or Taylor or Brander, I don’t know someone please help lol.
DEF: Haynes, Daniels, Doc, Sicily, Ridley, Williamson (S.Hill, McPherson)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Bont, Cripps, A.Brayshaw (Freo), Pickett, Mclnerney, S.Simpson (Budarick, Rivers, Robertson)
RUC: Gawn, Grundy (Cameron)
FWD: Whitfield, D.Martin, D.Smith, C.Taylor, Rankine, Mahony (Brander, Aarts)
19 Trades left, $268,000 in the bank
Help would be gratefully appreciated
Cheers
Who to bring in this week?
TU Treloar
TD Petracca
TU Petracca
TD Viney
Trac it is. Cheers legends.
Rucks are a bit of an issue for me with Nic Nat and Pitt so getting rid of Pitt this week.
TU: B Grundy
TD: T English
Comment: any other ideas
Worth noting I started with English and traded him to Pittonet after a lousy start so it would hurt a little to go back now
Going to trade out Fyfe
TU: Taylor Adams
TD: Steele ( St.Kilda)
I have been all over Taylor Adams Tully.
Well all over him in the sense that I keep putting him on my watchlist, but never actually trade him in……..this might be the week though.
Steele probably has the ability to go bigger, but I think Adams has the consistency. I don’t think he has been below 100 yet this year.
Either is a good option.
Pitt & D.Smith – Gawn & B.Smith
Pitt & D.Smith – Goldy/English & Petracca
Worth keeping in mind that D Smith has a game in hand. Not killing it with his average but his total points might make it worth keeping him if you can
What are we doing with Simpkin having missed training and missing this week?
Tu: Hold (should only be a 1 week injury)
TD: Trade (could be 2+, with extra trades get rid of him)
Was just thinking this, If I trade out Pitt and Simpkin I now have cash for Gawn and other other premo, but not sure if I want to trade out Simpkin if its only going to be a week long injury
Im contemplating the same and swapping to Petracca. Just trying to work out what Simpkins price might be after 2 games back (gold isnt showing a BE or price for any of the new round at the moment)
I’ve given up this season. Looked forward to this week, was expecting a big score but with Simpkin injured I have to field a Aarts over him how great.
Trading out Fyfe. Wanted Parker but the Bye throws him off
T/U – Treloar
T/D – Petracca
Comments – Adams, Steele, Petracca
Ugh exact same problem, can’t decide between Treloar or Petracca
Treloar is gonna have a bye at some point as well. If you’re worried about a player missing just one week then you have to take Melbourne or Essendon players
Hi all,
Who to trade in and out?
Help would be gratefully appreciated
Would probably trade out Budarick and Mclnerney or Taylor or Brander, I don’t know someone please help lol.
DEF: Haynes, Daniels, Doc, Sicily, Ridley, Williamson (S.Hill, McPherson)
MID: Neale, Oliver, Bont, Cripps, A.Brayshaw (Freo), Pickett, Mclnerney, S.Simpson (Budarick, Rivers, Robertson)
RUC: Gawn, Grundy (Cameron)
FWD: Whitfield, D.Martin, D.Smith, C.Taylor, Rankine, Mahony (Brander, Aarts)
19 Trades left, $268,000 in the bank
Cheers
Just my opinion and feel free to do otherwise. But if I were you I’d trade Brander/Taylor (leaning towards Brander) and pick up Bailey Smith with your first trade. I’d probably downgrade with your other trade. McInerney for either Egg or Mayes who are likely to make a bit of cash over the next few weeks
Eggs is DEF and How secure is Mayes’ JS, was looking to get Bailey Smith.
Whats better to trade Brander and Switch via DPP and have Stephen hill on my FWD bench, and Bailey smith would replace McInerney in that midfield space.
TU – Tom Green & Ben King -> Adam Treloar & Bailey Smith + $230k
TD – Bailey Williams & Ben King -> Jake Lloyd & Bailey Smith + $150k
Could trade out Starc & Taylor but I want bench cover coming into byes
Hello all, with the extra trades in mind is it worth trading an injured premo to get big Max in ? Might be now or never..
TU: Simpkin/Taylor > Gawn/ Simpson.. 2k itb
TD: double downgrade Taylor/Brander> Simpson/Macperson or McKay .. and keep Pittonet…200k itb
Are you guys 100% sure Simpkin won’t play??