76 thoughts on “Trade Talk – Round 21”

    1. I need clarification that the thumbs down to this means that thumbs down to getting him, or thumbs down to the suggestion that he’ll be getting tagged

      0

      1
      Reply

      1. Can’t speak for everyone but I treated it like a trade suggestion: thumbs up means get him, down means he’s a tag risk. For the price I’d suggest looking elsewhere

        14

        0
        Reply

  6. 2 trades left and holding them. Mills M8 only worry at the moment (looping with George Hewett) and no English.

    8

    0
    Reply

  8. Dilemma with my final remaining trade….

    Cincotta is my D 6 and Max Holmes is my Mid 8….I’d like to get rid of Cincotta but will only have around $380k to replace him, and if I get rid of Holmes I’ll have about $530k to play with for a solid Mid. Should I just accept I’ll be lacking in Defence and secure another strong Mid?

    TU: Trade Cincotta
    TD: Trade Holmes

    Thanks!

    0

    23
    Reply

    1. Pedro if you work it out on averages its not much difference, but if you look at other things it makes sense to trade Holmes to eg Macrae.

      Cincotta plus Macrae averages get you to 164 points.
      Holmes plus Ballard gets you to 161 points. Not much in it.
      But you would have to think that Macrae plus Cincotta has a higher floor, higher ceiling, and much higher potential, especially if you can have Macrae on field and can loop Cincotta.

      4

      0
      Reply

  11. What happens to Soldo now ? Bought him in to cover Cameron and get some cash 3 weeks ago. He’s been good but I guess he’ll make way for Nank ? He’s made enough cash for a 486k fwd or back. Thinking Llord ?

    1

    0
    Reply

    1. Soldo will hold his place. They will play 2 rucks i reckon to try and stop English.

      He wont score as much as recently but could hold as a F7 loop option. But is he is an onfield option then probably a trade out

      9

      0
      Reply

        1. Don’t go near Jackson. Week to week he’s given me nightmares for half the year. Games where he should go nuts(like sat) and did for a half, then goes nowhere.

          2

          1
          Reply

  12. Anyone thinking Oliver’s a chance this week?
    TU easy game to return back with roos
    TD won’t risk him coz it’s only roos

    0

    15
    Reply

  13. 4 trades left.

    Should I look to upgrade Keays and Mills or save trades for injuries?

    Tu – yep
    TD – nup

    22

    3
    Reply

  16. Can only afford these 2 for my last spot – who to pick?

    T/U – George Hewett
    T/D – Jeremy Cameron

    15

    16
    Reply

  18. Currently have 2 trades and 292k itb

    Will be trading Windhager this week, who to trade him to…..?

    T/U – Petracca = 1 trade & 32,000 itb

    T/D – Butters = 1 trade & 132,600 itb

    Thanks

    18

    0
    Reply

    1. Dunkley imo – he’s somewhat of a partial POD now too as quite a few jumped off.

      Gulden throws out some amazing scores but also serves up the occasional lemon.

      Dunkley is rolled gold. Can’t go wrong with him.

      12

      0
      Reply

  21. Asked this last week (poll was pretty even) but ended up not pulling the trigger as league win was pretty safe.

    Trade Ashcroft to:

    T/U – Touk Touk
    T/D – Jelly

    Comment – Reccomend someone different (can be essentially any line. If going a midfielder it drops either C. Mills or J. Cameron to the bench).

    6

    7
    Reply

    1. Both a little risky. Touk has been getting specific roles rather than just playing in the guts and Jelly has Green coming back this week.

      2

      0
      Reply

  22. I will have to leave one on the field Fletcher Lions or Mcvee Melbourne . Who will be the best for the finals. T/U Fletcher. T/D. McVee

    8

    2
    Reply

  24. Anyone got some intel on Keays? Been slightly frustrating this last month and assume he’s been playing more forward. Can move him on but also aware if to hold that 3 of his next 4 he’s tonned up against this season. Should I expect similar?

    If not have 610k in bank to swap.

    1

    0
    Reply

    1. Don’t think there is room for him in the guts at the moment. Crouch has come in and doesn’t look like being dropped. Might still get a tagging role that drags him in there occasionally. If on field and you have multiple trades then I’d be tempted to move him on.

      7

      0
      Reply

  26. Anyone have any thoughts on whitfield? Great 3 round average
    Havent seen any giants games, so not sure of the change – filling in for Tom green?
    And is the run going to continue?

    1

    3
    Reply

  28. Need to trade out Cerra. Only $5k in the bank.

    Tossing up between Brayshaw (Fre), Serong, Butters or left field Curnow or Walker.

    Comments welcome.

    TU: Brayshaw
    TD: Serong

    7

    5
    Reply

    1. 1 trade, 200k in the bank
      Thumbs up: Redman>Ryan (defence)
      Thumbs down: Keays>Rozee (fwd)
      Comment: should I use the last trade to get a mid priced dpp cover on the bench?

      4

      12
      Reply

    1. Got the same conundrum. Was thinking Butters but McCrae looks to have the easier draw with Tigers, Hawks and Eagles the next 3?

      3

      0
      Reply

      1. True JK – im swaying Butters as he can hurt you in the finals (if playing leagues) if he goes 150+

        0

        0
        Reply

  31. 2 trades left.

    Is it worth going Himmelburg to D. Cameron, or should I hold on to both trades in case of injuries? Currently ranked around 1200 aiming for top 1k

    TU – Do it
    TD – Hold just in case

    6

    14
    Reply

  32. 2 trades left..
    Neale in poor (premo) form, tag from Freo confirmed for Sunday.
    Thinking of trading to Parish who has WC and North coming?
    Have Hewett at M9 for cover..
    Pull the trigger?

    2

    10
    Reply

  35. 8 trades left, 3 trade boosts, 150 k ITB. Last upgrade if you count Mills, Daniel and Cameron as premiums. In 4 v 1 qualifying final v Lekdog.

    Thumbs Up Fletcher and Baker for Parish and Nankervis
    Thumbs Down Fletcher and Baker for Butters and Nankervis

    7

    6
    Reply

    1. Essentially that’s Butters v Parish 🙂
      Geez another tough call that one.
      Above we were musing over Butters v Macrae now you’ve added the Parishner to the mix.
      Also could add Treloar – same avg same price
      8 trades though! flip

      0

      0
      Reply

  37. Hey guys,
    I have $531.000K and my last trade. Just going to use himmleberg as a loop in my backline. So thinking Seamus Mitchell to either
    Macrae
    Or
    Touk Miller
    or if anyone can think of a better player at that price please comment.
    Cheers

    10

    7
    Reply

  38. Have RoMo and Briggs and wondering if I should swap out Briggs for Either Gawn or Tingles for a couple of knockout finals.

    TU worth doing at this stage
    TD keep Briggs and save your (3) trades.

    11

    1
    Reply

  39. If I do trade, which one serves better purpose.

    TU. Gawn as an anti pod (9%) and a hot streak without Grundy
    TD. Tingles to cover off half the competition

    7

    10
    Reply

  40. Hey guys what to do?
    use my last trade to go Mills to Petracca? And play Himmelberg on field
    Or
    trade Seamus Mitchell to Touk/Macrae and use Himmelberg as a Def loop
    Cheers

    6

    9
    Reply

  54. Need to get rid of Keays with only 532k to spend depending on amount of trades. 4 trades left. Playing in eliminations final

    TU – Crouch (1 Trade)
    TD – Cripps (2 trades – Nankervis second trade to make up the $)
    Thanks

    0

    0
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *