5
0
Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom
Skip to content
The original and the best. Your #1 resource for daily AFL SuperCoach tips and analysis.
Should have just titled this post “How Do I Get Dawson In – Round 5”.
Time travel, GD, as for round 6 that is another matter?
Yeah, I’ve always titled the Trade Talk threads after the round that’s just passed but, you’re right, it is a little weird. Hmm.
Will be odd when we’re in Round 24 but will edit now lol.
Since i haven’t copped a LTI this round I am not really sure what to do.
Probably do nothing.
No premos to replace, cows have a bit more fattening to go and nor is there a plethora of rookies screaming pick me.
Not concerned about ginbey and Mackenzie?
I assume you own both..
Yep Shaggi, same here this week, and the previous two weeks as well. Except missed that Witts was out again, so got Ryan’s score. Missing a few top premos going ballistic, not so fun, but holding fire while cows fatten up so I can upgrade instead of going sideways. See if short term pain pays off down the track.
Currently ranked in the top 1%.
Thinking of upgrading this week, early thoughts however..
Chandler > Williams
Ginbey > Wagner
Mackenzie > Touk Miller
Tu or Td
Wagner not ideal after 1 game however if I want to upgrade I need to make a double downgrade. Other option is to hold off and wait a week.
DEF – Dawson, Daicos , Ginbey
McKenna, Wilmot, Cowan
(Chesser, constable)
MID – Laird, Bont, LDU, Green, Hopper
Worpel, Ashcroft, Baker
(Mackenzie, philipou, long)
RUCK – Grundy, Marshall (madden)
FOR – Dunks, Taranto, Rozee, Gulden
Ziebell, Sheezel
( Greene, Davey)
31 trades $117k in bank. Trade thoughts?
Few big decisions this week with rookies stalling cash generation and some actually going to lose money with not too many on the horizon either. Well very few with decent scoring potential and JS.
Bytel, Mackenzie and ginbey all facing the axe this week. Hopefully one is dropped to stem the bleeding for atleast one week. Might be 2 down 1 up. I need cogs or Laird in.
Def – Stewart, Daicos, day, McKenna, Wilmot, Cowan (ginbey, constable )
Mid- Oliver, laird, bont, green, setterfield, hopper, Ashcroft, Hollands (McKenzie, Chesser, baker)
Ruc- Marshall, Witts (madden)
Fwd- Dunkley, Taranto, rozee, ziebell, shezzel, f.Greene (Ryan, van rooyen)
Got $101k in the bank with 3 boosts and 28 trades what should be the plan this week?
Need to get Ginbey and Mackenzie out, any downgrade options?
Might be worth it to at least hold one of them. Both are more than capable of reaching their BEs, they’ve both scored past their current BE scores and couple of times each so far.
If Mackenzie is the sub like last week, then ditch him. Only issue is a big lack of mid rookies on the bubble
Matt Roberts and Dylan Williams
Anyone know much about the JS for these two?
Roberts the sub in rds 1-3, didnt play rd 4, with their injuries he might get more opportunity? Not confident. 93 tasty though.
Williams looks an OK pick for the bench. Will he keep his spot
Trade Ginbey to:
TU Gulden
TD Cogs
Mackenzie > Roberts is a given.
I’m hesitant on downgrading Ginbey due to the lack of options we have currently.
Any move currently feels rushed and I don’t feel the need to burn a trade and a cow who hasn’t fattened yet just so I can pull off an upgrade.
You could always downgrade Ginbey to a fwd (Williams/Mitchell) if you swing Sheezel into def
Mitchell only has the one game played and I don’t know enough about Williams’ JS. Ginbey’s BE is projected to swing back to 43 next week, he could still generate another $60K or so.
A potential mid to fallen premo upgrade is Setters>Cogs.
Another potential premo to super premo is Green>Miller IF he gets rubbed out for multiple weeks.
I think Ginbey will have a rest as mentioned by his coach last week. Hopefully MacKenzie had his rest on the bench and gets a full game next week
Time to upgrade Setterfield?
Better to get all rookies off the field first
Which one to bring in first?
TU Dawson
TD Oliver
Looks like a coin toss then. If I go with Dawson then Oliver will do better. If I go with Oliver then Dawson will do better. If I decide who I want and then deliberately choose the other then I will still get it wrong. That is how the SC multiverse works!
Then PLEASE go Oliver (so the rest of us can safely trade in Dawson – lol)
Took Miller it is then 😉
This aged well
Thoughts on:
Ginbey > Roberts (via DPP, allows me to swing Sheezel back)
Setterfield > Dawson
much better week this week , moving up the rankings. Not sure if I want to keep on being aggressive or slow it down though.
TU: Ginbey > Roberts
TD: Ginbey, Ashcroft, Baker > Roberts, Johnson (or any other rookie), Touk
Triple Downgrade
OUT: Ginbey, Mackenzie & Chandler
IN: Roberts, Johnson & Williams
Leaves me with $481,800 for a double upgrade next week.
TU: Yay
TD: Nay
I like being aggressive. I’m not sure about this though. 3 decent rookies for 3 with question marks over their heads.
Bigger priority:
TU: Ridley to Dawson
TD: Brayshaw to Oliver
Ginbey and Mackenzie to Roberts and Miller.
Fall 20K short of Dawson and 10K short to Neale but touk has the better bye round. Good move?
I’ve noticed Lloyd is making a bit of a resurgence, averaging 106 at 533k
Is he worth picking up, or should I stick with Tom Stewart?
As in, get tom Stewart instead of lloyd
If you already have Stewart, stick with him. Dont sideways him out
Chayce Jones an option?
I really like the look of him, seems to have cemented his spot in the Adelaide side, with a sub score of 33 from 9 touches in 30% TOG and scores of 94 and 116 from 21 and 28 touches respectively off half-back and a wing, so it’s not a once off.
Is there risk associated? Of course, as with all midpriced picks
The downside is he’s never averaged more than 50 before (i.e. unproven), however with a BE of -31 and playing in a good side, I reckon he’s worth a shout and should be a good stepping stone.
Not at 300k, no.
More CBAs, fourth year, looks to have gone to another level. Is Serong a top 8 Mid?
TU – Yes
TD – No
Ginbey upgrade:
TU – Sinclair
TD – Lloyd
Mid Upgrade. Have 580k to play with:
TU: Serong
TD: Merrett/Parish
If TD, please vote which one :’)
TU: Merrett
TD: Parish
Zach Merrett has been offered a one-match ban for rough conduct.
Who to upgrade to as M1 this week?
TU – Lachie Neale
TD – Rory Laird
Hey guys would love some advice
Currently sitting at the 2k mark after 2400 for the round looking to keep climbing. This week going to go mckenzie to roberts which leaves me with 28 trades. Could go aggressive and use a boost to also get rid of ginbey and baker for Johnson/Williams or any rookie rly and Caleb Serong who is looking more and more like a top 8-10 mid. Worried about using the boost but thinking it’s better to use them earlier on for upgrading anyway
TU: Simple Mckenzie to Roberts (166k in bank, 28 trades 4 boosts)
TD: Mckenzie, Ginbey, Baker > Roberts, johnson, Serong (26 trades 3 boosts)
Long + Ginbey to Roberts and Cogs T/U
Long + Ginbey + Baker to Roberts, Williams and Touk T/D
Which Def to Trade Out?
TU: Cowan
TD: Ginbey
Which Mid to Trade Out?
TU: Mackenzie
TD: Baker
Thanks
Unsure what trades to make with team below:
Def: Dawson, Daicos, Stewart, Ridley, Ginbey, McKenna (wilmot, Cowan)
Mid: Clarry, bont, green, setters, hopper, Ashcroft, Phillips, mackenzie (phillipou, Davey, baker)
Ruck: Grundy, Marshall (madden)
Fwd: dunks, Taranto, rozee, Sheezel, chandler, Bruce (Greene, Ryan)
Currently 1310 rank with $197,700 in bank.
4 boosts remaining with 28 trades.
Thinking of using a boost with Bruce, Mackenzie & ginbey to Roberts, Williams and touk but unsure any ideas welcome!
Cheers.
General thoughts
You’re doing pretty well so just maintain the value of a trade. If you trade down do it to players you like.
If you trade up try and maintain 1 up 1 down
So what’s the go with roberts? Sub in his first 3 games? And now with injuries has more time on field? What position was he playing over the weekend didn’t have time to watch. Thanks
Who to get?
TU: Touk
TD: Laird
T/U – Double rookie trade for Rozee/ Cogs
T/D – Triple rookie trade for Bont/ Touk
High rank.
Don’t want to burn my good rookies so thinking about doing a boost and bringing in Cogs or Luke Jackson
TU do it they’re just bench rookies
TD just wait it out
Follow up question:
TU: Neale
TD: Serong + 65k for next week’s FWD upgrade
defender under 530ishk
TU:Lloyd (is he back??)
TD:Liam baker
Cogs via Sheezel DPP
Already have cogs, my fwd line is fine id say, only one i dont have is zeibell but im not 100% on him maintaining his role. The def fallen premo i dont have is sinclair.
not sure yet, but possibly :
Mackenzie -> Wagner
Cowan -> Mitchell/Gould
Ginbey -> Stewart
might be a week early?
T/U
T/D
Cheers legends
More important priority:
TU: Ridley to Dawson/Daicos – Premo to Uber premo
TD: Ginbey to Sinclair / Lloyd – 1 less rookie on field
I feel like points on field will be similar
Which is more important
TU: One simple downgrade for upgrades next week
TD: Using a boost to get a fallen premo like cogs or Sinclair this week
A. Brayshaw (Freo) has been a blight on my mids. He’s my M4 with only Holmes, Hopper and rookies behind him. It’s pretty bleak.
Do I pull the trigger to bring in Dawson or hold?
T/U bring in Dawson
T/D bring in Touk
TU: Bring in Oliver
TD: Wait a week
C. Jones in Def – bait or great? 308.3k
Did the Mackenzie to Brockman trade before the hawks game yesterday so current rookies are ok to hold for another weekend of footy.
Big question I have is trading Tom Green and Sicily to other premos? Both are not performing at all, particularly Green. Second year straight we’ve all been suckered in. Currently ranked in top 5k – top 700 score this weekend so feeling like I should go aggressive.
TU: Green, Sicily -> Bont/Oliver & Stewart
TD: Leave it and have patience
ITB: $171,000 and 29 trades left with 3 boosts
Cheers!
green is averaging 107 odd points in what world is is he underperforming? also got tagged in the second half yesterday and tonned up
That first round 134 is keeping his avg at 107.9
100, 106, 99 and 97. That’s no great and he didn’t ton up yesterday.
His lost money, so yes he is underperforming compared to his expectations and rest of the mids in SC.
Not underperforming at AFL level I must add.
fair enough my mistake he was a few points off, still think thats performing well though, lachie neale was scoring flat hundreds every week until the most recent now hes averaging 120 odd, the high ceiling and low floor is what makes them a premium mid imo
Get your rookies out first!
Thoughts on these changes?
OUT: Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker
IN: S. Mitchell, Roberts, Bont
DEF: N. Daicos, H. Andrews, T. Rivers, J. Buckley, R. Ginbey, C. McKenna …… L. Cowan & C. Constable (Bench)
MID: R. Laird, M. Bontempelli, T. Green, E. Gulden, W. Setterfield, J. Hopper, W. Ashcroft, C. Mackenzie….. A. Davey, O. Baker & N. Long (Bench)
RUC: J. Witts, R. Marshall ….. E. Ratugolea (Bench)
FWD: J. Dunkley, T. Taranto, C. Rozee, J. Ziebell, H. Sheezel, K. Chandler…. J. van Rooyen, J. Amartey (Bench)
28 Trades, 4 boost, $116.1k ITB
——–
TU: J. Amartey, O. Baker & C. Mackenzie >>> J. Dawson, D. Williams & A. Cincotta (Going early to scrape enough cash)
TD: J. Amartey & C. Mackenzie >>> D. Williams & M. Roberts w $381.1k ITB for next week and boost saved
Comment: Other ideas
The other thing to mention is I’ve started 1-4 so need to keep touch with the top 8.
Out: Hollands, McKenna, Chandler
In: Roberts, Williams, Miller
3rd boost, 23 trades left but 134th last week and top 1000 overall. Keep that foot on the gas baby.
TU:lloyd
TD; wait a week for sinclair (lets rookies gain a bit more too). Will just lose out on points
Seagull is just so consistent. His disposal efficiency is a major reason why he gets the points he does.
Which one is seagull hahaa
Ziegull
Lloyd
Jake Lloyd
Can’t quite get to Dawson, so planning on using a boost to go Mackenzie, Chandler and Ginbey >> Serong, Wagner and Williams.
TU Cogs
TD Gulden
TU: 2 trades to turn Ridley into Dawson
TD: 3 trades to turn Ginbey into Sinclair/Lloyd
Charlie Curnow > Matt Roberts
Anthony Caminiti > Dylan Williams
Conrad Williams > Lachie Neale
Just enough money in the bank to make these trades. Massively Downgrading Curnow to Roberts and massively Upgrading Williams to Neale. Any thoughts?
I can’t see Dylan Williams on lists to trade in ???
Dylan Williams – FWD – Pt Adel – $123,900
Yeah I had the same problem. Just click the arrow button on the top right of the ‘MY TEAM’ screen, search his name up in the search bar, click on the matching profile, click on the green button ‘TRADE PLAYER IN’. The Trades Centre page will then appear.
Is Macrae still a liable option to go to?
I’ve had him all year
He’s a far cry from the Macrae of old, and I highly doubt he’ll be a top 10 midfielder
I’ve heard rumours he’s carrying a rib injury, but from what I’ve seen the fact that he’s not a primary centre bounce midfielder (Bont, Libba, Treloar are preferred, Macrae averaging 51% CBAs), and he struggles to run out games, massively fading in the second half against both the Lions and the Power after being on track for massive scores.
As an owner, I have bigger problems, but I certainly wouldn’t bring him in.
Hi Guys,
I put in Mitch Duncan who got 34….and going to lose #$K this week
Thinking of up grading to Stewart.
Should I hold him or upgrade ???
TU Hold and give him time
TD Upgrade to Stewart
Thanks
T/U – Ridley to Sinclair
T/D – Ridley and McKenzie to Bont and Roberts
TU- Matt Roberts
TD- Matt Johnson
It was a fun few weeks owning Grundy
If Gawn returns this week is Grundy a must trade out?
T/U – Yes, must go.
T/D – No, hold him.
At the very least break even and you’ve probs got bigger fish to fry this week
Will al teams be acvised thursday night . And when will tuesday team be finialized ,is it monday at 5pm . Thanks
Am I the only person trying to trade down to Ports Dylan Williams, but cant find him anywhere ??
Have looked in the fwds?
Yep, but I think there is a gremlin at the moment.
I just traded him in and its working fine. Maybe re-start your PC or mobile?
Don’t get him wet… and whatever you do… don’t feed him after midnight!
what to do with green.
TU: trade
TD: hold
I see many say hold… what if I was trading him for laird??
I tend to use green for dragons, trees, grass
CMackenzie to
TU Sinclair
TD Cogs
Why is everyone trading roberts in? Sydney we’re missing a few on the weekend and hea straight out once they return.
Only him and Williams on the bubble.
Swans were missing key defensive stocks in Rampe and the McCartin brothers. Doesn’t affect Roberts.
He’ll do as a live downgrade.
CMack Ginbey Jones OUT
Cogs Sinclair Mitchell IN
TU Good Trades
TD Bad Trades
Dylan williams (PTA) Job security?
They moved DBJ to a pressure HF role, which was good. Williams would have been hard pressed to keep him out otherwise.
Decent enough.
Jack Ziebell, will he finish top 6-8 fwds, worth bringing in fwd and swing to def if needed?
Mackenzie -> Cogs
Ginbey -> Roberts
Phillipou -> Cincotta
Thoughts?
Out: Ginbey
In: Jones (crows)
TU or TD
OUT- MacKenzie..Chandler..Ridley
IN-Williams..Roberts(Mitchell).. Dawson
290k itb
T/U
OUT-Mackenzie..Chandler.. Gibney
IN- As above
1o5ITB
T/D
Thanks
Chandler and Mackenzie to a couple of the rookies that look alright and then Ginbey up to Stewart (Currently have Daicos, Redman and Ziebell as my only premo defenders but can’t afford Daws)
T/U
T/D
Hi guys.
Tossing up I should take a chance or stay safe.27 trades…
Gibney to Johnson
Green to Dawson
Duncan must go as will lose 34k to Zeibel
TU go for it
TD not a good idea.
Thanks
Who to bring in:
TU Stewart
TD Sinclair
Any news on aaron hall coming back for north?
For D3 (have dawson, daicos, day, buckley curremtly), fwd line is fine. 29 trades itb
TU: ziebell (2 trades)
TD: lloyd (3 trades/wait on sinclair next week – still 3 trades)
Does anyone know why the FILTER box has suddenly disappeared from my Trade Page screen?
Any tips on how I get it back?
Is it a widespread problem?
It makes the job of selecting players so much harder.
HELP please!
Mine has disappeared too, must be a bug on the app
Same problem. Should sort itself out.
Not enough people bought the supercoach gold or whatever it’s called so they are making the filter elements and the ability to switch between lines during trades a supercoach gold only feature.
Beware of buying the the gold/plus/whatever though coz heraldscum will auto bill you until you cancel your card or close the account regardless of how many times you turn off/cancel auto billing.
Worth trading Witts -> English?
TU: Pull the trigger
TD: See if Witts is back this week first
Tu:
Out – Ginbey, McKenzie, Callahan
In – Williams, Roberts, Dawson
Td:
Out – Ginbey, McKenzie
In – Williams, Zeibell and 100k itb or sinclair
Tu – Ziebell
Td – Sinclair
Mackenzie – Roberts
Baker – Johnson
Ginbey – Sinclair
Sinclair looks to have almost bottomed out, rather go him than Lloyd, Ryan and co. Still holding Setters who’s doing a decent job while getting the rookies off the field
Not sure about Sinclair. Wilkie(whom I’ve traded in)getting a lot of ball, makes me wonder about a slight role switch for Sinclair??
Last 2 weeks Sinclair been playing 30% cb’s will decrease with Steele back this week for 540k he’s value
Do you expect Sinclair’s scores to improve with Steele back in? Is that what’s happened historically?
Scores more playing half back
TU- Chayce Jones
TD- Jason Johannison
Can go Ginbey to Dawson if I downgrade Ashcroft instead of Mackenzie:
TU: Do it
TD: Hold on Ashcroft, get Sinclair instead
Can anyone provide advice on how to manage the byes?
I just used the bye planner and have a lot of premos from Round 15. Should I be looking at reducing that number?
It will impact my decision on getting Gulden or Coniglio this week.
Traditionally, you would try to spread your byes across your team so that you had as many players playing each week as you could (you could bump up those numbers by planning to bring premos in the week after they had their bye).
There’s been a couple extra strategies floating around though. One was tank one of the three bye weeks to focus on having the best performance in the other two weeks. Another, and one I might try personally this year, is a scorched earth strategy where you disregard byes and just aim to bring in the best premos for the best price, regardless of bye. I look forward to scoring 1200 points 3 weeks in a row.
Another thing to remember is only your best 18 scores count in the big three bye rounds (don’t know if that applies to the small bye this year) so having 19 premos play in one bye week is technically a waste.
Best of luck!
Thanks heaps
Is it worth using a boost to trade Ginbey for C.Jones?
-31 BE and projected 50k increase
TU: Worth a punt for D4
TD: Save trade and boost
TU: zeibell at F6 (dunks, taranto, cogs, gulden, sheezel)
TD; lloyd/sinclair at D3 (dawson/daicos/day/ buckley/mckenna/wilmot)
Freo Brayshaw at M5 (avg 90.2)
$295K ITB. 27 trades left. Do I luxury trade him out?
cheers
T/U Heeney
T/D Butters
Heeney $100k discount
Butters still a breakout candidate and m/f
Both with money to make I think
can’t afford anyone more expensive
any comments on either appreciated
My other option is keep Cowan on field this week
So I lose the points difference between him and Butters/Heeney
If Cowan gets dropped I would have to make the trade or cop a donut
Then next week I can upgrade to anybody with another trade
Better duo to field?
T/U: Ridley and Butters
T/D: Touk and Phillipou
Bloody hell.
Mackenzie > Roberts
Ginbey > Williams (via Sheezel DPP)
Davey > Cogs
Holding T Green on the bench. Let’s hope Cowan plays.
Ashcroft, Ginbey and Mackenzie for:
TU: Williams, Roberts & Touk + $32, 000
TD: Williams, Roberts & Dawson + $3,000
TU would give me more options for one up, one down in coming weeks, to target fallen premos, and Miller has North, Tiges and the Weagles in the next 5 rounds.
TD…. It’s Dawson. He has Hawks then three of the next 5 at AO.
Looking for an upgrade target after trading out the rookies with high BEs.
TU – Cogs + $42K
TD – Noah Anderson (with a favourable draw coming up)
Who to bring in;
Tu; Touk & C.Wagner
Td; Sinclair & Roberts
I feel like roberts could easily become the sub again? Don’t have enough to afford touk & roberts at the moment.
Brought in Duncan and scored 34
TU: trade him for zeibell
TD: keep him save a trade, just had a bad game
Trading out Ginbey and Mackenzie, do I use a boost and trade out Hayden Young too?
TU: 2 trades – Sinclair and Roberts in
TD: 3 trades – Sinclair, Cogs and Roberts in
Thoughts..
Ginbey to Daicos OR
Ashcroft to Miller?
Mackenzie out for
TU: ROBERTS
TD: WILLIAMS
TU: Pay up for Stuart before he gets away
TD: get Cogs for 120k less and maintain value of a trade
TU: McKenzie/Ginbey for Roberts/Ziebell
TD: McKenzie/Ginbey/Baker for Roberts/Johnson/Parish
Cheers!
Hi all,
With the suspensions on Caminiti, I’m considering boosting for the first time with these trades.
OUT: Ginbey, Caminiti + Mackenzie
IN: Seamus Mitchell, Matt Roberts + Jack Ziebell
Leaves me with 120k in cash with Mitchell + Roberts on the bench. Might change this thought process if any rookies are named to debut, but gives me Dawson, Daicos, Stewart and Ziebell in my defence. Also allows me to eventually flip Kade Chandler + Judd McVee in my midfield and fwd line to premos.
T/U: Good trades
T/D: You’re dumb, don’t do that
TU: Simple Mackenzie to roberts downgrade
TD: use a boost to go Mackenzie, Ginbey, baker > Roberts, Johnson, Sinclair/Cogs
Thoughts on these changes?
OUT: Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker
IN: Dawson, Roberts, Cincotta (If selected)
If Cincotta not selected, Chandler out instead of Baker and Wagner / Warner instead of Cincotta.
Wiil leave 27 trades and 3 boosts.
TU;Do it
TD; Don’t
Thanks !
Huge amount of people down-voting anything related to bringing C.Jones in.
Any reasons for this??
Low BE of -31 and scores of 93 & 116, genuinely interested in why so many people are staying away. Am quite tempted myself.
Can anyone elaborate?
Im a big crows fan and he honestly has never shown the potential other than in flashes for a pick 9.
However, saying that Im jumping on board he has cleaned up his ball use significantly, tackling harder & god he honestly is fighting for his contract. (contract yr)
Will make more cash than any of the rookies atm & the good ones have only played one week. IMO go for it!
What’s the plan though? 300k player at this stage of the season is just whack.
Early upgrades, rookie refreshing.
I’m not a fan at all but even if I was now is the time to net premiums, not take flyers on never before consistent or SC relevant dice rolls.
Admire the unique thinking and guts though. Goodluck, boys.
Understand your point but what is going to net you more money & good score over the next 4 weeks.
Would you rather Roberts who may get dropped/subbed with any in’s
Or a bloke who has shown a high ceiling in the form of his life & potential to make you the same $ as the rookie whilst also being playable? (-31 BE, with scores of 80 makes your 100k in 3 weeks and easy upgrade to prem)
It’s a risk I agree but no more than a flyer on Roberts (if it was next week with Williams and S.Mitch on the bubble than I probably wouldnt)
An average of 85 which seems a reasonable baseline will see him make $129k by the Crows bye, which isn’t the worst cash gen. You would need some more spike scores to really get the cash gen pumping.
Ok thoughts-
Ginbey – Bowes – McKenzie out
Butters- Daniher-Roberts in
Thoughts?
Why is no one talking about de goey?
Finally getting the midfield minutes and breaking out like people have been waiting for for 3-4 years and now no one is touching him.. do people not think he will keep it up?
And he is only 511k.
He was last minute out last week-you miss that?
That was due to illness… could happen to anyone so How does that make him any less relevant going forward?
I’m a Collingwood supporter but owning him would worry me – I feel he’s always a risk of another brain fade at any moment and suspended.
TU: parish . $557k
TD: de goey . $511k
Looking for value this week to get sic, cogs, day or Sinclair next week i Could afford touk this week but then miss out on the blokes next week as touk bleeds all my cash
I like Butters getting back to the firm he had last year before he copped that injury
Yep, im in the same position. Going to pass on Touk and move another premo into the back line next week.
TU: Touk
v
TD: Stewart
sorry if been asked before but anyone got a read on Dylan Williams job security?
TU Safe for a few weeks of lovely price rises
TD Danger danger danger!
Is this too crazy?
OUT-Ginbey, mackenzie, Tom Green
IN – Roberts, Butters, De Goey
T/U go for it
T/D don’t do it
Green is ok for a M7 or 8
TU: lloyd
TD: Sinclair
Is it worth trading:
Green -> Touk
I plan on Zig’ing when everyone zag’ing with none of the rookies doing it for me
OUT: Ginbey, Chandler, Cmack
TU: Chayce Jones, Ziebell, Cincotta (limited $)
TD: Jones, Hopper, Roberts
My logic is Jones/Hopper/Ziebell will make just as much money as these poor rookies whilst giving me much better on-field scores and zieball/hopper may even be keepers.
TU Sinclair
TD Lloyd
TU Sinclair+ Cogs
TD Lloyd + Butters
T/U – 3 trades for Bont this week @ 611k with the intention of 2 trades (Ridley + rookie) into Touk next week (risking that he may blow out to 650k if he destroys North despite a BE of 112).
T/D – 3 trades for Touk this week and aim for cheaper premos in the coming weeks.
Coniglio t/u
Sinclair t/d
Got the position flexibility and the funds to get either one (although Sinclair would leave the kitty pretty empty).
Cheers!
Hi Guys,
TU Degoey
TD Ziebel
Thanks
Hi again,
Have Mitch Duncan who gat 34 and will lose 34K
Could trade to Zeibel or upgrade to Dawson…
TU trade
TD hold he will come good
How/why do you have Duncan…
Is it time to pull the pin on Witts and jump onboard the Tingles train!??
Which one to go early on?
T/U- S.Mitchell
T/D- C.Wagner
Mitchell looked unreal, however I want to see if he gets named with Day back in too.
If so im all on Mitchell
Dawson, Daicos, H Andrews, Ginbey, McKenna, Wilmot (Cowan, Constable)
Oliver, Laird, LDU, Pendles, Ashcroft, Hollands, Mackenzie, Green (Baker, Chesser, Phillipou)
English, Marshal (Madden)
Dunkley, Sheezel, Taranto, Rozee, Ziebel, Chandler (Davey, Van Roo)
TU Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker —> Roberts, Mitchell, Neale (leaves a few bench doughnuts but gets an uber-premo)
TD Not worth the 3 trades and leaves the team with little cover if Roberts and Mitchell get dumped
TU: Touk
v
TD: Dawson
T/U – Settefield & Mackenzie to Roberts & Laird
T/D – Mackenzie & Ginbey to Roberts & Cogs
Already doing 2 trades this week:
1. Bazlenka > Laird
2. Mackenzie > Roberts
TU: Just these 2 trades
TD: Boost to also trade Ginbey > Williams (cash gen)
Is this worth wasting a boost on?
T.u Lloyd
Td Wikie
Same as above
T/u – Lloyd
T/d – Wilkie
The factors of having no money for upgrades, Saads non specific injury timeframe, and his high B/E, is enticing me to do 3 trades again this week.
Saad, Ginbey, MacKenzie & $21k ITB >> Dawson, M. Roberts, D. Williams & $250k ITB
Takes me from 28 trades down to 25 trades.
Gives me premo structure of 4,5,2,4 but that includes Sheezel, Setterfield, Hopper, Grundy, Rozee & Gulden.
T/U – Looks good, Dawson is a gun.
T/D – Saad is going to be top 6 DEF average, trade out Setters instead.
Saad is injured
For those of us who traded in Grundy l hope Melbourne stick to their word of being conservative with him and wait for a couple more weeks. Fingers crossed
TU: Baker to Cogs – keep Ginbey.
TD: Baker to Roberts, Ginbey to Touk.
Could make an extra trade to get in Dylan Williams, but not gonna use a boost for the sake of it, don’t need the cash.
Who to bring in this week…
T/u Sinclair
T/d Gulden
Do I use second boost for the season, and go
Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker -> Lloyd/Sinclair, Roberts, Williams
Who is more of a priority?
Lloyd/Sinclair (my backline is starving a bit)
OR
Cogs
TU: Sinclair
TD: De goey
Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker > Sinclair, Roberts, Johnson
T/U – Yes
T/D – No
I’ve currently got will day and Tom green
TU: hold green
Or
TD: Turn green into Dawson or Oliver
Hi Guys
Thoughts on trades?
Miller or Dawson?
Option 1
Out: Merrett – Gimbey – Chandler
In: Miller / Dawson – D. Williams – Ziebell
Ideally id like to keep Merrett but have a must win league game i cant risk it.
(Still cant believe he got a week for that tackle, one of the fairest blokes in the game)
Currently my Premos in the back are (almost all 4 premos :))
daicos – Ryan – Ridley – Llyod
Mid: Laird, Bont, Oliver,
Fwd: Sheezel, Gulden, Dunkley, Rozee
TU: Sinclair
TD: Lloyd
Will be using a boost I think this week, to get a premium in. Mackenzie & Ginbey at this stage, plus one of these two (even though they still have money to make)
TU : Chandler – AV 73 BE 47 & maybe getting tired?
TD : L Jones – AV 56, BE 31 and coming off a 88 in R5.
Otherwise might just do Mackenzie & Ginbey to Roberts & Williams and bank the cash for next week.
Currently running with 3 rookies onfield in my backline, plus L Jones, Daicos & Sicily.
My midfield (when Green is back from suspension) has 2 onfield rookies.
I’m bringing in a premium this week –
TU : T Stewart – my backline needs help but he’s projected to cost less next week, and I can’t afford Dawson without doing something crazy
TD : T Miller – probably at the lowest he’ll be for awhile. And R13 bye is nice.
Sinclair and bank some $$$?
Fixes the backline.
Which fallen premo?
TU: A. Brayshaw (Freo)
TD: Sinclair
Still so hurt that I missed the late Witts out a couple weeks ago (for a donut) and could’ve pivoted to English. Then didn’t listen to the thumbs last week and brought Gulden in instead of the Witts pivot! Time to type some crazy options to cope!
TU: Witts, JHF, Mackenzie -> English, Sinclair, Cincotta/Drury
TD: Tom Green, Witts, Mackenzie -> Touk, English, Williams/Roberts
Comment: Something reasonable
TU: Don’t boost, hold Ginbey, bank some cash for uber-premos with downgrades
TD: Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker -> Sinclair, Roberts, Williams
TU – Mckenna to Stewart + (100k for possibly Grundy to English or help with next upgrade next week)
TD – Cowan to Stewart. No extra money
TU: Worpel > Oliver
Or
TD: Callaghan > Touk or brayshaw
Touk definitely
Not Brayshaw, definitely Touk
TU : OUT – Mackenzie, IN – T Miller
or
TD : OUT – L Jones, IN – Dawson
I’m looking to use my first boost this week…
Option A – TU
Out: Ginbey, Caminiti, Mackenzie
Ins: Roberts, Williams, Touk
Option A wipes out my bank.
Option B – TD
Out: Caminiti, Mackenzie, Green
In: Roberts, Van Rooyen, Miller
Option B leaves me with $187k in the kitty for future upgrades
Cheers legends!
Yeo , ginbey, baker to laird Mitchell, roberts
Or wait a week and get Oliver instead?
TU out ginbey, Tom green, Ashcroft
In Taranto, roberts, Stewart/ Touk miller + 9k
TD out Ginbey, baker, Mackenzie
In Marty Johnson, roberts, Stewart/ Touk miller + 83k
T/U Williams
T/D S.Mitchell a week early
Mackenzie > Roberts
Baker > Johnson
Ginbey > Sinclair
Thoughts?
Who to bring in as a premo this week:
TU: Parish
TD: Sinclair
Comment Coniglio
Coniglio
TU Stewart or
TD Touk
Could swans tag Stewart this week ( Ryan fox)
TU – Bont
TD – Touk
Robbie fox sorry
Like a lot of others I need some CG and Roberts appears to be the most popular trade in target. If he doubles his 2nd highest score for the season and scores 54 against cats this week he’ll increase by about 34k if he matches his 2nd highest score he’ll increase by about 22k. If he gets back to back 60 v. cats and giants he’ll increase by about 80k over next 2 weeks.
His TOG this year-12%, 26%, 20%, DNP, 70%
Yeah the 1st 3 games he was sub and if not for injuries he may have been sub again last week. Pretty sure that without injuries he and cWarner will share the sub vest. Personally I want to see how Roberts goes against a good team before I risk a trade on him he might get smashed by the cats at Geelong and spit out another 4 instead of 60. Keep in mind Longmires idiosyncrasies and recall the great migration to Gulden after a single good game early this year
If williams (v. Eagles) matches his worst score he will increase by about 44k, if he scores his 2 game average (scored v. swans & dogs) he’ll increase by about 46k. If he maintains his 57 ave against eagles & saints he will increase by about 80k over next 2 weeks.
His TOG 75%, 78%
Williams has a very high K:HB ratio and against the eagles he could easily double his previous high.
My season is cooked already, I’m 102,000 positions lower than I was this time last year so I will go against the mob and get Williams.
Noah long > Setterfeild
TU: Yes
Or
TD: Too late on Setterfeild
TU: Sinclair
TD: Darcy Parish
TU: de goey . 511k & 110 avg
TD: cogs . 485k & 96 avg
Pies are firing, he may get DPP at some stage (don’t quote me). Fire up De Goey!!
There’s still some doubt on De Goey for this weekend (had a very light training session since he’s still suffering from gastro) so keep an eye out
Thanks for the heads up
The extra days between games should help him though, probably why they haven’t said too much on it
Pahs have shot their bolt early, long cold winter ahead hugging the March trophy, avoid De Goseph
Ginbey & Mackenzie -> Anderson & Wagner???
Ginbey, Mackenzie and Chandler to Neale, Williams and Roberts T.U OR just Davey and Mackenzie to Williams and Roberts for cash gen T.D
Hey team,
Not sure what to do about b.dale…..
Should I trade him in? Haven’t watched much of dog TV, but he seems like he isn’t setting the world alight this year…..
Move him on?
Witt’s possibly out again
Tu: trade
Td; hold
TU: Guldin
TD: Cogs
So confused on what to do. Don’t have Dawson and or English. Ranked 2.4K (1%) and with below trades left with 25
Mackenzie, Grundy, T Green to Williams, English, Dawson
TU – go for gold
TD – dumb, stick to leagues
Ginbey, Long and McKenzie
– > Neale, Roberts, Mitchell
TU: Yes
TD: No
With Gawn back, is this the week to go Grundy to English?
Hey Mark I’m in the same boat. I’m giving it an extra week as hoping Grundy gets the bulk of the ruck work with ax spending more time fwd.
TU: Neale
TD: Miller
With Long out, do I boost & downgrade to Williams?
TU: Boost & trade
TD: Hold Long, leave Williams
If Cincotta gets named in the final squad, is it worth going him over Williams so I can generate the funds to pickup Miller?
TU: Ginbey, Mackenzie, Chandler > Miller, Roberts, Cincotta
TD: Ginbey, Mackenzie, Baker > Sinclair, Roberts, Williams
Williams has been dropped.
TU: Parish
Or
TD: Crouch
Or
TU: Mason wood
Hi everyone,
Who has the better job security ???
TU Johnson in starting Freo line up
TD Roberts on Sydney bench ??/
Who to pick ??? Thanks
TU – De goey
TD – Noah Anderson
DEF – Dawson, Daicos, Stewart, Ginbey, McKenna, Wilmot (Cowan, Constable)
MID – Oliver, Macrae, Merrett, Green, Hopper, Ashcroft, Mackenzie. Phillips (Baker, Davey, Rowston)
RUC – English, Marshall (Madden)
FWD – Dunkley, Taranto, Coniglio, Ziebell, Sheezel, Phillipou (Greene, Caminiti)
27 trades left/ $24k remaning
Merrett, Green and Caminiti suspended, with Mackenzie and Ginbey around the financial peak.
Not sure what should do here. Don’t want to get rid of Merrett or Green, plus I feel getting rid of MacKenzie and Ginbey is a bit rushed
I’m not trading in Roberts, because he’s been the sub three times this years, who’s to say he won’t be made the sub again this week regardless of his decent score, not risking it. And now Dylan Williams has been omitted, and Seamus Mitchell is on the extended bench with Maginness and Scrimshaw to come back in for the Hawks.
Roberts named in the 22, won’t be the sub this week.
Fair enough. I may have been forced the hand to do that anyway with basically no other trade choices anywhere
THIS WEEK ONLY. Considering BE and price
TU Laird
TD Sinclair
Why would people be suggesting Laird over Sinclair? Just ridiculous advice. Laird could fall again this week and will be sub $600k. Sinclair every day of the week. Just braindead advice those giving the TU
Sinclair not even close to being a top 6 defender based on current form. Might be better this week with Steele back though.
100% Laird, vc/c every week…
is cogs worth it? Still think he’ll be a top 6 forward by the end of the season
Tu – do it
Tf – steer clear
Tu: cogs
Td: parish
Yay or nay:
Mackenzie>Roberts
Setters>Touk
Roberts or Williams for Mackenzie?
TU – BUTTERS
TD – SINCLAIR
Thoughts
Ginbey > Robert’s Via DPP
Baker > Johnson
Long > J Lloyd Via DPP
Is it worth the 2 downgrades just for one upgrade?
T/U yes
T/D No
Does bytel need to be traded? Made $0 but He’s dead… sub every week and 69BE now
TU: trade bytel – Johnson
TU: trade Mackenzie- Johnson.
Trading out which one ?
TU – Long
TD – Baker
TU: Serong
TD: Parish
T/U: Johnson
T/D: Roberts
OR
Hold Chandler for another week as both above players will still be worth picking up next week
Jed McEntee worth a look?
TU
Makenzie to Roberts
Oscars Baker to Johnson
Gibney to Sinclair
TD
Makenzie to Roberts
Hold trades for better rookies
TU: Gulden
Or
TD: Degoey
Or
TU: Cogs
TU Ashcroft, McDonald out
TD Stewart, roberts in
TU do it, saves on using a boost
TD don’t do it, trading Ashcroft who has still more cash to make
TU Ashcroft, Mackenzie out
TD Stewart, roberts in
TU do it, saves on using a boost
TD don’t do it, trading Ashcroft who has still more cash to make
TU : Noah long > Parish +5k ( Don’t think he is a top 10 mid)
Or
TD: Noah long > Cogs or gulden + 77k for upgrades next week
TU: Parish
Or
TD: Noah Anderson
TU out Mackenzie, Long, Camma
TD in Touk, S Mitchell, Roberts
Pros, upgrading premo in Touk, getting rid of injured rookies
Cons, using a trade boost, Long and Camaniti can still make money
I think I’m just gonna do these two trades
Caminiti – Roberts
Mackenzie – Johnson
I don’t think I should off Ginbey just yet. I think he’s more likely to reach his BE for one. Secondly I don’t feel safe wasting my third boost trade to downgrade him, because I simple don’t have enough to upgrade him to a proper premo. The best I could do is either Baker or Lloyd, but I don’t think I can call them premos yet. They’ve had a good start but we’re only 5 rounds in.
What do you guys think?
TU: Use boost trade to do Ginbey > Baker or Lloyd
TD: Save the trade, need the boosts for the bye rounds
Hey everyone!
Trying to get Dawson in my team. This is the trade I’m looking at. Leaves me with 26 trades/3 boosts.
Mackenzie, Ginbey, Gulden -> Johnson, Roberts, Dawson
I understand Gulden doesn’t have to go but I’m losing so many points to not having Dawson.
TU: Do it!
TD: Double downgrade is enough
Thanks!
Julian
TU: Ginbey > Sinclair
TD: Gulden > Dawson