227 thoughts on “Trade Talk – Round 8”

  1. Time for Oliver to go. He’s taking up a midfield spot, he’s not making money, and he’s not premium scoring. No benefit to him.

    2
    22
    Reply
    • I’d focus on getting your poor scoring rookies off of the field first before sideways trading Oliver. He’s definitely not at the level we expect from him but scores of 98/91/86/98/80 in his last 5 isn’t *awful*. Not ideal but surely there’s bigger fish to fry at the moment.

      40
      2
      Reply
        • Not when his next game od against West Coast. You need to also take into account the fixture as well. I’d at least hold on to him for one more week and then trade him if he still underperforms.

          8
          0
          Reply
            • He’s averaging 96.6 and holding his value, he’s not exactly burning a hole in anyone’s pocket. Definitely a trade at some point, just depends on where your teams at and who you have on field, especially with a good fixture next week. Id say he’s way down on the priorities, but it’s not impossible that you don’t have anything better to do.

              10
              0
              Reply
  2. Playing for overall, currently sitting in the top 1k

    Not having Gawn is killing me now, however the only avenue is through TDK. It helps my bye structure and it also doesn’t stall my upgrades. Not to mention, Max runs into the eagles next weekend. As a TDK owner, there is always going to be that Pitonett factor lingering in the background too, he will surely come into the side eventually. Yes I know TDK scored very well this week, however I fully expect Xerri & Gawn to be R1&R2 (Not sure what order).

    TDK > Gawn

    Tu or Td

    Thoughts appreciated, cheers in advance!

    6
    47
    Reply
    • The way I’d look at it is, do you think the difference in scoring between TDK and Gawn will be larger than upgrading a rookie to a premo? For example, if you think Davidson/Lindsay/insert rookie you have on field will score about 70 and Gawn about 130 over the next few rounds, that’s a total of 200. But if you think TDK will go about 110, and you upgrade that rookie to a premo who goes at about 100, that’s a total of 210 between the two (these numbers are just examples, you plug whatever you expect each player to average in).

      So it’s basically up to how big do you think Gawn will go/how much cash you have to invest to upgrade a rookie vs upgrading TDK to Gawn. For me personally, I would focus on upgrading on field rookies to premos before going sideways, but I’m also not in the top 1k (top 6k as of round 6), so take that with a grain of salt.

      If Pitto is ever named alongside TDK then that’s an entirely different story…

      11
      0
      Reply
    • Absolutely not.

      Simply not how you play this game.

      The outright, even tepid, approvals of TDK -> Gawn are stunning me.

      If Pitto was back and TDK was eating ass, fine. He just went 135.

      I don’t see how not owning Maxxy could possibly be “killing” you. They’re level on total points.

      Great job on ranking. Keep improving your team in terms of keepers and points OF.

      15
      1
      Reply
      • It’s not Gawn specifically that’s killing you it’s the 3 ruck set up that people are going with that’s the key to success this season as well as starting with brayshaw and having Whitfield and Sinclair (who’s dropped a few poor ones by his standard ) that’s where the top teams are making their points whilst other teams have weaker def premiums like Holmes etc and serong in the mids

        7
        1
        Reply
  3. Anyone have any thoughts on Kennedy, from bulldogs, he has a great heatmap playing midfield getting 20+ touches and hopefully kicking at least a goal a game
    I think he’ll be a cheap forward premium at the moment when I already have Rankine, macrae and Daniel.

    7
    2
    Reply
  4. Looking for value this week, so going to try to do a double upgrade with roughly 200k sitting in the bank.

    Rookie number 1 (probably Davidson) -> Warner
    Rookie number 2 (probably Prior) -> Freijah

    Warner looks to be back to his best, cheap as, and forward DPP makes him super valuable IMO

    Freijah also looks a million times better with Bont back and at about 400k and DEF DPP is a steal if this form keeps up.

    May have to make a change of plans as Cerra appeared to have a groin niggle + he might cop some attention from the MRO for a high hit. Cross that bridge when we come to it though.

    5
    2
    Reply
      • Might just be a cramp, with his history I was just a bit nervous, that’s all.

        Speaking of history, considering some of the baffling decisions made by the MRO recently it should be a fine and that’s it, but it wouldn’t shock me if they give him weeks for absolutely no reason. A week off is a hold though, I agree.

        1
        0
        Reply
    • Watching the Sydney game warner was looking amazing, like you said, at his best, i wouldn’t be judging off that one game, look for someone alot more reliable. This is just my opinion feel free to do what ever you like but yea, with bong back freijha looks amazing, shame I traded him 3 weeks ago.

      8
      0
      Reply
      • If he was a MID only I wouldn’t be going for Chad just yet, but as a forward his margin for error is much larger, only needs to average 95+ from here on out to finish as a top forward, anything else is a massive bonus. His last two years he’s averaged 100+ and I think he can get there again.

        Might also look at Rozee or Kennedy, hard to tell before Supercoach opens and I know exactly how much money I’m working with.

        2
        0
        Reply
        • Yea, I’m looking at Kennedy this week. He has been looking good. Already got rozee and yea I’ll see how warner goes next week before getting him

          2
          0
          Reply
    • I really like this, I don’t feel like I have the trade bank to take too many risks so warner off one game might still be too much of a risk to fill my last forward slot. But freijah at the price looks a solid bet with relatively low risk if I have to sideways him later. Considering him and rozee I think this week.

      2
      0
      Reply
    • UPDATE: I’m 5k short from doing the above, kill me lmao. Probably just going Davidson to Freijah and leaving it at that, getting Chad in would require sideways trading which at that point isn’t worth it anymore.

      1
      5
      Reply
  5. Kennedy looks to have had a more consistent scoring record than trac, and petracca has only tonned once against weak opposition, he’s also slightly more expensive.

    I like Trac but it just seems like a better more reliable and cheaper option at the moment, with a lower breakeven if I have to sideways for some reason.

    Tu- Kennedy

    Td- Petracca

    9
    19
    Reply
    • Need to see what they do with Jackson coming back.

      McDonald was good but I don’t see them dropping Amiss or Darcy. 2 goals but only 9 touches, so not super critical to their scoring chain.

      If he stays in the 22, sure. But definitely need to see sheets.

      2
      0
      Reply
      • Yeah fair enough, the only other rookie option I have is Brock probably in defence. Any chance he gets named again in the near future, could take the extra 20k if they both have bad js.

        0
        0
        Reply
  6. Worth going early on Hustwaite if it helps with an upgrade?

    Trying to avoid a Clay Hall type who has 1-2 prices then dropped. But literally no cheap bubble rookies available this week

    6
    7
    Reply
  7. Thoughts on Jordan Dawson….

    I’m honestly sick of commentators mostly saying how he is such a beautiful kick of the footy and one of the best in the comp.

    I’ve watched him pretty closely the last 3 weeks and have noticed his decision making is really poor, he’s to slow to get rid of the ball and he butches it a lot. With disposal efficiency of 38,52 and 42 in the last 3, in which kicking would be a lot worse is he a trade to Rozee which i can facilitate??

    Could be ranting a little bit and hate trading premiums, but with his kicking I really can’t see him being a top 10 mid.

    Cheers for reading legends x

    0
    7
    Reply
  8. TU: this week lalor, Lashcroft + Dale > L.neale, trac + boyd
    then next week go kayo + maric > sinclair + rookie

    TD: lalor + Ashcroft > trac + boyd
    next week maric, Reid + Oliver > sheezel (or another fallen premo) + Sinclair + rookie (hustwhaite?)

    worried with sheezel my team becomes very rd12 bye heavy

    1
    4
    Reply
  9. Murphy Reid has to go, but which rookie should also go with him:

    TU – L Ashcroft

    TD – Davidson

    Since they have similar scoring profiles and BEs I’m leaning towards Ashcroft to cash in on his higher price

    0
    25
    Reply
  10. I know the golden rule is to not trade your premo’s, but far out Stewart is not looking like a top 6-8 DEF. Not quite ready to upgrade my rookies yet who are still rising in price and wanting just some reliable points in my backline. I know people are talking bad about Oliver, but at least he’s not off back to back 60’s.

    Tu – trade to someone like Clark or comment a better option (have Whitfield, sheezel and Roberts)

    Td – gotta stick with him

    16
    16
    Reply
      • Yeah I’d normally hold, but he’s dropping like 20-30k probably and doesn’t look great. There’s always a chance he works his way back into the season and you regret wasting the trade later so I’d be very sure there’s no other trade priorities though.

        3
        0
        Reply
    • I’m in the same boat. He’s clearly not 100% so I’m leaning towards trading him this week as it sounds like he’ll be carrying his injury all season which will diminish his scoring, plus clubs again are putting plenty of attention into him

      1
      0
      Reply
    • I traded him in last year after the byes because he was ‘discounted’.
      I was in 44th position at the time – worst decision I made all year.
      So, yes, trade him!

      1
      0
      Reply
  11. Current state of affairs
    DEF – Whitfield, Sheezel, Clark, Dale, Bice, Reid (Carrol, Leak)
    MID – Daicos, Zerret, Serong, Neale, Cerra, Oliver, Lindsay, Moraes (Hall, Gross, Camporeale)
    RUCK – Xerri, De Koning (Boyd)
    FWD – Horne-Francis, Smith, Macrae, Daniel, Powell-Pepper, Davidson (Cleary, Stone)
    FLEX – Freijah
    Definitely going Hall -> Hustwaite, just need a more reliable on field rookie and he seems to be out of the west coast side
    For the second trade, looking at either;
    TU: Dale -> Sinclair/NAS (Dale clearly not looking like a keeper atp, however could bounce back)
    TD: Davidson -> Freijah
    Comment: Just leave it at one trade for the week

    1
    12
    Reply
      • Dale has almost lost all his value. Will surely have a spike score coming and will get back to $500k. Thats when you sell around the byes (thats my plan anyway). Worst case if he becomes Mills or even Holmes or Zorko who are dropping in value

        1
        0
        Reply
  12. I have two major problems:

    1. My midfield stinks worse than last week’s garbage – top score last weekend was Newcombe with an even 100

    2. I can not pick a captain to save my life

    So, righting wrongs from last week:

    LAshcroft and AReid out
    Bont and Sims in

    Yes, for about the tenth year in a row I’m overpaying for Bont but I think it’s justified. I was at Manuka on Saturday night and he just cruised around and scored 128. It’s quite ridiculous to watch at times and I feel like the overage on price is worth it for the safe C every week. Plus, I have lots of ground to make up and he’s still relatively PODish.

    7
    1
    Reply
  13. Still trying to work out trade plans..

    This week:
    Prior > O.McDonald (if he holds his spot)
    Tsatas > Hustwaite
    C.Hall > Petracca

    Next week:
    Reid > Buslinger
    Levi > Sinclair

    Is it worth using a boost this week to bring in Trac?

    Tu or Td

    6
    0
    Reply
  14. In two minds now that my previous plan has been foiled. I’m about to confess something truly barbaric, so hopefully you’ll all still treat me with kindness after hearing what I have to say…

    **In nearly 10 years of playing supercoach, I’ve never owned Marcus Bontempelli**

    I know! I know! Put me in the stocks, throw vegetables at me, I deserve it! But he’s always just been far too expensive and I can never justify spending that much money on a player to start the season, then all of a sudden he’s 700k and I can never get him in.

    After seeing him in second gear and then subbed off and STILL nearly score 130 on the weekend, that might have to change, especially with how weak my midfield is currently.

    So what do I do? Original plan of looking for value or go all in on Bont?

    T/U: Davidson -> OMac/other Rookie, Ashcroft -> Bont, 50k in the bank

    T/D: Davidson -> Freijah, 80k ITB

    13
    4
    Reply
    • Such a tough call. Couldn’t blame anyone for targeting bont with how he’s looking, but at the same time freijah seems like the traditionally better play. Id say getting greedy has tended to hurt me in the past so I’d do the disciplined play of not buying anyone at peak price but by doing that bont probably averages 150 for the rest of the season.

      2
      0
      Reply
      • The disciplined play of not buying anyone at peak price is exactly why I’ve never owned Bont! I’m just in two minds, because it wouldn’t shock me if this was his *lowest* price all year.

        That being said I’ll make all these moves to trade him in and he’ll score 70 this week. More research is definitely required…

        2
        0
        Reply
  15. Need to boost my mids as they are my weak link. Preferably someone under $600k
    TU Serong
    TD Dunkley
    Comment if anyone else is preferred I might’ve missed. Have Neale, Kelly, Oliver and Callaghan

    6
    7
    Reply
  16. Which combination?
    Z.Guthrie+S.Davidson+M.Reid out for:
    TU: C.Rozee+J.Friejah+H.Hustwaite
    TD: Bont+Hustwaite+Busslinger
    Thanks

    12
    11
    Reply
    • If you’re planning on a Ruck in flex long term it’s probably worth it Bo IMO. Check which cheap R/F has the most Sunday games though for loophole purposes.

      0
      0
      Reply
  17. If I have got the cash too, which I do, is it worth upgrading Oliver to bont, I know the dee’s are playing west coast but is it worth waiting that week to get bont?
    TU, Oliver to bont
    TD, get my rookies right

    0
    17
    Reply
    • Playing the role that Luke Jackson would play so Treacy doesn’t have to be the 2nd ruck, so will only be good until he’s back.

      4
      0
      Reply
  18. Initial plan was Petracca this week, but with SPP’s current form pretty happy with my F6. So which is the better trade:

    TU: Prior to a premo Def.
    TD: Davidson to a premo Mid.

    0
    17
    Reply
    • Mid it is then! With my budget I’m looking at Dunks or one of the GC mids. Already have Neale, generally prefer not 2 mids from the same team.

      TU: Touk (yet to go below 100, low ceiling)
      TD: Rowell (bigger ceiling but can throw in a stinker or 2)

      2
      0
      Reply
  19. Hall & Tsatas > Hustwaite & Warner (don’t have enough cash for Trac, Hustwaite will be bench cover in MID)

    OR

    Tsatas & Lalor > Hustwaite & Newcombe

    Would normally try and fix the rookies but there are none on the bubble this week.

    2
    0
    Reply
  20. Tu: freijah + hustwaite
    Td: rankine/trac + Omac

    And if td, which one?

    First option obviously costs less and will leave me with easily enough cash for Zorko/other premo next week, but not sure if option 2 will

    2
    1
    Reply
  21. Simpkin to Rankine
    Carrol to Busslinger

    TU yes
    TD no

    Tempted to use a boost and trade Hastie who is rotting on my bench to McDonald? But I’d have to use a boost. I also don’t know what to do with M. Reid.

    0
    10
    Reply
    • Update is it better to trade out M Reid for Hust

      Promote x Lindsay to the field and trade out Davidson for Rankine and keep Simpkin?

      8
      0
      Reply
  22. Lots of trading going on at Rd8 are people looking ahead at the bye rounds or are you going to look at that later down the track.

    1
    0
    Reply
    • It’s probably time to start looking at them. just be mindful of bringing round 12 premiums in now, if you’ve already got a few

      2
      0
      Reply
  23. Is it viable to trade out Reid & Prior this week if it allows you to bring in someone like Petracca?

    Missing out on further price rises from culling those rookies early, however Petracca will only rise with them if that makes sense. A sub 500k Trac as a fwd seems great value.

    Tu or Td

    17
    0
    Reply
    • wouldn’t do petracca next week, take him now or never because he’s playing eagles this week and after that he won’t be worth it at his increased price.

      5
      0
      Reply
  24. HELP

    Trading out M. Reid and S. Davidson.
    Going to bring in H. Hustwaite and either Petracca or Chad Warner.

    Tu: Petracca
    Td: Chad

    Or comment if I should get rid of warner or of this is a stupid trade

    14
    8
    Reply
  25. Had another re jig
    My two options are

    L Ashcroft, E Hewett, M Reid out
    Bont, H Davis, H Hustwaite in

    Or

    Davidson, M Reid, M Carrol out
    Rankine, Busslinger, H Hustwaite in

    TUP first
    TD second

    3
    7
    Reply
    • Can you possibly save the boost and wait on doing Carroll to Hustwaite? There’s just no urgency for that without him on the bubble

      2
      1
      Reply
  26. Reckon I’m going to get a big fish now, but the question is, which one? Who we trust more?

    T/U: Bont

    T/D: Gawn (at Flex) + 50k-ish.

    Leaning Gawn due to slightly lower price, Bont coming back from injury, Gawn’s upcoming fixture, plus having 3 rucks during byes sounds tasty (especially with my current two rucks sharing a bye), although hard to look past Bont’s scoring power + form.

    8
    14
    Reply
    • Additionally, worth using a boost to go Maric to Freijah? Maric about to hit his ceiling price wise and Freijah I really, really like at his price, would only leave me with one boost left though which makes me incredibly nervous, but would only have 5 spots left to upgrade after that which I’m optimistic I can do with only 1 boost.

      T/U: Do it, last chance to get Freijah at a decent price.

      T/D: Too risky, need to save those boosts for when you REALLY need them.

      5
      5
      Reply
      • I have tried the idea of using my boosts all really early to get the best team, and it has worked as i am top 5k, thats just what i have done, there is nothing wrong with using boosts, they are there to be used, if u feel like it i would use it.

        4
        5
        Reply
  27. I need to create a bit of depth in my midfield as I had no benchwarmers playing last round.
    Out – Sanders and Knevitt
    In – Rozee and Freijah.
    Ideally I would have liked to keep Sanders and trade Davidson or even LAshcroft but didnt have enough $
    My midfield bench is now FOS, Boxhall and Gross (both must be close to plaything this week).

    6
    1
    Reply
  28. if you were to bring in a bargain premium before their price rises again who would you prioritise out of
    T/u Petracca
    T/d Neale

    1
    14
    Reply
  29. I dont think i will do any trades this week, no rookies really stand out and i have only got 5 rookies on field, projected 2380
    TU dont do any trades
    TD downgrade my rookies to bring chashflow

    16
    2
    Reply
  30. Lalor > Hustwaite
    Tsatas > Freijah

    Deficit ~15k from this trade. Leaves 28.5k ITB. Lalor price stalled and Frejiah -5 makes me think this is the right time although rd 12 doggies bye is main drawback. Also let’s me get rid of dead rookie in Tsatas

    TU: Yes
    TD: No

    4
    7
    Reply
    • If Jackson is back this week, OMac is gone.

      He is our third string back-up fwd / ruck behind Jacko and Voss. If you already have a number of dead rookies i would look elsewhere as he may give you one more game and then he will be out.

      3
      0
      Reply
    • Warner, easily. Kako has the lower BE and gets North this week.

      Could make a case for holding both, but if you have to trade then it’s Warner

      6
      0
      Reply
  31. Freijah started with 100’s the first two rounds so I brought him in and then he went 70, 50 & 50 odd, so I traded in out only for him to go 120 and 115 odd in the last two,

    That is the story of my season,

    You’re Welcome !

    21
    0
    Reply
  32. After doing Rankine for Davidson
    M Reid out for Hustwaite

    Is it worth using a boost to trade Simpkin for Trac?

    I’m considering not trading Carrol for Busslinger as with SOS out he might keep his spot

    8
    3
    Reply
  33. TU: 1 trade, M Reid to Petracca

    TD: 3 trades, M Reid, L Ashcroft, Maric out, Hustwaite, Petracca, Bont in

    2nd option leaves me with less cash in bank and going early on Maric, but obviously getting Bont is the benefit

    8
    7
    Reply
  34. wait has everyone already been trading out gross
    just waiting for him to play so he can get that cash generation but will he, should i bother holding?

    2
    0
    Reply
  35. Which trade is better

    TU Short and Ashcroft out for Daicos and Hustwaite

    Or TD Short and Moraes out for Petracca and Hustwaite

    Basically this is a Q of the immediate and pressing issue of getting Daicos or Petracca. Which one is the priority?. Thanks in advance

    11
    1
    Reply
  36. Need to do something as losing most weeks. I’m willing to risk trading in these 2 rookies as have good bench coverage with others

    OUT – Lash, Davidson & M Reid
    IN – Bont, Hustwaite & Tunstill

    TU : Go for it
    TD : Cool your jets, Bont can wait.

    0
    14
    Reply
  37. I’m holding would love to get Warner as a forward but don’t want to go early on huswaite as have pepper hall still making coin. A wise cow talker told me trades are gold don’t burn through them.

    1
    0
    Reply
    • Too late to be bringing Hewett in for mine. Already missed out on 100k in cash gen, would prefer going early on Hustwaite or even looking at a useful non playing dpp

      3
      0
      Reply
  38. Didn’t get Carroll last week due to Cowan risk and fixture times. JS has improved with SOS injured.

    TU: Pay up for Carroll this week
    TD: Wait for Busslinger next week if he’s on the bubble

    0
    7
    Reply
  39. M Reid and Davidson out for:

    TU: Rankine and Hustwaite
    TD: Rozee and Brock

    I know Brock isn’t playing but he lets me loophole between Stone and Z Reid plus gets me Rozee who I just couldn’t afford last week

    2
    0
    Reply
  40. Ranked 560 atm.

    DEF: Whitfield, Roberts, Dale, Bice, Reid, Stone (Carroll & Hastie).

    MID: Butters, Brayshaw, Naicos, Anderson, Rozee, Richards, Oliver, Cerra (Linsday, Hall, Gross).

    RUCK: Xerri & TDK (Boyd).

    FWD: JHF, Smith, Macrae, Daniel, L Ashcroft, M Hall (Reid & Cleary).

    Want to trade out Cerra (groin issue apparently) and L Ashcroft to bring in either Rankine, Trac, or Warner.

    My second trade cant be a premo as I can’t afford it. Really need to strengthen my back line, what are your thoughts on bringing in Bowey who will make me a bit of money and I can then upgrade in the future to Sinclair hopefully? Or should I just hold off on that trade and do a straight sway for Rankine & Cerra?

    1
    0
    Reply
  41. Ranked 560 atm.

    DEF: Whitfield, Roberts, Dale, Bice, Reid, Stone (Carroll & Hastie).

    MID: Butters, Brayshaw, Naicos, Anderson, Rozee, Richards, Oliver, Cerra (Linsday, Hall, Gross).

    RUCK: Xerri & TDK (Boyd).

    FWD: JHF, Smith, Macrae, Daniel, L Ashcroft, M Hall (Reid & Cleary).

    Want to trade out Cerra (groin issue apparently) and L Ashcroft to bring in either Rankine, Trac, or Warner.

    My second trade cant be a premo as I can’t afford it. Really need to strengthen my back line, what are your thoughts on bringing in Bowey who will make me a bit of money and I can then upgrade in the future to Sinclair hopefully? Or should I just hold off on that trade and do a straight sway for Rankine & Cerra?

    1
    0
    Reply
  42. I am currently running with Gawn and TDK with Tim English in flex. Thought Xerri would come down in price and English would return to 2023 form (probably got it wrong.)

    Would you:
    T/u – M.Reid and Levi to Petracca and OMac/Hustwaite.
    or use a boost:
    T/d – M.Reid, Levi, English to OMac/Hustwaite, Chad Warner and Xerri.

    0
    8
    Reply
    • i think Blues will appeal and hopefully he gets off.

      i was more concerned with him grabing his groin when he had a shot on goal in the last quarter and then went off for a bit and didn’t score any points after that, even though he came back on.

      He was going to be in my team until the byes. Carlton have a round 12 bye, so if he misses this week, he has 3 more games.

      His 81 will stay in his price calculation until the bye and limit any further cash generation. He has made all the cash he is going to.

      depending on news of his suspension or injury, i’m happy to move him on.

      4
      0
      Reply
    • Personal opinion is he has nearly made all the money he will make. He also won’t finish as a top 10 Mid so if you can get a gun I would trade

      6
      0
      Reply
  43. can any Bomber fans confirm that Tsatas was a late withdrawl from the VFL side on Sunday due to the quick turn-around for essendon’s game on Thursday, not because of injury.

    if that is the case it looks good for a tsatas return this week (hopefully not as sub)

    4
    0
    Reply
  44. I’ve gone with Lashcroft & Tsatas for Libba and Hustwaite with $73K in the bank.

    Libba hasn’t gone under 100 for the season (but will now I have traded him in!!!) and is only in 8% of teams.

    2
    0
    Reply
  45. In the SuperCoach app, the “Select Teams” button, which allows you to choose teams that you have drafted is now gone?
    It’s usually located near the top of the interface.

    1
    0
    Reply
    • I sent them a msg. Dream Team is the same. Only 1 draft league is visible. I guess they both made a change and it’s not a change for the better. SC and DT do similar things, change layouts etc. Can’t access our other draft leagues now. Classic is OK.
      Maybe it was the work experience kid
      Send them a msg too

      0
      0
      Reply
  46. Currently ranked 206 and playing for overall

    L.Ashcroft -> Hustwaite
    SPP -> Petracca

    Not a great matchup for SPP this week against the dogs in Ballarat, I doubt I would actually field him.

    Is it worth making these trades, I think Hustwaite is a genuine good player and should get minimum 2 price rises before Nash comes back. Best case he even holds his spot if he does enough.

    TU – Yes make trades will enable more points on field
    TD – Hold trades, still a bit of money to make for the 2 rooks especially SPP. Trac only rises 13k if he scores 100.

    1
    6
    Reply
  47. Projection 2350-5 rookies on field, all going to get 60+, the only rookie who might loose money is trainor.
    TU: trade trainor for that mcdonald rookie (jacksons coming in so low JS)
    TD: Trainor for hustawaite
    more suggestions below

    0
    1
    Reply
  48. TU –
    Z.Reid > O.Mac
    L.Ashcroft > Neale

    But O.Mac would be on field with shocking bench cover.

    TD –
    L,.Ashcroft > Warner

    0
    11
    Reply
  49. I am tempted to not trade this week but FOMO on daicos or petracca

    TU Short&Moraes >Petracca & Hustwaite
    TDShort&Ashcroft > Naicos&Hustwaite

    1
    5
    Reply
  50. Would you do FOS > Carroll this week?
    Obviously missed the boat for the big cash rise on Carrol last week, but with his JS prospects and cash gen looking ok for at least a few weeks, is it worth jumping on now given FOS isn’t generating anything worthwhile?

    TU: Yes
    TD: No

    0
    7
    Reply
  51. TU Davidson, LAshcroft > Macdonald, Freijah
    TD Davidson, LAshcroft > Macdonald, Rankine

    Thought Freijah would be worse with the inclusion of Bont but he looks even better, his breakeven is also lower than Rankine’s that’s why its a toss up for me

    leave other suggestions if there are other good looking players i’d rather Rankine than trac or warner as they have not been scoring that well until this point especially with trac facing tigers

    0
    1
    Reply
  52. Can potentially do Cerra, Lashcroft and SPP to Rozee, Petracca & have 206k to get whoever.

    The way I see it I’m gaining 2 keepers and giving up zero keepers. I’m more than happy to have Rozee in my final 6 defenders and same with Trac for forwards. Obviously Cerra may still miss this week and has a niggling groin injury from the weekend, and will be culled before his bye in 3-4 weeks anyway.

    keen to hear thoughts.

    TU – go for it
    TD – wait and reassess next week

    0
    2
    Reply

Leave a Reply to Murray Cancel reply