111 thoughts on “Rate My Team 3”

  1. DEF: H. Shaw, J. McVeigh, E. Mackenzie, B. Whitecross, M. Brown, A. Aliir (D. Viojo-Rainbow, M. Brown)
    MID: S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, R. Sloane, J. Selwood, T. Rockliff, T. Liberatore, D. Myers, J. Trengove (J. Gresham, D. Gore, B. Keays)
    RUC: S. Martin, S. Jacobs (T. West)
    FWD: B. Deledio, L. Montagna, L. Dahlhaus, B. Kennedy, S. Kerridge, C. Petracca (L. Sumner, A. McDonald-Tipungwuti)
    CASH LEFT: $900

    I’ve got a very light backline which is a bit of a problem so I’m hoping there are a few rookies down there who put their hands up to play round 1.

    I’m thinking of taking Sloane out for Tom Mitchell as I’m unsure of how he’ll perform with danger gone. I would prefer to put Priddis in there but I don’t have the money for him.

    Any help would be appreciated

    0

    0
  2. Hey guys here is my latest attempt unsure about D4 cant decide between Rich with $8400 left and Aish and $168800 left thoughts please

    H.Shaw, J.McVeigh, E.Yeo, D4, C.Byrne, M.Hibberd (A.Aliir, R.Bonner)

    G.Ablett, T.Rockliff, T.Adams, O.Wines, T.Liberatore, J.Oโ€™meara, J.Anderson, J.Hopper (P.Ahern, N.Freeman, B.Keys)

    S.Martin, S.Jacobs (T.West)

    L.Dalhouse, J.Gunston, K.Tippett, C.Bird, S.Kerridge, C.Petracca (N.Kommer, M.Brown)

    0

    0
  3. Well, finally a first draft. All the rookies are up in the air, of course, and I am sure the preseason will change everything. But, still, I look forward to hearing how badly I messed this up. ๐Ÿ™‚

    Defenders
    1. McVeigh, J
    2. Yeo, E
    3. Williams, Z
    4. Walker, A
    5. Whitecross, B
    6. Doedee, T
    23. Hibberd, M
    24. Adamson, C

    Midfielders
    7. Ablett, G
    8. Beams, D
    9. Rockliff, T
    10. Crouch, M
    11. Liberatore, T
    12. Ah Chee, B
    13. O’Meara, J
    14. Myers, D
    25. Jansen, J
    26. Sumner, L
    27. Keays, B

    Rucks
    15. Goldstein, T
    16. Sandilands, A
    28. Chol, M

    Forwards
    17. Dahlhaus, L
    18. Zorko, D
    19. Steele, J
    20. Lennon, B
    21. de Boer, M
    22. Lyons, J
    29. Petracca, C
    30. Brown, M

    0

    0
  4. Defenders:
    Heath Shaw [GWS] ($607,800)
    Kade Kolodjashnij [GCS] ($482,200)
    Brodie Smith [ADE] [MID] ($415,500)
    James Aish [COL] [MID] ($275,700)
    Ciaran Byrne [CAR] ($123,900)
    Josh Wagner [MEL] ($121,900)
    Mitch Brown [ESS] [FWD] ($117,300)
    Marcus Adams [WBD] [FWD] ($117,300)

    Midfielders:
    Scott Pendlebury [COL] ($627,200)
    Gary Ablett [GCS] ($623,200)
    Josh P. Kennedy [SYD] ($594,800)
    Joel Selwood [GEE] ($565,500)
    Tom Rockliff [BRL] ($550,100)
    Tom Liberatore [WBD] ($357,300)
    Dean Gore [ADE] ($123,900)
    Nathan Freeman [STK] ($123,900)
    Anthony Morabito [FRE] ($123,900)
    David Cuningham [CAR] ($121,800)
    Ben Keays [BRL] ($117,300)

    Rucks:
    Todd Goldstein [NTH] ($695,100)
    Nic Naitanui [WCE] ($560,700)
    Cameron Loersch [GCS] [FWD] ($102,400)

    Forwards:
    Brett Deledio [RIC] ($608,800)
    Dustin Martin [RIC] [MID] ($569,300)
    Luke Dahlhaus [WBD] [MID] ($563,600)
    Nakia Cockatoo [GEE] ($172,700)
    Sam Kerridge [CAR] [MID] ($137,600)
    Paul Ahern [GWS] [MID] ($123,900)
    Christian Petracca [MEL] [MID] ($123,900)
    Shane Yarran [FRE] ($117,300)

    0

    0
  5. Defenders: McVeigh, Bartel, Yeo, Smith.B, Byrne.C, Brown.M (Hibberd.M, Bonner.R)

    Midfields: Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Rockliff, Wines, Liberatore, Kerridge.S, Gore.D (Freeman.N, Keays.B, Mathieson.R)

    Rucks: Martin.S, Naitanui.N (Loersch.C)

    Forwards: Martin, Barlow, Harvey, Merrett.Z, Kommer.N, Petracca.C (Short.J, Adams.M)

    0

    0
  6. Well after last years shocker season happy to wipe it clean and start again.

    Left about 127k per rookie hopefully should be enough to get the right ones when the time comes.

    Rich the biggest concern hopefully avoids a tag with Beams Rocky & Hanley all fit and firing. Montagna is a class player really surprised to not see him in more teams. 18 games at around 110 and ill be more then happy.

    Bartel, Yeo, Rich, Smith

    Gaz Pendles Selwood Rocky Libba

    Goldy, Martin

    Deledio Montagna Dusty Barlow

    0

    0
  7. Defenders:
    Jarrad McVeigh [SYD] [MID] ($542,600)
    Rory Laird [ADE] ($506,200)
    Nick Malceski [GCS] ($383,800)
    Dylan Buckley [CAR] ($296,800)
    Mitchell Brown [WCE] ($133,900)
    Mitch Brown [ESS] [FWD] ($117,300)
    Riley Bonner [PTA] ($117,300)
    Bailey Rice [STK] ($117,300)

    Midfielders:
    Gary Ablett [GCS] ($623,200)
    Patrick Cripps [CAR] ($519,600)
    Mitch Duncan [GEE] ($493,000)
    Lachie Hunter [WBD] ($415,500)
    Tom Liberatore [WBD] ($357,300)
    Jaeger O’Meara [GCS] ($316,300)
    Dale Thomas [CAR] [FWD] ($308,700)
    Brad Crouch [ADE] ($306,100)
    James Aish [COL] [DEF] ($275,700)
    Jarryd Lyons [ADE] [FWD] ($241,900)
    Callum Mills [SYD] ($211,800)

    Rucks:
    Stefan Martin [BRL] ($597,600)
    Matthew Leuenberger [ESS] [FWD] ($310,700)
    Mabior Chol [RIC] [FWD] ($102,400)

    Forwards:
    Luke Dahlhaus [WBD] [MID] ($563,600)
    Harley Bennell [FRE] [MID] ($548,600)
    Aaron Hall [GCS] [MID] ($428,100)
    Jack Martin [GCS] ($386,300)
    Sam Kerridge [CAR] [MID] ($137,600)
    Christian Petracca [MEL] [MID] ($123,900)
    Nick Kommer [ESS] ($123,900)
    Mason Cox [COL] [RUC] ($117,300)

    0

    0
  8. Shaw 607,800
    bartell 470,400
    jaensh 407,600
    seedsman 324,700
    malceski 383,800
    otten 148,400
    hibberd 117,300
    brown 117,300

    Ablett 623,200
    swallow 416,800
    rockcliff 550,100
    watson 499,600
    Libba 357,300
    omera 316,300
    crouch 306,100
    trengrove 156,500
    janssen 123,900
    Gore 123,900
    freeman 123,900

    blicav 562,700
    martin 597,600
    west 196,700

    barlow 505,300
    dahlhaus 563,600
    motlop 475,400
    bird 348,000
    kennedy 187,800
    kommer 123,900
    kerridge 137,600
    petracca 123,900

    2600 left over thoughts?

    0

    0
  9. Happy New Years all.

    My first post on this site for the year. I’m sure my team will look nothing like this by round 1. Like the guys above- all rookies are subject to nab form

    Kk, docherty, Bartel, b smith, m
    Brown, b white, durdin, Byrne

    Pendles, gaz, Selwood, rocky, Parker, Libba, Gresham, ahern, Cunningham, hibberd, r Davis

    Goldy, blix, loersch

    Dusty, dollhouse, Bennell, Anderson, petracca, Kerridge, m Adams, s yarran

    Feel free to pick the s*** out of it guys!

    0

    0
  10. 1. Shaw, H – GWS $607,800
    2. Smith, B – ADE MID $415,500
    3. Malceski, N – GCS $383,800
    4. Brown, M – WCE$133,900
    5. Hibberd, M – NTH MID $117,300
    6. Bonner, R – PTA $117,300
    23. Brown, M – ESS FWD $117,300
    24. Collins, K – WBD $117,300

    MIDFIELDERS
    7. Dangerfield, P – GEE $647,000
    8. Ablett, G – GCS $623,200
    9. Rockliff, T – BRL $550,100
    10. Watson, J – ESS $499,600
    11. Duncan, M – GEE $493,000
    12. Liberatore, T – WBD $357,300
    13. O’Meara, J – GCS$316,300 (or B.Crouch if not ready Rnd 1)
    14. Gore, D – ADE $123,900
    25. Petracca, C – MELFWD$123,900
    26. Keays, B – BRL $117,300
    27. Mathieson, R – BRL $117,300

    RUCKS
    15. Goldstein, T – NTH $695,100
    16. Jacobs, S – ADE $582,500
    28. Naismith, S – SYD FWD$123,900

    FORWARDS
    17. Bennell, H – FRE MID $548,600
    18. Barlow, M – FRE MID $505,300
    19. Bird, C – ESS MID $348,000
    20. Leuenberger, M – ESS RUC $310,700
    21. Thomas, D – CAR MID $308,700
    22. Kennedy, B – MEL MID $187,800
    29. Wells, D – NTH MID $243,900
    30. Kerridge, S – CAR MID$137,600

    Danger in for Fyfe. Will need to bolster defence to ensure have 6 + at least 1 sub playing. Got some hugely risky players coming back from injury who will need to get through the NAB cup & show a fair bit of potential.

    0

    0
  11. G’day esteemed SC Talkers, I’m just gonna leave this here and hopefully I will get some feedback, all rookies are set in concrete unless of course they dont get picked come round 1.

    D:Bartel, Yeo, Smith,Aish,M.Brown (WCE) Allir x 2,(Byrne, Adams (FWD)
    M: Gaz, Pendles, JPK, Joelwood, Rocky, Liber,Blakely, Freeman (Gore, Long(Fwd), Hibberd(Def)
    R: Goldy, Martin (Naismith)
    F:Deledio, Dollhouse, Barlow,Leuenburger,Kerridge, Petracca (M.Brown(def),Yarran)

    $34,800 leftover.

    0

    0
  12. Hi everybody its my first draft of the year so feel free to tear it apart
    Def:
    M.Boyd
    E.Yeo
    B.Smith
    M.Suckling
    M.Rosa
    J.Thurlow

    M.Brown
    M.Brown
    Mids:
    G.Abblet
    J.Selwood
    T.Rockcliff
    D.Prestia
    T.Libertore
    B.Crouch
    L.Duggan
    J.Anderson

    J.Trengrove
    S.Kerridge
    L.Sumner
    Rucs:
    S.Jacobs
    M.Leuenberger

    T.West
    Fwds:
    D.Zorko
    C.Wingard
    T.Walker
    C.Bird
    D.Wells
    B.Kennedy

    C.Pretrenca
    D.Myers

    Unsure about D.Prestia, T.Walker, and J.Thurlow prices if someone can let me know

    0

    0
  13. Defenders:
    Heath Shaw [GWS] ($607,800)
    Bachar Houli [RIC] ($516,100)
    Elliot Yeo [WCE] [MID] ($443,300)
    Brodie Smith [ADE] [MID] ($415,500)
    Eric MacKenzie [WCE] ($243,400)
    Eric Hipwood [BRL] [FWD] ($162,300)
    Aliir Aliir [SYD] ($123,900)
    Mitchell Hibberd [NTH] [MID] ($117,300)

    Midfielders:
    Patrick Dangerfield [GEE] ($647,000)
    Gary Ablett [GCS] ($623,200)
    Dayne Beams [BRL] ($612,100)
    Tom Liberatore [WBD] ($357,300)
    Jaeger O’Meara [GCS] ($316,300)
    Brad Crouch [ADE] ($306,100)
    Liam Duggan [WCE] [FWD] ($229,800)
    Aaron Francis [ESS] [MID] ($198,300)
    Brayden Fiorini [GCS] ($135,300)
    Rhys Mathieson [BRL] ($117,300)
    Corey Adamson [WCE] [MID] ($117,300)

    Rucks:
    Shane Mumford [GWS] ($570,500)
    Nic Naitanui [WCE] ($560,700)
    Cameron Loersch [GCS] [FWD] ($102,400)

    Forwards:
    Brett Deledio [RIC] ($608,800)
    Dustin Martin [RIC] [MID] ($569,300)
    Michael Barlow [FRE] [MID] ($505,300)
    Daniel Wells [NTH] [MID] ($243,900)
    Christian Petracca [MEL] [MID] ($123,900)
    Sam Kerridge [CAR] [MID] ($137,600)
    Liam Sumner [CAR] [MID] ($123,900)
    Daniel Rioli [RIC] ($157,800)

    its my first attempt of the year, so its a bit scratchy. ive only gone with the three premium priced players in the midfield because I think omeara crouch and libba are all capable of scoring just as high as any premium. also haven’t done much work on the rookies just yet, so they are more or less notional rookies at this point in time, feel free to pick it to pieces, should I trust mumford? went with bellchambers last year and it killed me so I’m thinking ill probably stick with two premos for the ruck line

    0

    0
  14. 5th January – Harbour Heroes version 6.

    Defenders:
    Heath Shaw [GWS] ($607,800)
    Jarrad McVeigh [SYD] [MID] ($542,600)
    Elliot Yeo [WCE] [MID] ($443,300)
    Brodie Smith [ADE] [MID] ($415,500)
    James Aish [COL] [MID] ($275,700)
    Andy Otten [ADE] ($148,400)

    Mitchell Brown [WCE] ($133,900)
    Mitchell Brown [ESS] [FWD] ($117,300)

    Midfielders:
    Gary Ablett [GCS] ($623,200)
    Joel Selwood [GEE] ($565,500)
    Tom Rockliff [BRL] ($550,100)
    David Swallow [GCS] ($416,800)
    Tom Liberatore [WBD] ($357,300)
    Jaeger Oโ€™Meara [GCS] ($316,300)
    Brad Crouch [ADE] ($306,100)
    Liam Duggan [WCE] [FWD] ($229,800)

    Sam Kerridge [CAR] [FWD] ($137,600)
    Christian Petracca [MEL] [MID] ($123,900)
    Mitchell Hibberd [NTH] [DEF] ($117,300)

    Rucks:
    Kurt Tippett [SYD] [RUC] ($483,800)
    Stefan Martin [BRL] ($597,600)

    Cameron Loersch [GCS] [FWD] ($102,400)

    Forwards:
    Harley Bennell [FRE] [MID]($548,600)
    Chad Wingard [PTA] ($527,800)
    Matthew Wright [CAR] [MID] ($294,800)
    Daniel Wells [NTH] [MID] ($243,900)
    Jed Anderson [NTH] [MID] ($223,900)
    Daniel Gorringe [CAR] [RUC] ($222,300)

    Ben Kennedy [MEL] [MID] ($187,800)
    Liam Sumner [CAR] [MID] ($123,900)

    Little bit thin in the forwards I know, but Kurt Tippett will move in there when I buy Goldy. And I do have Kerridge, Duggan, Petracca to swap in as well as the two subs.

    Only question – Selwood down to Patrick Cripps [CAR] ($519,600) or Luke Parker [SYD] ($538,200).

    Would let me upgrade Wingard to Zorko.

    Well guys, your turn to rip me a new one and tell me how wrong I am.

    0

    0
  15. HH Luke Parker is a more proven premium than Cripps. Parker is in a better team.

    Cripps also likely to cop a few tags with blues light on midfield depth.

    So Parker all the way at that price probably undervalued after early season concussion last year causing a form slump.

    0

    0
  16. Sadly pretrenca has broken a toe and wont be having a full preseason but hopefully a downgrade target during mid year once back in full fitness

    0

    0
  17. Ok this is how i am going leave my team hope it works good for me tell me what u guys think

    Def
    Ranch shaw seedsman m rosa doedee aish bench hibberd bonner

    Mids
    Abeltt j selwood wines d armtige libby b crouch hopper gresham bench kerredge keys mengola

    Rucks goldy jaccobs bench loresch

    Fwds
    Chad wingard dahlhaus m wright d menzil schache widemen bench petrecca l summner

    Got 110 k left so what do u guys think i reckon this team could get me of to a flyer

    0

    0
  18. May i ask a question hear i notice a lot of people dont have wines or armtige both those players should be or one in your team look at the points they scored last year i rather go armtige and wines over pendles and rocky might sound crazy

    0

    0
  19. Granted menzil been out of the afl in 4 years game against the pies 135 hawks twice 140 the guy has been unlucky with knee bur i rather have him then wells wells is a waste i dont tnink he will do much with supercoach scores

    0

    0
  20. DEF: H. Shaw, J. McVeigh, B. Smith, M. Brown, A. Aliir, D. Viojo-Rainbow (M. Brown, N. Newman)
    MID: P. Dangerfield, S. Pendlebury, G. Ablett jnr, J. Selwood, T. Rockliff, T. Liberatore, J. Trengove, J. Gresham (D. Gore, J. Jansen, B. Keays)
    RUC: S. Martin, S. Jacobs (C. Loersch)
    FWD: B. Deledio, L. Montagna, D. Martin, B. Kennedy, S. Kerridge, C. Petracca (L. Sumner, A. McDonald-Tipungwuti)
    CASH LEFT: $46,400

    I’m happy with my team right now, I’ve just got one question though. Would you guys go with dangerfied, stef Martin and 45k or JPK and Goldstein?

    0

    0
  21. Ok after taking some advice from guys on hear. My team is this

    Def p seedsman e yoe j aish h shaw m rosa doedee bench adamson bonner

    Mids gary abblet .j selwood. o wines t rocklif. j stevson. libby gresham. hopper bench kerridge hibbard mangola

    Rucks s martin. S jaccobs bench lorsche

    Fwds l dahlhuas. C wingard m wright. D menzil scarshe wideman bench d rioli summner

    So what do u think of my team know i think this. Is better then my first one let me know

    0

    0
  22. Sorry guys for my spelling but u guys are rude wankers and i will be winning the supercoach this year so why dont u stop and think my spelling might be bad bur i think i am going hit 2800 first game

    0

    0
  23. Nick well you have not set a high Benchmark to better at Supercoach than you are at spelling.
    Seeing as you are talking such a big game let us all know what the name of your Supercoach team will be so we can monitor your progress. We dont like big noters on the site but you could prove us all wrong.
    So Nick what will your teams name be?

    0

    0
  24. Great Thanks Nick I will be impressed if you can finish in the top 5k. That is just a pass mark for most people on the site.

    Good luck and be sure to let us all know of your progress thru the year and your 2800 1st round prize winning score.

    0

    0
  25. Are you taking the piss Nick.
    I was trying to give you constructive advice regarding the way you post in the way you dont use these……
    Use sentences.

    Look I won’t and once the site gets busy people will only engage with you by their dislikes.

    HH has already been very patient with you.

    As a once off I will advice you that Zac Smith is in the no go zone IMO.
    Smith is too injury prone and has not cemented his spot in the Cats team.
    Smith is not a proven premo ruck so not a keeper and at his awkard price is not a stepping stone to a Goldy.

    0

    0
  26. Keep it civil, fellas. Everyone here wants the same thing, no need for it to get outta hand.

    @HH – I haven’t put together any teams yet but taking plenty of mental notes from your comments. Doing the hard work early, good stuff!

    0

    0
  27. Here is my team. For now
    DEF: McViegh, Yeo, Smith, (Bonner)
    Malceski, Aish, Brown (ESS) (Byrne)

    MID: Ablett, Pendles, Selwood, Rocky, (Hibberd) (Mathieson)
    Libba, JOM, Gresham, Gore (Sumner)

    RUC: Goldy, Martin (Loersch)

    FWD: Montagna, Dahlhaus, Zorko (Petracca)
    Anderson, Kennedy, Kerridge (Ahern)

    Please give me your thoughts on my team. Would really love some help
    Thanks in advance Liam

    0

    0
  28. OK AFTER thinking about my team i have done a set and forget def let me know what u think

    Def H shaw J mcveigh M rosa E yoe P seedsman T doedee. Bench adamson booner

    Mids
    G Ablett J selwood J stevson O wines Libby J aish Hooper Gresham bench hibbard kerraidge keys.

    RUCKS
    Jacobs Martin bench loersh

    Fwds
    L dahlhaus C wingard M wright D menzil J schache S weidemen bench d rioli l sumner

    So what do u guys think know i am sort of up and down on aish or crouch. I think aish will make a fair bit of money as it might take crouch a few weeks etc. This is my final team

    0

    0
  29. howdy people its that time of year again super coach this is what my team looks like defenders yeo Brodie smith Carlisle seedsman doedee Mitch brown alillr Bonner midfields Dangerfield ablett rockliff Duncan liberatore brad crouch james aish Jed Anderson Gresham Keogh freeman rucks godly ryder cox forwards bennell roughead franklin walker leuenberger Curnow brown markov

    0

    0
  30. thanks do you think walker forbid injury will be a good pick and what about malceski hope Rodney eade does not play him like he did last year will take your advice on Carlisle

    0

    0
  31. NEW TEAM: DEFENCE YEO,E MALCESKI,N CARLISLE,J WALKER,A SEEDSMAN,P BROWN,M DOEDEE,T BONNER,R MIDFIELDS DANGERFIELD,P ABLETT,G ROCKLIFF,T DUNCAN,M LIBERATORE,T CROUCH,B AISH,J ANDERSON,J GRESHAM,J GORE,D DAVIS,R RUCKS MARTIN,S RYDER,P COX FORWARDS BENNELL,H ROUGHEAD,J FRANKLIN,L WALKER,T LEUENBERGER,CURNOW,C BROWN,M MARKOV,O

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *