Trade Talk R20, 2013

Written by Motts on August 5 2013

Welcome to the first week of SC Finals!

You’re probably going to be a little skinny on trades this week. I’ll still be pulling the trigger on a couple but will wait on the Ibbo/Priddo prognoses before making any final decisions.

Has Tom Mitchell played his last game for your boys? Who’s on your radar?

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

118 thoughts on “Trade Talk R20, 2013”

  1. Ibbotson was withdrawn because of an achilles injury. Priddis was out because of a quad. That could mean a couple of sideways trades for The Maulers this week.

    0

    0
  2. planning on mitchell to watson. also looking at barlow for his easy draw but watson’s price is probably too good to pass up. plans might change if priddis is not named.
    T/U watson
    T/D barlow

    0

    0
  3. I’ve got priddis and ibbotson, but i have a feeling they might both be back this week. Hopefully they were just rested.
    Cant decide on pendles, beams or griffen as an upgrade for T mitchell

    0

    0
  4. Going to upgrade Staker for the 1st week of the finals for a premo midfielder (via DPP) – Cash isn’t an issue.

    Current Midfield – Ablett, Pendles, Danger, Cotch, Deledio, JPK, Murphy and Mitchell (bench Colquhoun and Kennedy)

    Want to move Mitchell to M9

    T/U Griffin
    T/D Beams

    Comment – Jack (or other recommendation)

    0

    0
  5. Interested in peoples thoughts on JPK. He doesn’t seem to be the player that he was earlier on this/last year??

    0

    0
  6. So I’ve got to get rid of Zorko…

    4 trades left

    Got just enough cash for Brent Harvey.
    OR
    Trade Nicholls in for cash and switch Zorko to Stevie J
    OR
    Go for a POD such as Pavlich?

    I won my league and only lost one early round, ironically the team I play in the first week of the finals is the team I lost too!

    I also have Priddis in the mids to consider, is their any word on his injury?

    0

    0
  7. Hey guys

    I’ve got a few under performing premiums in jpk and priddis. I’m considering burning 2 of my last 3 trade to get someone like danger field, beams, and jobe as pods

    What do you think thanks.

    0

    0
  8. 5 trades left, $220k in the bank, what should I do with T Mitchell as my M8?
    Current midfield: Swan, Pendles, Barlow, Danger, Ablett, Cotchin

    Thumbs up: Griffen, great draw and your must-win final opponent has him
    Thumbs down: Watson, will average the same as Griff and you’ll save $80k too

    0

    0
  9. Who’s short on trades, not me. I have 8 remaining so plenty of opportunity for fine tuning. I seriously thought about trading Cox out for Rioli, glad I didn’t go through with that. But, is there any danger JPK will go big again? I suspect it’s time to move him on.

    0

    0
  10. I need to replace swallow

    not sure if I should go with griffin or barlow

    T/U griffin
    T/D barlow

    money isn’t an issue

    0

    0
  11. Was wondering whether I should trade Staker to D.Martin or trade Zorko and get someone else under 498k.

    T/U: Staker to Martin

    T/D: Zorko to someone cheaper

    0

    0
  12. Still holding onto my last trade. My nerves will be tested though with Priddis in doubt, and Mundy now also carrying an ankle and could be rested against the GWS in Perth. I have Viney and TMitch, but not sure I can go into a final series with those 2 starting.

    Griffen is the obvious option.

    0

    0
  13. 3 trades left. Only 15k in the bank

    Thumbs Up: Trade Staker to Dixon, completing my backline, leaving $4.5k in the bank and two trades

    Thumbs Down: Trade Nicholls to Grundy and upgrade Priddis to Jack/Watson/Danger/Barlow leaving one trade and roughly $150k in bank

    0

    0
  14. Just the one trade – Staker > Boomer

    Only one trade left for the rest of the finals, but gotta be in it to win it!!

    0

    0
  15. 2 trades left 156k in the bank. Top 4 in all my leagues so 2nd chance.

    If Ibbotson isnt named this week do I trade him to Hanley, Enright or another Premium or Keep him because of how good his Finals run is.
    Goddard, Gibbs, Shaw, Ibbotson, Heppell, McKenzie is my DEF.

    T/U: Trade him if not named.
    T/D: Keep him and play Webster on field.

    0

    0
  16. Could be in trouble this week. Have Ibbo Priddis and T.Mitchell, but only three trades left and even worse only 18,000 in the bank. Am thinking Mitchell to Deledio for sure, and will wait for team news on Ibbo and Priddis, not that I have many options with the limited funds I have.

    0

    0
  17. Looking at moving on JPK , thinking about Griffin or K Jack
    what do you think I have 2 trades & about $260 k

    T/U Griffin
    T/D K Jack

    0

    0
  18. Made top 4 and I have 4 trades and then 184 k. Decisions are 1 or 2 trades. Im thinking 2and which def? where else do I need to upgrade?

    Team

    B Goddard Gibbs Shaw Heppel Ibottson Clisby (Goodes, Thurlow)
    C Ablett Penldes Swan Danger JPK Barlow Priddis Fyfe (Mitchell Saunders)
    R Kreuzer Jacobs (Grundy Rowe)
    F Cox Franklin Rockcliff Kennedy Stevie J Martin (Staker B Kennedy)
    Clisby (Goodes, Thurlow)
    C Ablett Penldes Swan Danger JPK Barlow Priddis Fyfe (Mitchell Saunders)
    R Kreuzer Jacobs (Grundy Rowe)
    F Cox Franklin Rockcliff Kennedy Stevie J Martin (Staker B Kennedy)

    Thumbs up Goodes out for Scotland and then hold for prelim/GF(hopefully) and 246k in bank

    Thumbs down Goodes out for Scotland and Priddis out for Griffen 153k in the bank

    0

    0
  19. Team right now
    B: Goddard – Heppell – McKenzie – Gibbs – Hibberd – Ibbotson – (Staker – Thurlow)
    M: Ablett – Pendlebury – Swan – Cotchin – Fyfe – Liberatore – Priddis – JPK (T Mitchell – Hrovat)
    R: Maric – Roughead (Nicholls – Currie)
    F: S Johnson – Rockliff – Martin – Bartel – Cox – JJK (Steinberg – Mcbean)

    Have only 2 trades left, but 400K in cash after making a (unnecessary) panic trade after the late withdrawal of Ibbotson, getting in Steinberg as I had Stakes in FWD.

    Have a tough match up coming up in the elimination final, and tempted to trade.

    T/U Upgrade Staker to a Shaw/Hanley/Bob Murphy
    T/D Upgrade Tom Mitchell to a Selwood/Beams/Griffen

    0

    0
  20. I’m overseas so have let my team slip a bit. Have 7 trades left and $400k just scraped into finals so have no second chance. Team currently as follows:

    D: Goddard, Shaw, Thompson, Gibbs, Heppell, Hanley, (Clisby, Wilson)
    M: Ablett, Swan, Griffen, Dangerfield, JPK, Cotchin, Fyfe, SJ (Mitchell, B.Kennedy)
    R: Cox, Goldstein (Nicholls, Gawn)
    F: Walker, Bartel, Martin, JJK, Rockliff, Franklin (Staker, Rowe)

    T/U – Franklin to Pendlebury (via SJ going forward)
    T/D – JPK to pendlebury.

    Or any other suggestions?

    0

    0
  21. was thinking of this bringing Enright in foir smith and bring back jobe Watson for priddis what you guys think of those trades

    0

    0
  22. my teams back goddard heppel gibbs ibbston Enright and shaw mids beems swann penddels abblett Watson cotchen and deledio selwood

    rucks minsion and cox

    fwds walker stevie j jimmy bartel buddy kenndy and cloke what do you think of that team I reckon I kill the finals

    0

    0
  23. Gibbs and his crappy scoring out for Dixon who has a dream finals run

    Def will be :- Goddard, Hanley, Enright, Hibberd, Dixon, Talia – (Vlas, Colqhuon)

    T/U – yep
    T/D – no, try and get Libba in (that’s for Steve)

    0

    0
  24. Can afford any D for Goodes so which one will score the most this rd that I dont already have?
    Team:
    B Goddard Gibbs Shaw Heppel Ibottson Clisby (Goodes, Thurlow)
    C Ablett Penldes Swan Danger JPK Barlow Priddis Fyfe (Mitchell Saunders)
    R Kreuzer Jacobs (Grundy Rowe)
    F Cox Franklin Rockcliff Kennedy Stevie J Martin (Staker B Kennedy)

    Thumbs up Hanley
    Thumbs down Mckenzie

    0

    0
  25. Have gone

    Priddis > Griffen
    Buddy > Martin

    which leads me with 2 trades left

    Team Reads atm:

    D: Goddard, Thompson, Gibbs, Heppell, Hartlett, Mckenzie (Duffield, Clisby )
    M: Ablett, Swan, Griffen, Pendelbury, JPK, Barlow, Fyfe, Selwood (Mitchell, K.Martin)
    R: Minson Goldstein (Nicholls, Currie)
    F: Cox, Bartel, Martin, JJK, Rockliff, Stevie J (Staker, Macaffer)

    0

    0
  26. 1 trade left, $285 in the kitty

    B: Goddard, Heppel, Ibbotson, Murphy, Gibbs, Staker (Clarke, Clisby)
    M: Ablett, Pendles, Barlow, Dangerfield, Fyfe, Stevie J, Delidio, Pridis (Mitchel, Martin)
    R: Minson, Nichols (Currie, McBean)
    F: Martin, Rockliff, Bartel, Kennedy, Franklin, Ryder (Winderlich, Daniher)

    Ibbotson, Priddis and Nichols all in the grey zone

    Was hoping to move Stevie J forward, trade winderlich out for Griffen, Swan or K. Jack and hope for the best

    Nichols the only one i can’t cover short term (as I backed him in when I booted Nic Nat) – I’m top 4 in all leagues, so have the double chance to wait on Ibboston, pridis and nichols

    Suggestions??

    0

    0
  27. In a bit of a predincidink.
    can’t really trust Franklin’s bipolar scoring anymore as a regular so was thinking

    Either:

    Winderlich > Rockliff
    Nicholls > McBean

    This would leave Franklin as my forward sub with the option to rotate cox to ruck
    if Goldstein/Minston have an out during finals (obviously at the expense of a donut from mcbean every week)

    OR – other option would be to trade

    Franklin > Rockliff
    Nicholls > Grundy

    which leaves Winderlich and Grundy on the pine as B grade substitutes. only problem with this is that it would leave me with about $400k. overkill considering I would only have 1 trade left with no-one in my A side below $400k

    I only have 3 trades left so it would be cutting it fine. but this would leave 1 emergency trade for finals and I’m pretty well covered for the rest of the ground with clisby and mitchell

    would appreciate some guidance

    0

    0
  28. Hey guys need your hand with what moves I should make:

    Backs: Goddard, Heppell, Shaw, Gibbs, McKenzie, Goodes (Clisby, Webster)
    Mids: Ablett, Pendles, Swan, Selwood, Barlow, JPK, T.Mitchell, Rockliff (Priddis, Crouch)
    Rucks: McEvoy, Jacobs (Nicholls, Currie)
    Fwds: Cox, JJK, Walker, Martin, Bartel, Staker (Daniher, Oxley)

    Don’t know what moves to make, currently 2 trades left and only 11k in the bank.

    What would be a good premium upgrade in the leadup to my qualifying finals matches this week? (in top 4 in 3 leagues) I’m very much the underdog against the opponents I’m facing this week.

    0

    0
  29. Hey guys could really do with some trade help this week, I have made the finals but will be a definite underdog in my match this week.

    I have 3 trades left with $17,900 in the bank, here is how my team is currently looking.

    GODDARD, HEPPELL, SHAW, MCKENZIE, IBBO STAKER (CLISBY, SIERAKOWSKI)

    ABLETT, SWAN, K.JACK, J.SELWOOD, JPK, FYFE, PRIDDIS, MITCHELL (B.JACK, NEADE)

    COX, JACOBS (NICHOLLS, CURRIE)

    DUSTY, BARTEL, ROUGHIE, BUDDY, BOOMER, JJK (DANIHER, COLLEDGE)

    Cheers.

    0

    0
  30. Trading Tom Mitchell but which midfielder should I get?
    Midfield currently is Ablett, Pendlebury, Swan, Jack, Barlow, J.Selwood, JPK, T.Mitchell
    TU: Griffen
    TD: Danger
    Comment for Beams or anyone else
    I have two trades left and $220,800 in the bank, Mitchell and Pittard are the two upgrades left, not sure what price Pittard will get to.

    0

    0
  31. Hey SCT coaches,

    Thinking of off loading Franklin, swapping Bartel to the fwd line & grabbing Barlow in the mids!

    T/U…….gr8 trade, maximising scoring
    T/D…….foolish, save the trade!

    Cheers

    0

    0
  32. I’m hearing you Adam, he should have a huge night!

    The thing that frustrates me up against the lesser teams like Melbourne, GC & GWS where you’d think he’d smash out massive score’s & monster the opposition, he’s only raised the bat v GWS for 107! He’s pissing me off & I think getting in a Barlow will maximise scoring with on ballers on both my mid & fwd line for SC finals.

    0

    0
  33. I am just biting the bullet till I need too.
    League Rankings 2nd, 3rd, 4th, then the big boys SC CASH 11th LEOC2 16th

    Only 1 trade 4 of them I have the double chance ok only the seconds in the Cash but something.

    Just cannot trust anything at the moment Hodgey out Thumb, kept Danger Came back. NIc Nat who knows still got him. Hanley was back early. Watson wow back early than I can believe.

    Fingers crossed my team gets across the line.

    Love the talk of Buddy out, Rance Killed him last year as well, against the Saints he will fire and I hope all the people I play against have not got him.

    0

    0
  34. Also well done to the Tigers Credit where credit due.
    No chance to watch it Saturday sat down Sunday stayed away from the scores to watch the replay and they flogged us again.

    Cotchin played so well. We have some work to do to beat the Tiges and Geelong.

    0

    0
  35. Just looking through some stats, if you have a premium midfielder counting out GWS Melbourne the game Watson did not play against Hawthorn you could nearly make them Capt each week.

    Each of the Number 1 mids from each team from round 1 are averaging a whooping 132 points against the Hawks.

    Highest Danger 173 lowest Barlow 95.

    Weeks read Cotchin 144 Watson DNP Griffen 140 Boak 139 Selwood 151, 126. Ablett 149 Gibbs (Murphy out 132, Judd 128) JPK 143, Danger 173 Swallow 125 Barlow 95, Pendles 124, Priddis 113, 102.

    We must give out on average more points than any other team.

    0

    0
  36. Looking at two upgrades this week

    T/U = 1. Nicholls – Cox, & 2. Staker – Rockliff/Walker

    T/D = 1. Nicholls – Maric/Mumford, & 2. Staker – Stevie J

    I’m tragically 2k short of getting both Cox and Stevie J 🙁

    0

    0
  37. This decision’s been haunting me all hump day. Thought I’d throw this one out to SCT community. What’s the better combo to have leading into finals?

    Sam Mitchell and Charlie Dixon? (T/U)

    Jobe Watson and Heath Scotland? (T/D)

    Thanks in advance guys. Appreciate your votes/feedback

    0

    0
  38. After some advice. 2 trades left 96,000 in bank but have double chance in all my 3 leagues. Was thinking of trading Nic Nat to Roughead or have to play Mayes no bench cover. Then if Priddis does not play upgrade to Barlow also have no bench cover with hrovat and Ben Kennedy . Finally if Priddis plays I have Mitchell as M8 and wondering do I use last trade on say a gold coast midfielder Dion Prestia for 51K or should I save the trade. Any other opinions would be good in a bit of a pickle due to no bench cover in forward or midfield.

    0

    0
  39. Anyone else looking at sidebottom, ward or redden as straight swaps from jpk or priddis. They have all been massive in thier last few games and could become an outstanding finals POD. the one im considering the most is Callan Ward at the moment. But then again Sidebottom’s been great since beams has come back.

    0

    0
  40. Only 2 trades left, so:

    This week: T.Mitchell > Watson
    Then, next week: Pittard > Hanley/Dixon

    TU: Good trades
    TD: There’s better options

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *