R2 Wash Up

Written by Duck on April 9 2012

Righto, how’d your boys go? Who’s head will roll and who’s a lock as we head into the first of the league matches?

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

253 thoughts on “R2 Wash Up”

  1. Martin score hasn’t been to good. But that’s not what is worries me. He doesn’t seem to be playing to much time in the mid. What does everyone think?

    0

    0
  2. I have made my decision. You do not sideways trade. Ever(unless LTI). However I may have to reconsider Golby as my mid-priced POD. There appears to be better options at his price and he is still young so will get better just not good enough for my needs. I am not happy with Shaw, Broughton, Pavlich and Martin but will stand by them. Trades are gold.

    0

    0
  3. No major changes for me this week ill just be swapin a couple of rookies im thinkin Out-Dickson, Wilson IN-Milera,Kennedy.
    Only premos im not happy with are Shaw,and Dusty but ill stick by them Theyll come good.Keep the faith i say

    0

    0
  4. has anyone thought of Whitecross?? starting the season fantastic.. 98 Vs pies LW, 100+ TW.. can he maintain it??

    0

    0
  5. Broughton is gone this week for me and many other coaches,

    Which gun would you take ?

    Thumbs Up – G.Birchall ($509,600)

    Thumbs Down – A.Carrazzo ( $505,800)

    Cheers ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  6. Need to make one of these trades to get cash to upgrade broughton.

    Thumbs up: Bartel to Stanton
    Thumbs down: D.Smith to Milera

    I know Stanton is doing good, but I’m pretty pleased with Bartel. I think smith will come good in a few weeks but I think I have to many GWS players so trading him for Milera will improve my side.

    0

    0
  7. in SCTTL1..

    2013.. Very happy that i cracked 2k comsidering i was more worried bout getting Mummy on the bench in my No. 1 team, i completely forgot bout him in this team.. ALSO!!! did the dumb thing of making cox Capt!!!! all in all, happy to crack 2k and will be making trades this wk.

    0

    0
  8. 2253
    Was on track for more but i’ll take that score. ๐Ÿ™‚
    Thinking of the following trades:
    Dickson > Milera
    Broughton > Dempsey
    Pretty good supercoach weekend, but as a Hawks supporter, absolutely gutted.

    0

    0
  9. What the hell is wrong with kicking the ball in the air? Why would you try dribble it in the wet?
    Anyway, scored 2119 in my second week of SC, so maintaining a 2000/rd average so far.
    Probably trade a couple this week to fix problems like Broughton and a rookie

    0

    0
  10. Anyone think that Broughton to Goddard is a good trade and yes i am an idiot from not having him from the start?

    0

    0
  11. O stephanson: do not know what to do with him? didnt geta game today and cant see him getting one for little while

    0

    0
  12. 2164, 5th best in my work league. 1 guy scored 2428 will be up there for the $1000 i think.

    Broughton on the chopping block. He does my head in. Hes on the list with Higgins now.

    Possibly Mumford too depending on the news.

    0

    0
  13. 2053 with Murphy captain.

    Seen a few go with this format, so I might go back to school and give it a go this week:
    A+: Murphy, Deledio, Lake, Goddard, Ablett
    A: Pendlebury, Magner, Clarke, Selwood
    B: Fyfe, Kennedy, Shiel, Bugg, Ellis
    C: Cox, Broughton, Franklin, Smith
    D: Pavlich, Martin, Hall
    F: Mumford (no EMG)

    Not looking forward to seeing the overall ranking I’ll have tonight, but it’s only early days. Leaning towards sticking with Broughton as he’s got Brisbane, Gold Coast and Port in his next 5 and he’s got just as much potential as any other premium back. Not many others doing too much better down there! And I hate trading Premiums!

    0

    0
  14. SCT5

    2160 / GAJ

    A++ โ€“ Jobe, Lids, Gods, GAJ
    A+ โ€“ Lake, TheGoodSwallow, Giles, Joelwood
    A โ€“ Magnet, Porps
    B โ€“ Fyffa, Buddy
    C โ€“ JRed, Broughts, Shaw, Kennedy, Stevie J
    D โ€“ Ellis, Dusty, DevSmith, Buggsta, Caddy

    On the chopping block:
    Broughton, Caddy, Johnson, Shaw (probably won’t trade the last 3)

    SCTTL3

    2167 / Murphy (Loophole)

    Equal second for the week.

    The Good: Murphy, Magner, Clarke, Deledio, Lake, Goddard, Giles, Ablett, Selwood

    The Bad: Pavlich, Shaw, Martin, Ellis, Smith, Bugg, Coniglio

    Chopping Block: Pavlich, Shaw, Pfeiffer, Saad

    Betting

    Bloody Hawks lost it for me in my multi – had it all in the bag and then Buddy decides to dribble it and Osborne and Breust miss sitters and I lose $560 that should have been mine.

    Happy Easter everyone! Have fun this week with your trading! ๐Ÿ˜€

    0

    0
  15. How does Schoenmakers get a game seriously? he’s gotta be the worst player of all time!! Yes, you can smile tonight relton!!

    0

    0
  16. score just ova 2100 this week and happy but knew could have got more

    good:jobe watson, deledio, dempsey, ablett, glies, porplyzia

    bad: Pavlich, Shaw, Ellis, Smith, Bugg, Coniglio

    thinking about doing one of my 3 only trades in the ruck for mumford to sandilands or someone else but wont be doing it till friday when get more news on mumford, i can see him lowering in price a little and considering shaw but wont happen as he can pull some good games

    am not looking forward to trading this week XD

    0

    0
  17. ok guys. in regards to Lake.. yeah, it was great to see the guy do well in SC world.. but what if he stinks it up nxt wk?? what score nxt wk will people be happy with from lake? he has gone from 1 extreme to the other.. is anything less then 70-80 from him a fail? or do u look at the option that not too many players his price and under will score much better then him??

    0

    0
  18. 1989 for mine and 1983 (good year) for SCTTL. No, I don’t want to talk about it *sulks* thank god my footy team won this weekend or I’d be miserable.

    0

    0
  19. If mumford has an LTI its time to bring myself in (NIC_NAT) looks like our no.1 ruck so far this year and he loves getting contested possies. should have gone with my gut feeling and started him. Cox;s numbers are down and surely Nic has something to do with it so far.

    Other option wait it out since mumford wont drop in price, (run with Redden and Giles) and get Cox or Goldstein at a cheaper price?
    Im still not sold on Sandi, i think rossy will rest him when he’s not 100%

    what u guys reckon?

    0

    0
  20. 2076 for me
    2203 for my son (SCTTL3)
    Leaves me a lot to think about

    Highlight for the weekend

    $80 on WCE 40+ @ $1.45
    $50 on WCE 100+ @ $7.80

    Number 1 tip for the year:
    Only bet on good sides

    0

    0
  21. 2244 not bad but room for improvement. Need to get in a higher scoring fwd and defender. Out Saad in Milera or A Kennedy I think. Out Morris/Ellis

    0

    0
  22. 2150, happy with the score even though it was a disappointing weekend, should have been higher if a few things went better, let’s just say luck wasn’t on my side this weekend, but oh well always next week. Hoping to get 2250-2300 next weekend.

    Thinking of this trade:
    In- Milera and Birchall
    Out- D.Smith and Broughton

    Thumbs up- Good trade
    Thumbs down- Better options for those 2 (could you please list any ideas)

    Cheers guys ๐Ÿ™‚

    0

    0
  23. I reckon if Mumford was a horse he would of been shot by you guys by now, he woke up on Saturday with slight back tightness and just failed a fitness test before the game.

    0

    0
  24. 2333 should be an ok score, broughton and minson in the ruck has been my worst supercoach decision ever…yet I’m still in the overall hunt so must trade minson this week, any thoughts on best trade for minson, I have cash? thinking Sandi, Ryder or Kruezer? Thumbs up Sandi, down Ryder…thanks

    0

    0
  25. Might go duffman into Dempsey, hold on to broughton for now. Bring milera in for pfief. Frees up a tonne of cash

    0

    0
  26. Scored a rubbish 2049. Usual non performers.
    Going to trade this week in preparation for the post round 3 price change. I’m hearing everyone about not trading so called premiums, but I don’t know if I can stomach a massive Broughton price drop. And I’d love to get Stants in.
    another massive week of indecision coming up.

    0

    0
  27. Disappointing 2192.
    Went with two unique picks for the year in Rhys Palmer and Jarryn Geary.
    Palmer showed his true ability. He’s gone for Magner.

    0

    0
  28. sitting with the trade screen open, Broughton, why can’t I do it?
    “Trade him out before his price drops”
    -“You picked him for a reason, show some faith”
    –“Courtenay dempsey?”
    —“Ball sack”

    0

    0
  29. Where can we check the break evens???

    Also, hold onto Shaw and Scotland or down grade 1 to maybe a dempsey?

    My Golby POD has been woeful to date also!

    Thoughts on those 3?

    0

    0
  30. Theres one thing i don’t understand..
    Why do people who get 2300 + in the first two rounds call it an ‘ok’ score?
    Or they question it, i’ve seen something like ‘2400 isn’t bad is it?’
    It’s a grouse score ! There’s no need to complain about it, when you’re ranked in the top 500 weekly scores!

    0

    0
  31. Could Rance be the next Joel Bowden at Tigerland with cheap disposals?
    pretty tempting.

    Broughton Dilemma.
    Problem is Ross Lyon, if broughton was playing his normal role and was just having a bad spell then i dont think we would consider trading him, the fact that he’s fine and that he’s role has changed is the real worry! he’s becoming the carazzo of a few years ago when he started tagging and playing negating roles so i think he’s gotta go, bite the bullet people!!

    0

    0
  32. What do people think of Burgoyne as a smokey for those wanting to trade out Broughton?

    His role has changed since his glory days but he has the potential to still average 95+

    0

    0
  33. Hold off on the Broughton Q’s team (I myself posted a similar Q but in regards to Shaw and Scotland so this includes me)…. I reckon Motts and the boys will be all over it with a poll in the coming days! We’re all chomping at the bit….Gotta love Supercoach!!!

    0

    0
  34. I was surprised to see Hall with a lowly 30, I expexted a solid 50 this week. Milera had another good day out. Should I swap Hall to Milera or keep the trade and stick with Hall?

    0

    0
  35. What are everyoneโ€™s current overall ranks? Has anyone moved to an early front-pack breakaway? Or are you sitting in the peloton ready to gradually make your way to the top?
    I dropped 50 thousand this week to land in the 68 thousandโ€™s. Hopefully the lactic acid hasnโ€™t already hit me!

    0

    0
  36. thinking about Broughton to Bock (will he play a full game straight up or is the vest a possibilty?) and probling going to get Kennedy or
    Milera in for smedts or hall…

    0

    0
  37. People thinking of downgrading Broughton/Shaw/Scotland to Dempsey, don’t be silly?
    Why might you ask? I’ll tell you why!
    despite saving the odd $250 K, you’re downgrading a premium, a proven performer who has generally been a supercoach favourite to a man who had the dirtiest of beards a week back.
    Some people will say “I don’t care about beards, he’s averaged 100 odd points in the last 2 weeks and is about to rise in price”
    Supercoachers, don’t be naive, we’re talking about a man who’s just come back from a season ending knee injury, with a history of inefficient ball use (though i must admit, he’s been much improved in the last 2 games).
    Dempsey, in all likelihood, won’t be a keeper in your team, once he hits a certain price, you’ll want to upgrade him to someone better, more consistent, requiring yet ANOTHER TRADE. That’s two trades used to get from one premium to another.
    Again, the counter argument might be “well i just made 250 thousand, who cares if i use 2 trades”.
    There’s no guarantee Dempsey will keep up his scoring efficiency, and what if that happens? there goes yet ANOTHER TRADE, trying to fix a premium who’s had 2 bad weeks ! Is it worth the risk, putting yet another mid-pricer in our defences anyway? When there are proven performers for the same price, such as Brian Lake? Who many of us have, do we really need another mid-pricer to solve our Premium problems?
    With that said, I must admit, the Broughton trade is looking very tempting. Why, you might ask? If he’s a premium, won’t he come good?
    Normally, the answer would be ‘of course, you’d be absurd to trade out a premium’.
    The risk many of us took was that Broughton would be used in his more fancied role of on ball, or through the guts you might prefer. This is where he churned out his best scores alst year and in previous years. What Lyon has done, is place him in a shut down role – the worst kind of role. This heavily negates his weekly supercoach score, as stopping his opponent is his main aim, not hitting 30 possies and a goal. When he was named on ball for round 1, I, like many other supercoachers placed him in our sides straight away. Big, big mistake.

    The way to go is to sideways trade him, there are plenty of options like Birchall, Bock, Suckling, Carrazzo, Bob Murphy, Fisher, and many more. There’s just no certainty in downgrading a premium to a mid-pricer.

    0

    0
  38. Overall I am happy with my team, especially Goddard, Lids, Pendles, Ablett, Giles, Goodes and Chappy.
    I expected more from Shaw and Dusty over the first two rounds but I have the faith to stick with them. Ledger will be traded this week and Hall may join him.
    I hope Mummy is well rested and rips it this week (can’t blame the guy for calling in sick against the man mountain from Freo).

    0

    0
  39. 2266. Want to trade out Broughton this week but already have god,lids, lake, m Clarke and Dempsey. No one else really grabs me so have an idea out of left field.
    Trade Broughton for Surjan from Port.
    Use the extra cash to upgrade Coniglio to Scott Selwood or Kennedy from Swans. Alternatively Stanton.
    Any feedback would be appreciated.

    0

    0
  40. 2343. was 130 off the $1000. overall ranking of 3122.

    I know you can always say “what if?” but with mumford out and buddy + shaw scoring low..

    0

    0
  41. Just did the Broughton >> Dempsey and Crapps >> Milera trades. Shit it felt good trading on a Monday!! ๐Ÿ˜›

    Of course I’ll be re-assessing over the next three days.

    0

    0
  42. Steve Johnson (BE 226) is expected to go down $71,800… I know I don’t want to trade but the new BE’s are playing tricks with my mind:

    Get rid of him – Thumbs up
    Stick with him Ollie he is a keeper – Thumbs Down

    0

    0
  43. He’s started well but will A.Rance continue his form and be in the top 10 defenders come years end?

    Thumbs up- Yes
    Thumbs down- No

    0

    0
  44. Demon of darch
    2203/buddy
    about 20000 overall
    Damn was so confident in buddy as captain. At least I made the mistake of picking him during our ‘byes’
    Going to hold Martin as I’m confident he will start playing well soon. Thinking of a cox to Kreuzer swap but probly won’t as I’m happy with 2200 at this time of year, and want to stick to my guns and rookies policy with a no trade on premiums unless their injured…or Greg broughton

    0

    0
  45. * currently thinking of Dickson to Milera
    * currently wishing i had Guthrie instead of Smedts but not going to burn a trade on that one
    * currently evalutating a few people and whether i make a sidewaysish trade – Scotland, Shaw, Swallow, Martin … think they’re all worthy of keeping, just wish they would do what they’re in the team for!!

    0

    0
  46. Trades are money. It’s as much a stock market game as it is football fantasy. Unless your prepared to stick with broughton or even a Stevie j get rid of them now before they cost you too much moula. As I see it you cannot win the 50k with a GnR strategy. Look at the teams on top at the moment. Thrown together a few premiums with many mid priced players and a few rookies. You have to arse it like these bozo’s. Build your team and Trade for cash to win your leagues.

    0

    0
  47. 2253 to back up my 2210 last week – currently sitting around 3400th overall. Hope to keep the consistency.

    0

    0
  48. 1952 / GAJ

    Deledio/Ablett/Murphy/Pendlebury – Cheers.
    Lake – You listened to us and stepped up.
    Magner/Giles – I may not bench you guys again..
    Martin/Fyfe/Shaw/Franklin – 500k+ is a premium in my book.. where are those tons fellas?
    Mumford – WTF?!? Last week I forgave you.. this week to don’t even play?
    J Riewoldt – How the hell do you do the opposite of Lake?
    Deledio – Tell your teammates to step it up.

    0

    0
  49. I Had $50 on the cats between 1-19 points @ $4.75 and final score to be Hawks between 76 and 90 and Geelong between 91 and 105 @ 16 x $10
    Also won a footy multi and soccer multi. $450 profit for the weekend and tipped 9 (not too hard this round). Scored 2201 in sc with 4/5 prems scoring less than their average.
    Pretty happy BigMolly at the moment ๐Ÿ˜€

    Quick question. UP: Persist with Parker and Golby and trade Tory Dickson and another shit rook for Milera and Greene or DOWN: Trade Parker and Golby for Milera and Greene and gain some spare cash.

    0

    0
  50. The beauty of supercoach is you know that the round doesn’t start until at least Thursday.
    Any other fantasy premier league coaches will be feeling my pain right now, the gameweek finished this morning (gw33) and the next one started about an hour ago (gw34). Pain in the ass.

    0

    0
  51. Haven’t seen any of StKilda this year and I’m trying to decide if I should swap Pfiefer for Milera on my bench or save the trade for later in the year. Thumbs up to trade.

    0

    0
  52. Hi guys,

    Quick Question: I’m surprised Dustin Martin’s name hasn’t come up in more conversation. He’s underperformed and will lose out on a heap of cash.

    I Was thinking of bringing in Zaharakis or even opting for Tommy Hawkins after his superb start to the year. Even thought of bringing in Petrie! Let me know your thoughts – Can definitely raise some money on his trade! Especially if I opt for T Hawkins who will likely go up around $20k and Dustin Martin drop around $20-30k.

    Thoughts?

    2.

    0

    0
  53. Team- Dazza’s Allstars
    Rd 1 Score-2,054
    Overall Ranking-58,754
    My Ratings
    A+-Godds,Lids,GAJ,Smurf,Pendles
    A Clarke,Magnet,Joelwood,Giles,Goodes,T,Greene
    B Morris
    C Bugg,Mohr,Ellis,Shiel,Redden(port),Cox,Buddy,Fyfe,
    D Paine,D,Smith,Smedts
    F Mummy,Hall,Dickson,Wilson.Dusty,Ledger
    Chopping Block Dusty, Hall,Dickson, Wilson.,Ledger
    Chance to come in – Kennedy,Milera,Cameron

    0

    0
  54. Was contemplating Dusty Martin and it struck me that his two games have been against Carlton and Collingwood. Of the other top five from last year he only has Geelong in Rnd 4, WC in Rnd 5 and Carlton again in Rnd 18. I’m going to hold fire and keep Dusty.

    Thumbs up: Good logic, keep him
    Thumbs down: Doesn’t look like he’s going to live up to pre-season expectations

    0

    0
  55. At the moment I have $42,300 and I am really thinking about trading Jack Grimes to Dempsey which will give me $149,000 then I was thinking Guthrie to Hargrave or McIntosh to Ryder in the ruck. My backline at the moment is Goddard, Deledio, Grimes, Lake, M Clarke, Guthrie, Ellis (Bugg, Darley) what should I do? comments.

    0

    0
  56. Is anyone thinkin about trading out Mummy IMO its a worry with him having back problems this early in the year and if its ongoing he could be in and out all year with the same problems i would like to know everyones thoughts?

    0

    0
  57. Currently have dickson and hall in my fwds but not sure if i should trade one for milera.
    Thumbs Up: Trade
    Thumbs down: Don’t waste a trade
    Also comments on who to trade would be nice

    0

    0
  58. About To Get Reimered
    2165/GAJ WR-45,848 OAR-22,400
    The Good
    GAJ, Watto, Smurph, God, Lids, Giles, Porps and Clarke.
    The Bad
    Mummy, Heater, Brought-on-a-headache, Buddy, Fyfe, Pav, Dusty
    The Ugly
    Ross Lyon.
    Pending Trades
    My Golby risk hasn’t paid off so he will be getting the chop probably for Dempsey or Lake. I will wait and see for info on Mummy about his shaggers back. If he is up the shitters ditch then it would be hard to go past a straight swap for 211.

    Squirelly Wrath SCTTL 2
    2011/GAJ
    The Good
    God, Lids, Clarke, Stants, Smurph, GAJ, Giles and Porps.
    The Bad
    The same as above team but add Cox and minus Brought-on-a-headache.
    The Down Right Disgusting
    Mummy and not knowing about him in time to use Giles 100, Ross Lyon
    Pending Trades
    Pfffff and Wondersoap for Malleria and Grassy Knoll.

    Multi-Bet.

    Layed out $40 on a 9 game option with only 7 to win and come in with 6 to miss out on the biscuits. Picked Carlton over 39.5, Dons under 39.5, WC over 39.5, Adelaide win, North over 39.5, Saints over 39.5. Pies screwed me by playing shitfull in the last as I had then for over 39.5 and missed Sydney and Cats for the win. Hawks and Pies…… I hate you. you robbed me of close to 3k.
    Oh well there is always next week.

    0

    0
  59. Hey fellas,

    I cannot believe i picked David Hale this year! Although he hasn’t started terribly, he is going to go down in price this week I think. Should i trade him now? Or wait to see him against lesser opposition?

    Trade- Thumbs up

    Hold- Thumbs down

    I could trade him for a Mid or a Forward.

    Thanks guys

    0

    0
  60. If I had to trade one of these blokes for Milera, which one would it be? Also taking into consideration whether they get named or not…

    Aaron Hall – Thumbs Up
    Tory Dickson – Thumbs Down
    Devon Smith – Comment

    0

    0
  61. Not sure about Milera actually – he has played 2 easy teams (no offence to Port and Suns supporters) so will he struggle against the good teams???

    0

    0
  62. Scored an average 1985 this week to go with my 1998 from last week.

    So many trades are sitting there wanting to be made.
    Broughton, Stevie J, Martin just to name a few.

    Decided to pull the trigger on (Reverse changes button coverage)
    Darley -> Demsey
    Mummy -> 211

    Not completely sold on the Mummy -> 211 trade as its a sideways premo trade but I am also worried about the back injury & can’t afford a week on week off playing from Mummy

    0

    0
  63. Average Score so far: 2,115
    Trades for R3: Higgins for Hawkins and Dickson for A.Kennedy (GWS) Leaves $368,600 in bank
    Trades for R4: Coniglio for Josh, P.Kennedy (SYD) leaves $0 in bank
    or
    Trades for R3: Higgins for Hawkins and Scotland for Dempsey leaves $674,300 in bank
    Trades for R4: Coniglio for M.Murphy, then leaves around $200k in bank
    —should i trade Scotland?
    HIT LIKE FOR 1ST PLAN, DISLIKE FOR 2ND PLAN

    0

    0
  64. why are people trading premiums after rnd 2?? u pick ur premiums, knowing at the end of the day they are goin to prob drop in value over the course of the season.. no point chasing last wks scores & no point trading out players u are likely to trade back in down the track..

    0

    0
  65. goddard deledio waters malceski bugg ellis golby smedts yagmoor
    pendles gazza murphy masten magner dangerfield smith and smith
    kruz giles oro redden
    franklin chapman goodes martin fyfe kennedy porps hlall tomlinson

    ranked 283. Bite me.

    0

    0
  66. 2242/GAJ

    The good – Godds,Dids,Watto,GAJ,Smurf,Lake, Giles,Morris ( on my bench)

    The bad – Broughton,C Smith,Martin,Heater

    Pleased with my rookies thus far. I feel I have all the decent ones going around so if I stick tight with Broughton it might be the first time in 3 years that I make no trades going into week 3…..

    I have a future trade in my mind – Coniglio to Old Mac…..Hopefully the two week buffer I have allows Coniglio to make some money and then I can actually downgrade him to old mac….\

    Not sure on Milera Is he worth it??? Perhaps Dickson ( who looked great for that little bit he did play) to Milera..maybe…Or perhaps Davis

    0

    0
  67. the trade i am tempted to make is Darley to Morris.. will most likely keep Broughton.. i made that decision, so i will live with it..

    0

    0
  68. trading mummy down to kruezer
    which gives me enough cash to upgrade the over priced for his average coniglio to either stanton (thumbs up) or j.p.Kennedy (thumbs down)

    0

    0
  69. ok…who do we feel will be the bigger cash cow out of these two

    thumbs up- d.sheil

    thumbs down – c.smith

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *