Trade Or Hold: Shannon Hurn

Written by Schwarzwalder on July 26 2019

We already had this poll up earlier in the week but that was assuming that Hurn would play against North on Saturday.

Hurn was a late out last week, isn’t playing this Saturday and must be some doubt to make the trip to Melbourne next week for the Carlton match.  That’s three games from the crucial last six weeks of SuperCoach.

There are currently 26% of teams that Hurn is occupying.  What would you recommend for his Coaches?

 

What to do with Shannon Hurn (WCE)?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
4
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

14 thoughts on “Trade Or Hold: Shannon Hurn”

  1. Depends on cover and how many trades you have left.

    Personally I’ve got Answerth and Logue as cover, but I’m trading as I also have 9 trades left.

    11

    1
  2. This is the big question for me. 5 trades left.

    TU – trade Hurn to Whitfield but left with no DEF cover
    TD – keep Hurn and bring in Silvagni as DEF cover

    26

    5
  3. TU:
    Trade Hurn
    Hurn / Lockhart to BSmith / Silvagni
    BSmith D6
    Silvagni D7 for future DEF/FWD cover

    TD:
    Keep Hurn
    OBaker / Lockhart to IHill / Silvagni
    IHill opens up FWD/MID swing
    Silvagni D7 and covers for Hurn this week

    1

    13
    1. Currently ranked 61 or so about 500 points behind 1st is there anyway I can make up the points to first ?

      I have hurn but no cover in defence albeit only 2 trades. Safe in the top 4 in my main league so what do I do community? Wanting to pull the trigger on hurn but also understand that injuries and only the one trade are a big concern..

      TU: Trade
      TD:Hold

      26

      4
  4. Only playing for leagues and ladder position is strong so I’m holding. But if he’s out again next week he’s gone. In the meantime who covers:
    TU: Quaynor
    TD: Answerth

    15

    7
    1. I’d go Answerth. RIC intense pressure tends to mean low scores to non-premo DEFs.
      Can you not loophole anyway with Quaynor playing tonight?!

      11

      0
      1. Good thinking, always the worry of another late out loopholing on a Friday night though..

        1

        0
  5. Community, Would you;

    TU: Trade Hurn to Lloyd and have Logue as F7.
    TD: Trade Logue to Ryan (keeping Hurn) and looping either of Sis/B.Smith/Ryan as F7 when Hurn returns.

    3

    10
  6. 6 trades remain 170k bank

    Option 1: TU
    Hurn -> Houli/Crisp
    ROB -> Grundy
    will miss getting whitfield

    Option 2: TD (can only do this providing burgess is named tonight)
    Setters-> Hill
    ROB -> Grundy
    Hurn to whitfield next week if need be but play burgess onfield this round
    but locked into top 4 most leagues

    6

    3
  7. 5 trades left.. 200k itb

    Def: Williams,Lloyd, Laird, Hurn, Sicily, Logue
    Answerth, Gardiner

    TU: Trade Hately>Hill/ Logue > Whitfield
    Hold Hurn

    TD: Trade Hurn> Whitfield/ Logue > LRyan
    Finish off defence Leaves 3 trades and one mid upgrade to full premo team

    1

    3
  8. Trading Hurn to Whitfield can’t trust Hurn being a old man with calf issues finals time leaves me with 2 trades and 150k banked

    0

    5
  9. I have a must win game in my primary league, three trades left, almost nothing in the bank and only Ellis for cover.

    Hurn to Whitfield it is.

    2

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *