Trade Talk R12

Written by Motts on June 12 2012

211 out for 10 so he’s gotta get the a55. Maybe you traded Dids in after a couple of good performances. Matty Priddis’ price just too tempting now he’s got the bye out the way?

Tell us all who’s in and who’s out this week for your boys.

0
0


Leave a comment / Scroll to bottom

231 thoughts on “Trade Talk R12”

  1. 7 trades left after these 2

    Coniglio > priddis

    Morris > sam shaw

    Thumbs up – good trades

    Thumbs down – wait another week on morris

    0

    0
  2. Any Geelong fans think Smedts can improve on his in one week (some being sub affected) & out the next week situation? He does look very much a fringe player that they will play against lesser teams when they are resting players.

    Only reason for asking is that although he has the bye this week & his scores have been ordinary, it is burning a trade for 60K & he could be handy for me to keep if i pick up Michael Johnson of Freo as another D / F DPP.

    Thumbs UP: People looking to keep Smedts due to the DPP reason
    Thumbs DOWN: He is gone, it is bye week & poor JS & scoring.

    Any comments would be greatly appreciated.

    0

    0
  3. Bugg -> Sam Shaw
    Sandilands -> Maric
    Coniglio -> Priddis

    Leaves me with 12 trades and $200,000 in the bank. Ablett will be returning into my team in a couple of weeks when he bottoms out.

    0

    0
  4. I will find a way to get priddis in. Too good to ignore.
    A bit off topic but is Hurn or Watters suspended this week? I seem to remember something going on about it at some stage. The bye weeks have got me in a bit of a tail spin and I have noooooo idea as to what is going on.

    0

    0
  5. All over it in my SCTTL team: Magner to Priddis (kapow!)

    Considering in mine:
    Shiel to Priddis, Guthrie to Wilkes/Sam Shaw

    0

    0
  6. Options to trade in Sam Shaw- for Smedts , Clarke or Dempsey.The latter will give me a load more cash but Smedts JS is suspect, leaning torwards that one.The biggy for me is whether i should be giving Stanton the Heave ho and trading in Priddis, almost a sideways trade but will make 100 k out of it and will enable me to get Jobe, Joelwood at a later date. Missed out on the Elliot trade, which shouldnt hurt too much as i think his days are numbered with Pendles coming back.

    0

    0
  7. Malceski to Hurn or Adcock

    Thumbs up-Hurn
    Thumbs down-Adcock

    9 trades left after this trade
    any other trade suggestions would be good

    0

    0
  8. Think I will be pulling the trigger three times this round.

    OUT: M Clarke, Horsely, Zaharakis
    IN: S Shaw, Priddis, Naitanui

    Obviously this is contingent on Shaw getting a game. He really only needs to play two games for me and I will be happy. Fingers crossed. At least this week I should only have one doughnut, not six!

    0

    0
  9. TU: Ellis -> Sam Shaw
    TD: Morris -> Sam Shaw

    I know Ellis has a low BE and could gain a but more cash than Morris (seems to have bottomed out).

    0

    0
  10. Time for Bower to go, considering Sam Shaw or Darley. Any ideas who has the better JS?
    Also time for Priddis to join the team, my options are either Horsley or Old Mac out, again I am considering future game time for these two as trades are getting low and whoever stays will be be my bench cover, any thoughts would be appreciated.

    0

    0
  11. Time for McIntosh to go – already have Cox, Redden & Stephenson. Was going to bring in Maric, but with him having the bye in Round 13, I’m considering NIc Nac – already had the bye, average 105.75 and $70k cheaper.

    Thumbs up : Maric
    Thumbs down : Nic Nac

    0

    0
  12. This is where i’m at. With $200k in the bank.

    Def: Deledio, Goddard, Broughton, Adcock, Clarke, Ellis, Shaw, Smedts and Spurr. (definitely my weakest line)

    Mids: Swan, Selwood, Boyd, Watson, Priddis, Hayes, Zorko, Miles.

    Rucks: Cox, Giles, Stephenson, Redden

    Fwds: Franklin, Pavlich, Dangerfield, Rioli, Chapman, Zaharakis, Cameron, Dickson & Pfeiffer.

    For this week i was considering:

    Zaharakis – Sidebottom (has a bye but so would essendon and i’m predicted to win all leagues)

    Clarke – Hurn or Birchall.

    Spare some thoughts.. defence is battling and i don’t have an good downgrade options this week with around 5 rookies sitting at 270k… and few good potentials that have played < 3 games.

    0

    0
  13. Just the one this week:
    OUT: Smedts
    IN: Shaw

    Couple more next week:
    OUT: Horsley, Porplyzia.
    IN: Crozier (On Pine) & Beams.

    Obviously didn’t see any point in getting a Docker & Pie in this week.

    0

    0
  14. I know might sound ridiculous but is anyone else considering waiting for Mumford to bottom out and trade him in for Sandi? or just too much of a risk?

    0

    0
  15. I have Ablett, Watson, Mitchell, Swan, Hayes, Horsely, McDonald, Pfeiffer as my midfield.
    Do I
    TU – Trade Horse for Priddis and worry later if I should get Pendles.
    TD – Hold the trade, get Pendles in when his back.

    0

    0
  16. have 12 trades remaining. should i make two trades and keep the remaining cash or just make one trade to save up trades for finals
    like – adam selwood and jason porplyzia for sam shaw and matt priddis
    dislike – jason porplyzia for matt priddis

    0

    0
  17. Using a fake name today to pronounce im down to 4 trades.
    Good team though. any tips??

    0

    0
  18. I will probably get a bit of crap for this but surely boomer harver is about to fire up? he plays gold coast this week. I am thinking zaharakis to harvey for a bit of money?
    T/U – take the risk he will fire up
    T/D- no his old body is about to fall to pieces.

    0

    0
  19. What are your thoughts on the following
    11 trades remaining, Bank $79800

    Round 12
    Marty Clarke to Drummond/Adcock
    Who do I get between these two. Please comment who

    Round 13
    Sandilands to Jarryd Roughead

    What are your thoughts?
    My Other rucks are Kruezer, Giles and Redden

    0

    0
  20. Some help please

    Need to get rid of McIntosh and Zaha

    other rucks are giles, redden, stephenson

    other forwards are martin, sidey, danger, cloke

    any suggestions, prefer someone who already has had bye

    0

    0
  21. Thoughts?

    I was thinking 3 trades this week:

    Horse to Priddis (WCE)
    Sandi to Phillips (GWS)
    Adam Kennedy to Scott Thompson (ADL)

    Means rucks i will be running Cox and Giles with Phillips and Redden bench. Reason for this is, if giles isn’t going to play then there is a fairly good chance that phillips would play.

    Or
    Horse Priddis
    Sandi Goldy
    Morris Shaw

    With the thought of going Thompson in a few weeks when his price drops.

    0

    0
  22. Im sick of Kruezer’s up and down scoring. I got him when Luenberger went down early in the season. I knew it was a risk, and im now seeing it as a failed risk. I think Goldstein as a real bargain price at the moment. Has a huge scoring ability whilst McIntosh is missing. Bit of a sideways trade i know but what are peoples thoughts on Kruezer -> Goldstein? Like a lot of people my ruck division lets me down. Currently Kruezer – Giles – Redden – Jenkins. I have 13 trades and $343k in the bank

    Thumbs up – U have to stick with Kruezer for the season now

    Thumbs down – Take a risk and get Goldy in

    0

    0
  23. no trades this week for me as i have saved the coin for the big 3 trades next week.
    bugg- broughton
    old mac – swan
    saad – chapman

    0

    0
  24. Horsley-Sam Shaw via Scotland to mids.

    Next week:

    Scotland-Swan.
    Tomlinson-M.Johnson
    Adam Kennedy-Downgrade.

    Thumbs up – good plan.
    Thumbs down- bad idea.

    Will only have a possible Tomlinson doughnut in defence this week, if all players expected to play do so. Already have Priddis.

    0

    0
  25. I think this is a little flawed, im ranked in top 3000 and coming 5th on league ladder when the winner of the league is ranked 160,000th. Do overall points count for nothing??

    0

    0
  26. Should i get rid of either….
    Billie Smedts (UP) OR Lee Spurr (Down)
    I will trade in Shaw from Adelaide
    Thanks!

    0

    0
  27. worth benching zaharkis for a few weeks?, thomson from adelaide gnna be a bargain ( i got cover aswell so no doughnuts)

    0

    0
  28. Went and put Dangerfield into midfield by trading Horsley to Patton and then Porplyzia to ROK.
    Midfield now sits: Ablett, Kennedy, Boyd, Dangerfield, Priddis, Dal Santo.

    0

    0
  29. Also, how many donuts are everyone looking at this week? – with no structure what so ever, I surprisingly will have a full team.
    Until someone withdraws late, gets the vest or injures themselves…

    0

    0
  30. Horse >> Priddis. Done.

    If Scotland plays, potentially no donuts this week!. ๐Ÿ˜€ ๐Ÿ˜€ ๐Ÿ˜€

    0

    0
  31. Not so much for this round but in general, which two would you prefer in your side:

    T/U – Priddis and Waters
    T/D – Watson and Adcock

    0

    0
  32. Does anyone know how many weeks Didak will miss?
    Seen a lot of articles about him not needing surgery but know where have I seen the amount of weeks he will miss. Anyone know?

    #cantbelieveitradedhiminthisweek

    0

    0
  33. Just letting everyone know that Im trading in Priddis this week so I GUARANTEE he will get injured this weekend!! ๐Ÿ™‚

    SO far…

    Mummy out Sandi in – next week gets injured
    Traded in Dempsey – next week hammy goes ping
    Carrazzo in – next week broken shoulder/collarbone
    Fyfe – had from start, another one goneski – season this time
    Ablett – had from start – held onto for a week then read he out for another 4-6weeks – trade out – he comes in next week
    Swan – Bring him in over Pendles – try to be smart and different as everyone has Pendles – he does hammy! (at least he back now and pendles out!)
    Goodes – had from start – does hip
    Sandi – had hung onto since bringing him in for Mummy early on. Got like 3 games outa him then finally now gone for 10
    Didak – brought in the Dids thinking best move ever – how could this go wrong! boom 1 kick later in the first 2 mins the collingwood sack pulls his tiny weeeeny peni, I mean groin.

    Im predicting Priddis will re injure himself within the first quarter. Just enough time to get 5-10 points and then be subbed out. Going down 50k in the process. AKA everyone above! I know im not the only one but fark it just keeps happening every week.

    0

    0
  34. Only have 9 trades left so is it worth doing the Morris > Shaw trade??

    Thumbs up: yes
    Thumbs down: no

    Thanks

    0

    0
  35. Smedts out…………..Shaw (Adel) in
    Magner out……………Priddis in

    This will leave me with 10 trades

    T/U…………..Good trades, go for it!
    T/D…………..Look elsewhere, that’s a waste!

    0

    0
  36. obviously time to bring in priddis, and i want some money out of a downgrade (sam shaw)
    Two options:
    T/U: Out – Horsley and Porplyzia. In – Priddis and Shaw.
    T/D: Out: Barlow and Porplyzia. In – Priddis and Shaw.
    (moving smedts fwd in both)
    By going with Barlow i can get 240k or so to eventually move shiel/treloar/horsley to ablett once he bottoms out (and they peak). However horsley seems to be done and barlow is still putting out consistently ok performances.
    Another thing to consider that i wasnt going to put up, but feels important here is that by doing this i am down to 6 trades. If i go with horsley rather than barlow, i then need to use another two trades minimum in order to fully upgrade (rookie+barlow both will need to go to get the cash for gary) whereas i could do a straight swap from rookie to ablett if i move barlow now but would then be keeping the horse for the rest of the season most likely.
    Please help me out with comments and ratings, a second opinion always helps alot.

    0

    0
  37. Really doubt that either Carrots of Scotland will play, but if the coach says so…..just gonna have to wait and see.
    Anyway: I’ll be looking to do
    T/U
    -Porps to Priddis
    -Malceski to S.Shaw
    Leaves 597k in bank
    R13
    -Dempsey to M.Johnson
    or be outrageous and do 3 trades this week and try save some doughnuts
    T/D
    -Porps to Priddis
    -Malceski to S.Shaw
    -Dempsey to Birchall
    Leaves 497k in bank

    0

    0
  38. What’s Lee Spurrs chance of getting a game?
    Thinking of either him, Tomlinson or Smedts making way for Shaw from Adelaide
    What do you reckon?
    Which one?

    0

    0
  39. James “I-tagged-Maxwell” MAGNER OUT and Matthew “Bargain” PRIDDIS IN
    Aaron “Ouch-I-stubbed-my-toe” SANDI OUT David “#1-Hawk-Ruck” HALE IN

    0

    0
  40. Thought I’d put it out there……there is an app/bookmark thing called “footynerd”
    which if you bookmark it, then click on it while on your SC team page it shows when each player is having the bye round while your selecting your team.
    It’s really usefull

    0

    0
  41. I can either get rid of Adam Kennedy or Coniglio.

    Coniglio ($352,200) has a BE of 73 with an average of 72. In his last 5 he is averaging 81 but taking out a shocker against the Dons he is averaging 92 in those 4.

    Kennedy ($230,600) has a BE of 43 with an average of 60. In his last 5 he is averaging 49 but taking out a shocker against the Dons he is averaging 57 in those 4. He is also struggling with a shoulder injury and/or getting selected.

    Who do I get rid of?

    Kennedy – Thumbs Up
    Coniglio (leaves me with an extra $121,600) – Thumbs Down

    0

    0
  42. Last week downgraded Giles to A.Pattison from hawthorn, then used the cash to bring in Cloke and Chappy. This has left my current rucks as:

    Kreuzer, Redden, Big O, Pattison

    They are in desperate need of help, and I don’t have enough cash to bring in Cox, Ryder, Nic Nat etc.ย 

    My Forward line is pretty much set, Midfield set, got a trade plan to fill my last 2 back line spots over the next few weeks. All that is left to focus on is the rucks.

    What are people’s thoughts on brining David Hale? Swing Pattison to F9, trade out a forward and bring in Hale, this would leave me with Mids, Forwards and Rucks all set. Hale and Pattisons Fwd/Ruck DPP means that I can swing hale in and out of the rucks if need be. ย He will be a bit of a POD as well I think, and with a BE of 30 it’s now or never.ย 

    Thumbs up- Sounds good benno, do itย 
    Thumbs down- Don’t do it.

    0

    0
  43. Hey guys, would love your help!
    Currently Have Sandilands, Giles, Stephenson and Redden
    Need to trade Sandilands for someone consistant,
    T/U – Nic Nat
    T/D – Wait a week or two for Cox to drop a little in price.
    Or comment for others…

    0

    0
  44. Need a little help. Should I pick up Hurn (475k) this round or wait until next round and pick up waters (530k).
    Thumbs Up: Hurn
    Thumbs Down: Waters

    0

    0
  45. Have Scotty Selwood who has been on a bit of a downward slide.. Priddis is such good value at the moment.. Have 11 trades left

    Thumbs up – jump on Priddis and make a little bit of cash
    Thumbs down – waste of a trade and stay strong with Scotty Selwood who will come good

    0

    0
  46. Here is a thought I just had for those who are planning these trades….(which I am )

    If you were thinking

    Horse to Priddis and Zaha to Sidey next week…..

    Try

    Zaha to Priddis this week and Horse to Sidey next week….

    You could save yourself a couple of donuts this week and should only lose a couple of dollars on Horse

    0

    0
  47. How many trades will everyone have after this week

    Thumbs up – 10 or more

    Thumbs down – 9 or less

    Feel free to coment the exact number I will have 7 most likely

    0

    0
  48. Will 6 trades left with a complete team be enough for after the bye rounds?

    Thumbs up- Yes- mos people will only have about that many

    Thumbs down- No- need more trades for the last 10 rounds!

    0

    0
  49. Does anybody have Sam Jacobs? What about Sandi > Jacobs? I know Jacobs has not set the world on first but the Crows have a nice draw and are flying. He did have a ripper run home last year, maybe he likes July and August. Thoughts?

    0

    0
  50. Who should I trade out for shaw?
    Thumbs up M. Clarke
    Thumbs down Bugg
    Clarke seems like the better option with the bye but is anyone considering Clarke as a potential keeper?

    0

    0
  51. I’m resigned to the fact that through a few poor decisions and a series of injuries i will not make it to a team full of premiums in 2012.

    Still going to keep plugging away and trying to get the best out of my team, but just know i can’t make it to 22 guns.

    0

    0
  52. What do you guys think of this as an option?????

    I can trade out Dempsey, Clarke and Horsley this week for Adcock, S.Shaw and Priddis. Next week will be Sandilands and Treloar out for Cox and Cloke.

    Then my side will look like this (with 7 trades left):

    DEF: Broughton, Lake, H.Shaw, Adcock, Delidio, Goddard, Bugg, (S.Shaw) & (Darley)
    MID: Mitchell, Boyd, Ablett, Watson, Pendlebury, Priddis, (McDonald) & (Zorko)
    RUCK: Cox, Giles, (Redden) & (Stephanson)
    FWD: Franklin, Dangerfield, Pavlich, S.Johnson, Martin, J.Lewis, T.Cloke, (A.Kennedy) & (T.Adams)

    0

    0
  53. OK This is preety complex so just say whether you like this or not, it involves 3 trades next week because of Sandi.
    1. Sell Sandi to M Johnson via Hale
    2. Sell Bugg to Forward Rookie via Johnson (Have a spare spot in forward bench so no dramas)
    3. Sell McDonald to Sidebottom via Adams
    Would fix 3 Areas with just 3 trades
    TU like
    TD just trade Sandi for Cox/Maric and forget about it

    0

    0
  54. Is it worthwhile going Horse-Swan this week despite Swan’s bye in order to safeguard against a potential Horse pricedrop if he plays?

    Will also need to downgrade Adam Kennedy at the same time. Mid/Fwd downgrade options?

    0

    0
  55. i did magner>priddis

    now thinking of getting shaw in for morris

    upgrading horse to mitchel

    keeping zah on bench till thompson drops like a beech then buying

    tu good idea
    td bad idea

    0

    0
  56. Looking to bring in a premium midfielder to finish off my midfield soon. Can’t go past Priddis at that price, but Thompson from Adelaide caught my eye with his low price and huge b/e. Who to trade in?
    Thumbs up: Priddis
    Thumbs down: Thompson (Crows)

    0

    0
  57. thaught about it again
    magner-priddis
    morris-shaw
    keeping zaharkis till thompson drops
    trading horse for a fwd/mid most likeley pavlich

    my mids will read abblett,boyd,del santo, prddis, thompson, mcdonald

    fowards will read sidebum,chapman,danger,martin,pavlich,treloar

    thoughts?

    0

    0
  58. Needd some ideas to trade in to avoid doughnuts as to stay in top eight. Traded out magner for gibson, hawkins for dangerman. Have tom couch covered in splinters and 260k. Have full mids & frwds,need 2 more backs & 7 trades after couchy goes. Need to win next two!

    0

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *